r/chess•
Mutte23

Behavioral analyst goes over Hans Nieman's body language.

Miscellaneous

Posted Sep 22, 2022, 10:23 PM UTC

025
SolomonGilbert Beat the Eric Hansen bot once•

Body language analysis is known bullshit. It's NLP lite.

11
gobbedy•

not always, but this guy is definitely full of crap

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

9
Pera_Espinosa•

Given that it's all bullshit I'd say it doesn't make any difference. There is no way to tell from body language if someone is lying. There are several Youtubers that look at interrogation videos of people that have been convicted and declare that it's a tell any time they scratch their noses or cross their arms or whatever else.

When they don't know the outcome they say "this is a possible sign of deceit" and other non committal statements on possible signs. At most he'll say that this or that is suspect a bunch of times.

6
contantofaz•

The interview itself isn't bs though. It's a historic piece of evidence that can be revisited after new facts are revealed. It's like trying to catch Carlsen committing to saying something on camera that he could later on regret.

1
Pera_Espinosa•

Actually watching the video he does some good research and catches Hans lying more than once in the Sinquefield Cup Interview.

2
Choekaas•

I was also curious on that, since I am always a bit wary on self-proclaimed YouTube experts, but I saw that he has a link to his website where he says that he is on the Masters program in Forensic Psychology at Arizona State University. Although I would've preferred someone that had already graduated and worked in the field, at least he's someone that studies the field.

4
p1_tjc•

https://www.linkedin.com/in/derekvanschaik

Here's his LinkedIn with all his education listed. I don't know enough about any of those courses though to know just how much of an expert any of his schooling makes him.

1
Pera_Espinosa•

So while I think these body language "experts" are full of shit - this guy actually goes over Hans' interviews and finds inconsistencies in things he has said. So bullshit body language talk aside - he actually did some good detective work aside from that in catching Hans in some lies, particularly in the Interview he gave during the Sinquefield Cup.

6
BlaZ3UP•

that guy comes off very conceited.

6
p1_tjc•

Is it his body language?

7
BlaZ3UP•

LOL. he's the ultimate guru. #thefinalboss

3
PhantaumAss•

What a clickbait

5
Fredman1576•

Chess cheating or not, Hans seems to frequently have a problem with sticking to the truth - historically and present. Magnus on the other hand seems to prefer silence instead, if there nothing to say at the moment. Thats probably one reason why MC has much more respect in these matters.

5
Fop_Vndone•

This is nothing, I'm having a psychic astral project into the past to truly get to the bottom of this

4
neoquipover 9000+•

This is breathtakingly retarded

3
Ommmm22•

The body language expert has same energy as Hans.

They're both con artists.

3
Mr-X1•

His introduction and framing alone shows that he is a dishonest ***.

Edit: And he keeps going on and on with dishonest implications. Also, for a body language expert etc he sure does a very bad job at not looking like untrustworthy... whatever.

Edit: He also should stfu when it comes to accents. Typical monolingual bs stuff. Hans's retard bs about fluent English, bad English blbl also fits into that category.

Edit 2: The analyst is later right about needing social interactions to pick up an accent.

Edit 3: Holy amount of bad faith from both of them. Actually kind of entertaining.

1
Ok-Control-787•

"Turns out Hans is like a pretty weird dude."

2

Fuck everything about this thumbnail

2
gaspard_caderousse•

Seems to me that this guy has the body language of a 'Youtube hack'

2
Mutte23OPTeam Ding. •

First I want to point out this is not proof of Hans Nieman cheating, I just want to share for entertainment, and I think is interesting what a professional has to say about the body language of a professional chess player.

1
p1_tjc•

This is a great video. People will ignore it as nobody wants to talk about Hans interview anymore though.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
deepbluewaffle•

I guess this proves it. Bring out the gallows.

0
WilliamFairfax•

Behavior analysis does not work on chess players

0