Why do we (generally) love when stories come “full circle”?

Requesting articles/books/other media

Hello all,

I teach a college writing course, and when I teach students to write personal essays, I advise them to reincorporate an aspect from earlier in their essay into their conclusion.

For example, if a student brings up a metaphor/symbol (e.g. a rubik’s cube) early in their writing, I advise them to invoke it again in their conclusion.

I do this because I know from experience that we as humans love when stories come full circle. We also see this in comedy (particularly stand-up) when a comic will make an early joke, get some laughs, but later reincorporate the same joke into their act and get a significantly larger reaction.

I know this works, but I don’t know why this works.

Can anyone point me to where I could find more information on this subject?

Thank you!

Posted Sep 27, 2022, 5:52 PM UTC

479
majeric•

We like it when "we are in on it". It's a sense of being a part of the group. We are deeply deeply social animals. It's why children will watch a show over and over again because they like to be "in on the know."

23
EndokinetB.Sc. | Psychology•

I don't think that it has anything to do with the circle itself really. I believe that the most intriguing aspect of a story is a characters development. Going "full circle" is a story telling tool to remind the viewer/listener/reader/or even gamer where the main protagonist started, what their former situation and mentality was like and to establish the idea that they have grown in the process

10
JustAHomoSepian•

I would think this thread belongs to r/evolution more but anyway.

The BEST example of this I have seen is "Pulp Fiction".

Our brains LOVE mysteries or detection of patterns. Because our survival depended on it. That's why we are so good at recognising faces. But at heart of it, it's a "Aha!" moment with touch of dopamine.

So, when you complete the circle, you are getting little of that "happy" hormone :)

7
raisondecalcul•

This whole series (or this one-video version) explains a lot of related things. She would probably say that we are appreciating the theme when we enjoy a story returning to the start; we are recognizing a theme.

Also maybe check out Difference and Repetition, it is all about memory and development of things via repetition.

2
ThomasEdmund84•

I think stories function in the brain as guides in how to think and behave - so when a story comes full circle its a more complete and sensical lesson.

2
Shop_Environmental•

I've heard about how most of our life revolves around the balance between the familiar and the unknown. So for instance if a new trend in fashion evolves, and it has novelty but it's also familiar to something from the past, the success rate is high. So possibly, when your students refer to a concept from earlier in the essay, maybe it feels more personal and novel to the reader at the same time. Like it gives more life and meaning to the essay because something that they are now familiar to has been reintroduced in a new context. This is just what I feel.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
cryptographicbot•

One reason i can think of is karma is embedded into us through religion and movies

1
concreteutopianM.A Social Work/Psychology (spec. DBT)•

Why do we (generally) love when stories come “full circle”?

Are you sure we do generally or only people exposed to certain literary expectations? I'm not saying we don't, I'm just saying the premise isn't self-evident.

For example, if a student brings up a metaphor/symbol (e.g. a rubik’s cube) early in their writing, I advise them to invoke it again in their conclusion.

Case in point. You shaped writing to fit a literary expectation just as your writing was shaped. Other literatures around the world have different conventions and find different things significant.

when I teach students to write personal essays, I advise them to reincorporate an aspect from earlier in their essay into their conclusion.

Again.

I know this works, but I don’t know why this works.

My ex also knew that women love men with accents and brainstormed evolutionary reasons for such a love of the foreigner, ignoring both the widespread situations where attraction follows social norms rather than seeking novelty, and also embarrassingly ignored the fact that accents are functionally no different than speech impediments -a substitution of easier phonemes for more difficult native phonemes.

Look for evidence that this literary tradition is widespread before looking for something more than a sociological answer.

1