Theorycrafting an Eldritch Scion Magus/Dragon Disciple natural attack build

1E Player

First off, I know this is not the most optimal way to go dragon themed natural attacker with some spellcasting. I'm mostly just doing this for fun. Was scrolling through an old Max the Min, and someone half-jokingly suggested an all Dragon Disciple Party (Bloodrager, Sorcerer, Oracle, Magus). And, well... I wanna put it together, for fun.

Paizo only, with the exception of Elephant in the Room to add some spice, and since my tables all use it.

There's another post on this subreddit where someone suggests a DEX build for this (getting an agile AoMF to get dex to damage). I'm not married to this, but I figure it gives some fun variety if we make the Bloodrager of the group a big 2H Str build.

We'd like to get up to 2 claws and a bite as soon as we can. Draconic bloodline gives us 2 claws immediately. Then we can either start as something like Tiefling or Half-Orc to get a bite, ooor, we deal with it and wait for Dragon Disciple 2 to get one anyways. Feels a bit bad to give up one of the other juicy Tiefling features we could get, if we're getting a bit anyways, but I imagine that would depend on starting and ending level.

For my purposes I was looking at speccing out a Magus 5/DD 2.

Beyond that, I don't have much of a formal plan, just some miscellaneous thoughts...

  • Obviously being a Magus, we'd like to mix spells into our attack routine, I was thinking Chill Touch since it can apply to multiple natural attacks (I think, given multiple charges).

  • We can always use Spellstrike with natural weapons (and by always I mean when Mystic Focus is up...)

  • We can get Spell Combat to apply to our natural weapons if we take the Natural Spell Combat Magus Arcana. Ideally we'd take it twice so it can apply to Bite and Claw (and possibly a 3rd time if we get Powerful Wings later?). We'd have to burn at least 1 feat on Extra Arcana to get it twice, since we're not going past 5 in Magus.

  • Speaking of Powerful Wings, would a Tiefling's Vestigial Wings alternate racial trait allow that to work RAW? I'd probably allow it as a GM, but not sure about RAW. Worst case we wait until we get dragon wings much later. And then maybe take Extra Arcana again...?

  • We could dip Scaled Fist (unchained) Monk. This gets us CHA to AC if we don't wear armor. This could be good since we're not getting medium armor proficiency at 7. It also would allow us to take Dragon Style, and Dragon Ferocity on our claws, if we wanted. But it does delay us getting into DD until 7, OR 1 fewer Magus level. We'd lose a bonus feat, and our +2 arcane/eldritch pool.

  • For some of the same reasons listed above, we could also take Greensting Slayer Magus. Normally this would be awful, but since we're already not getting most of the things we give up...? Maybe fun to have some Sneak Attack die.

This is about the extent of my brainstorming so far. I'm not even positive if all that works RAW, as I alluded to. Curious to see what others can offer! Thanks for making it this far, if you did.

Posted Sep 13, 2022, 9:29 PM UTC

106
brokowski96•

It could be a fun, flavorful build that performs decently. Sadly, Magus is one of those classes that really benefits from minimal multiclassing, so it probably won't be as powerful as straight Magus.

2
lashielOP•

Oh for sure, I doubt this build will ever see the light of day, short of maybe convincing friends to do a silly one shot. But I thought it might be a fun theoretical exercise.

1

Greensting slayer's sneak attack costs a swift action and an arcane pool point to add a damage bonus to one attack, and must be done before the attack is rolled. It has no use case.

Light armor is probably better than Cha to AC unless you have astonishing stats. It might be different if mage armor was on the magus spell list but it isn't and it's not worth both a dip and a magus arcana/feat to get mage armor + Cha here IMO.

Vestigial wings might work, but with a BAB +8 prereq on powerful wings you don't lose much by waiting until you get wings from the PrC anyway. Level 14 instead of level 12.

You can deliver a touch attack with a natural attack without needing spellstrike at all. In any case spellstrike isn't limited by mystic focus, it's just spell combat that is.

For a bite you might look at a weretiger-kin skinwalker. It gets you a bite, but once you get one from the PrC you can stop using that bestial feature and get a 10' speed bonus or see in darkness instead. +2 Dex, +2 Cha, -2 Wis sounds good for this plan too.

2
lashielOP•

Great stuff here, thanks!

Greensting slayer's sneak attack costs a swift action and an arcane pool point to add a damage bonus to one attack, and must be done before the attack is rolled. It has no use case.

Good call here.

Light armor is probably better than Cha to AC unless you have astonishing stats. It might be different if mage armor was on the magus spell list but it isn't and it's not worth both a dip and a magus arcana/feat to get mage armor + Cha here IMO.

And here as well. Had already decided similarly. In my prospective build we only have 16 CHA before items, and even getting it up to 18, that's just not as good (and more expensive) than a +1 chain shirt.

I also did the math, and if we dump Int down to 8 to get 14 STR (12+2 from DD 2), and then waste 4k on a +2 belt, Dragon Style+Ferocity is maybe an extra 8 damage a round (if we're power attacking). Which isn't bad, but 2 feats, 4k, and giving up almost all of our skill points doesn't seem worth it.

It might be a higher consideration if we were already STR based, but even then, giving up another Magus level is rough, and the later we delay DD, the sillier this already silly build concept seems to become.

Vestigial wings might work, but with a BAB +8 prereq on powerful wings you don't lose much by waiting until you get wings from the PrC anyway. Level 14 instead of level 12.

We'd get BAB 11 at level 11 I think, which should let us take the feat then. But this is still a fair point.

You can deliver a touch attack with a natural attack without needing spellstrike at all. In any case spellstrike isn't limited by mystic focus, it's just spell combat that is.

There Hero Lab goes, lying to me again.

Do you think we ignore Spell Combat with this build, or is taking Natural Spell Combat worth it? We'd be doing Bite+Claw+Spell at level 7, vs Bite+Claw+Claw. If we wanted to use any metamagic on our say, Shocking Grasp, we'd need the feat that lets us keep it to a standard action as a Spontaneous Caster. We're also burning 2 (or 3, if wings later) feats to use all of our natural attacks with the spell.

We could also only grab Natural Spell Combat once, allowing say Claw+Spell, but then we're just starting to feel like a normal Magus flavorwise and worse mechanically.

For a bite you might look at a weretiger-kin skinwalker. It gets you a bite, but once you get one from the PrC you can stop using that bestial feature and get a 10' speed bonus or see in darkness instead. +2 Dex, +2 Cha, -2 Wis sounds good for this plan too.

I didn't know about this one! Thanks for the tip off. It could definitely fit, and has some cool flavor.

What Feats would be good for this character? I figure we're taking Extra Arcane Pool at least once just so as to be able to use our limited Eldritch Pool.

Extra Arcana once or twice to pick up Natural Spell Combat if we go that route.

EitR gives us free Weapon Finesse and Power Attack at least. Might be worth looking at STR regardless, since it would enable a couple things. Although I suppose we'd be trading defense for offense, and this character isn't the beefiest to begin with.

Thanks for your response, and sorry for my rambling reply. May as well have as much fun with this dumb idea as I can.

1

Spell combat's not just for shocking grasp. Shield or mirror image in a tight spot (possibly with fighting defensively also), bladed dash for almost-pounce, buffs in general. Natural spell combat might be better than you think with claws too - "For example, a magus could select this arcana twice, choosing claw attacks and bite attacks. This would allow him to use a full-round action to make all of his claw attacks with his free hand and all of his bite attacks in addition to casting a spell"

I probably wouldn't bother with metamagic at all on an eldritch scion.

Dex-based might very well make sense if you can get an agile AoMF early, possibly by making it yourself.

Feats and arcana might go something like this

1: extra arcane pool, 3: natural spell combat, extra arcana (NCS), 5: weapon focus (natural weapons), craft wondrous item, 7: dazzling display, 9: violent display, 11: shatter defences, 13: skill focus (fly), 15: powerful wings, 17: extra arcana (NCS)

If you don't want to pour your limited skill points into intimidate then maybe get favored prestige class, prestigious spellcaster, aerial roll (or a 2nd prestigious spellcaster) in place of the intimidate feats.

2
lashielOP•

I'm so bad at Pathfinder and reading. I totally misread NSC. I'm not even sure how, since I know how spell combat works normally...

Thanks so much, this is a huge help. Thanks for taking the time to help me with my little diversion.

1