r/AskReddit•
IL05

Questions about gymnastics.

I have a couple questions for any gymnasts or anyone involved with gymnastics.

I've noticed that most gymnasts are really short. The males are mostly 5'5" and under and the females are generally 5'3" or shorter. Does gymnastics make people shorter? Does it stunt growth? Or are the taller people just weeded out of elite gymnastics?

Another thing I've been wondering is why the female gymnasts all have male coaches. How would a male coach be better at training/coaching them in events that they haven't done themselves?

Posted Aug 6, 2012, 7:40 AM UTC

08
JoshShouldBeWorking•

Former gymnast here:

  • Being shorter is an advantage on most events because of the lower center of gravity. Makes for faster flipping and twisting and easier to stick dismounts. Though for some of the swinging events a little height isn't bad.
  • Gymnastics is also hard on your joints and bones. Your joints get constantly compressed and many gymnasts can fracture growth plates. Usually you end up a few inches shorter than what you normally would be. Note: after quitting gymnastics I grew 2 inches that next year. 5' 4" to 5' 6"
  • Having done gymnastics won't automatically make you a better coach. I know some great gymnasts that are terrible coaches. I have found at the gyms I went to girls tend to respond better to a male coach than a female coach when it comes to tough instruction. I dont know if this is just a girl thing.
  • Also many of the developmental lower level coaches tend to be female coaches. Again in my experience younger girls tended to respond better to them than the male coaches, but thats just my observation.
2
IL05OP•

Thanks. These are the kind of answers I was looking for.

Do you think gymnastics ultimately affected your final height?

1
JoshShouldBeWorking•

Yes, I was always destined to be short. I had gone to doctors for growth plate fractures and was basically told I would be 2-3" taller had I quit when they first happened.

1
[deleted]•

taller people don't usually make it as good gymnasts, it's a short persons sport.

1
EdgeOfDreams•

I think short people make better gymnasts because they have an overall lower body weight, but can be almost as strong as someone taller (given the same overall body type and muscle build). So, (totally making up numbers here), a 5'5" guy might be 90% as heavy as the 6' guy, but 95% as strong, giving the shorter guy an edge in lifting/throwing/spinning himself.

1
doubleemmartin•

Being short and relatively compact is just a huge asset to the sport. Try and picture Usain Bolt doing a vault, and you'll see why -- at a certain point of height it would be almost impossible to rotate some of the tricks enough, and a lot of the sport is based on being able to lift and support your own body weight. That's easier to do when you're more compact.

1
thunderling•

Does playing basketball make someone tall?

0
IL05OP•

I was just thinking maybe the overstretching of your legs could hurt your growth.

Also, I think if you do play a ton of basketball while young, it could make you taller. It certainly won't beat genetics, but I think it could help stimulate growth.

0