Does any one else think that Garen could be decent with just a little rework?
Recently Riot keeps revisiting old champs and switching up their kits or tweaking them a little bit. I am just wondering if Garen is ever going to see one? I play him top lane and as a kill lane bot with an ADC just for fun sometimes and he seems to do decently well if played right. What do you guys think of him and his kit and what would you change?
Posted Aug 1, 2012, 11:34 PM UTC
He's decent, but really, his problem isn't that he's week, others are just stronger. Darius and Riven fill the same gap with more damage, versatility, or CC.
I think he would need a rework to be put ahead. His W is nice IMO, but his passive needs to be changed to something more agressive, and his Q needs something more, maybe a slow instead of a silence. His E is decent, but may need some scaling tweaks or another effect, and his ult just needs to be changed, Riven's is more effective, as is Darius'.
I agree Riven and Darius's ULTs are just better versions of Garen's. What would you change his passive too? He needs some sort of kit or damage rework because his late game is almost non existent. I run AD runes and tanky dps masteries on him and smash almost every other top lane with him from 1-6 or 7 it seems. After level 10 is where it seems like his problems start to show.
Ok, the two most popular bruisers are Jax and Malphite at the moment. What do they have in common?
Naturally tanky
Sustained damage
Can build offense and get defense, or vice versa
Garen can stomp, but really, he can go tank and do no damage, glass cannon and get wrecked, or hybrid and be a tier-3 bruiser.
If I reworked him:
This would give Garen tankiness, while still having damage. Ratios are up for debate, but it would be a smallish number, more useful in small trades until it gets ranked up. Once it is, it's a decent amout of armor/mr in teamfights.
This gives Garen a situational escape, a bit of CC, and a good bit of damage. Depending on scaling/ratio, an AS debuff may work too.
This gives Garen a way to trade early, and can help proc his passive if used right. Also acts as a good burst negator. Sheild wouldn't be very large, to compensate for passive, and woudnt scale well.
This gives Garen a decent AOE move, and helps his lategame. When his damage declines, he can still help the team, using his slow and armor reduction.
Gives Garen great teamfight annd supporty presence, while still keeping his sword-dropping execution awesomeness. To compensate, the delay will be quite large, maybe 1.5-2.25 seconds, depending on damage and buffs/debuffs
Even though its not finished you're right that's exactly where Garen's problem is. He's either just a damage soak with no scariness to make people not ignore him or he can do damage but gets shit on. I like your passive, it makes him not as passive as his current one where after trades you have to sit around and parade around the lane while you heal. On the Decisive Strike though why the mana cost refunded? You think they should change him to be a mana champ rather than manaless?
Yea, I think garen should have mana. With the kind of champ he is, mana less would be op. To push him outta lane, he needs a drawback like mana. Think about jax. His mana costs aren't crippling, but he has to be careful. I imagine garen like that. If he stayed manaless, he would need a very specific kit, its hard to balence manaless champs, especially bruisers (see Lee Sin and Shen).
Sorry about formating, im on my phone.
the silence on his Q is what makes garen so strong at early game in top lane, so i feel it would hurt him to change that.
Maybe, but without it, he has no CC. Its just my guess