Asking because I don't know, but do any non-US redditors dive? Is there a stigma in your country about this?

Posted Sep 30, 2022, 2:32 PM UTC

2420
Background-Pen7724•

It’s actually illegal in Japan, and people also HATE it when someone looks through their garbage. Some people(not even retail places) even destroy shirts and stuff when they put out household trash.

you can still find people digging trash bags in places but it’s really rare, because you can’t risk being seen by neighbours(social suicide) and also the risk of getting caught by police

I do sometimes bring bags with electronic devices homes tho.

I feel like people are more tolerant with smaller machines prob because they aren’t paying a lot for trash(you just need to get a special bag for them at the most) unlike furniture where you have to pay quite a lot to put in the curb AND also because you don’t wear them. (Don’t really know why but some people get creeped out when other people wears their discarded stuff. Probably because sometimes people have weird fetishes and you don’t know if one’s wearing your clothes for fetish which kinda feels stalker-vibes or just because they wanted to save them. Also probably why people are okay with thrift stores because the buyer probably won’t know that the clothes came from you so no stalker vibes. )

For retail, it depends on different cities, but most often they are locked inside the buildings so it’s not easy. And even if outside, since it’s illegal to take trash and the higher probability of cameras near retail curbs the “dumpster diving” attempts. I’ve heard of people digging for shoes in the center of Shibuya (they usually put trash bags outside their stores around there) though so there are people. It’s just not common.

EDIT Forgot to add that it’s really common for homeless people to “steal” the cans put out for recycling to bring it to the scrap yard. The stuff in recycling is technically the city’s property once it’s there so it’s a crime, but most of the time they aren’t caught.

17
steinvvord•

Very interesting to have this information from such culture, so different than mine. Thanks!

6
GoldaV123•

I am in British Columbia, Canada, and I definitely do it. I don’t start work until 4pm so I take my dog for long walks every day and I look in any dumpsters I see along the way. I don’t actually “dive”/jump in because I am holding my dog’s leash but I usually take a peek unless there are a lot of people around. I am still shy about it.

I also go to popular weekend hangouts on Monday morning and find what people have left behind. Most recently I took my dog to a local lake for a swim and I happened to see a huge box for an inflatable paddleboard at the dumpster. For whatever reason I checked the empty box and underneath a lot of packing material was a still factory wrapped/sealed Body Glove brand air pump. I was over the moon because my son started to paddleboard last summer and this pump was way nicer and bigger than what we have. I was thrilled with my find that day. Plus it would have ended up in a landfill which would be a shame.

12
psychocopter•

We've got a guy in our neighborhood that drives around the night before garbage pickup in the morning looking for anything to take. I dont think anyone minds because I'm getting rid of it anyway and they can make use out of it.

2
NoSuchKotH•

It's a lot less common because there are a lot fewer dumpsters. And what is in there is usually not usefful.

The US is quite unique in its throw-away culture. Anything that is not needed is thrown away. Combine that with the consume culture, and you get a lot of stuff that is not needed thus ends up on some pile.

Meanwhile, in Europe and east Asia, a lot less is bought. Most people tend to buy more deliberately, and mostly things they think they will use/need for some time. And stuff is usually not thrown away if it still works or is so old that there is no use for it. And even then, it's likely that the item will first go to friends and neighbors, who might have a need for it, before it is thrown away. Add to that, that especially in Europe a lot more gets recycled than in the US and throwing electronics of any kind into the trash is even forbidden.

Which means that there are fewer dumpsters with anything but household garbage, and thus it's not worth looking for anything, anyways.

11
maroooni•

Dumpsters at stores are often filled to the brim with food, what you wrote only applies to household dumpsters etc

6
NoSuchKotH•

Well, if a country has a proper social welfare system, then there is very little need to fish out potentially spoiled food from a dumpster because people still have enough money to buy food and pay rent. That's why you will not see any dumpster divers in other industrialized countries.

And in countries without proper social welfare, e.g. like eastern Europe or Middle East food is handed out to those in need directly by the store. I.e. people do are not forced to humiliate themselves by dumpsterdiving, but get it in directly from a human being. A human being who also ensures that the food they get is still safe to consume.

-1†
maroooni•

Huh? In countries like Germany and Austria there's lots of dumpster divers (except if you live on the countryside maybe, where everything that seems weird to conservative people is frowned upon). I know because i'm from there. And just because we have a proper welfare system we didn't eradicate poverty lol. Some cities have basically unaffordable rent prices, some people can't apply for benefits because of various reasons (citizenship/visa, homelessness, not having worked enough to get unemployment benefits, not fulfilling your Auflagen from Arbeitsamt/AMS, etc), the electricity and gas costy are rising rapidly, etc

The best thing was dumpster diving in Vienna back when basically everyone had this city key/post key that they got copies of at random lockmith shops, and so you could just go inside dumpster rooms from stores all over the city without having to climb over something or having to break a lock haha

5
NoSuchKotH•

Huh? In countries like Germany and Austria there's lots of dumpster divers (except if you live on the countryside maybe, where everything that seems weird to conservative people is frowned upon).

I don't know about Austria, but Germany is special. When Germany introduced Hartz IV, the rest of Europe collectively went "WTF? Why do they hate their poor so much? Do they really want to starve them to death??" Some commenters even asked whether that's a violation of human rights because of parts of it being pretty dehumanizing. So, no. I do not consider Germany as a country with a proper social welfare system. It might not be as bad as the US, but it pretty shitty.

And just as a disclaimer, I live in Germany. And I have not seen anyone dumpster diving so far. But I also live in the Alabama of Germany, so that might count as rural/conservative... maybe?

-1
Background-Pen7724•

We used to have a lot of dumpster diving homeless people for food around convenience stores in Japan before they started to lock them up to deter homeless people so it’s definitely not true that “you don’t see dumpsters divers in other industrialised countries because the y don’t need to”

It’s just hidden.

5
steinvvord•

I lived in Germany for a while and there was a shit ton of divers, way more than in my poor southern country, so i don't really know were your vision comes from, specially if you currently live there.

3
einat162•

And in countries without proper social welfare, e.g. like eastern Europeor Middle East food is handed out to those in need directly by thestore

What?

Name the countries out of these two regions that you know do this as a common cultural thing.

2
xtiaaneubaten•

Im a kiwi, I used to when I was a kid (early 20's) and poor, there was no stigma in our social scene (punk/goth/alt) but it was thought of as weird among normal people.

I dont dumpster dive for food anymore, but Ill still totally look at any skips I go past for anything useful. Looking in a skip people dont think so much of as strange I dont think.

11
maroooni•

Yeah, sure. Lots of people in europe do it in places where the supermarket trash cans are easily accessible.

At this point the stigma isn't so bad anymore and dumpster diving got more and more popular.

10
Liichei•

Person from Croatia here: dumpster diving in order to recover tossed plastic bottles or aluminum cans (which can be returned at any supermarket to get 0.50 HRK - ~0.07 € bottle deposit back) is a common thing amongst poorer people here.

Other than that, it is quite rare, AFAIK, but you can still, on occasion, find some good things, especially considering that, in the true Balkan tradition, a lot of stuff that you have to arrange transport to the dump for, people still, occasionally, just dump next to the dumpsters (or somewhere out of town, but that is a whole other can of worms).

7
steinvvord•

I'm from southern europe, and i dive everyday. There is A LOOOT of stigma here. Even the poor or the "behind the doors poor" act all like "im way superior because i dont do that". General population also dont engage, which for me is amazing so i have less competition.

I see some increased perception with the young lads that i tell my stories to. They act suspicious at first, then with time they see the sheer quantity of cool things i find and they think is good overall, but none of them do it regardless. Also lot of older people tell me they see very good stuff but dont do it out of shame.

Do be fair, some of people tell me "yeah my sofa is from the trash" or "my cousin got this tv from the trash and gave it to me" but those are exceptions, they dont dive per se. Its just out of coincidence and circunstance one day in a year.

Things are changing now though, and fast!

7
gr4v3robber•

I do it in Canada, most dumpsters are locked up and you can’t get in but there’s a lot of people who do it here despite the stigma towards it and the locks.

5

Brazilian here. There is A LOOT of stigma when it comes to diving. I had friends from college calling me rolling stone and hobbos, and most people in general tend to always assume the worst of you and evoid talking to you thinking you'll rob them or worse.

Most of my house stuff like mirrors, kitchen sink, bedframe and even table where found in the trash. I honestly don't know why people just throw away stuff that can still be used and are in perfect condition.

4
Voltfan•

Yeah I am French There is a lot of stigma because gypsies do it too to scrap metals and they open all the garbage bags, break the appliances and ceramic toilets and sinks just for the faucet and they make a mess on the sidewalks. But usually when you explain people that you will not do a mess and you will donate the majority of the items they are usually very nice

2
putadeplaya•

There are no places to do it here.

1

I live in Jamaica where there are many poor people. Some people live on and eat from the site of the biggest landfill. I don't know if large supermarkets are dived here. I doubt it though. Food waste is considered a huge no-no. and these places are also policed by armed security guards. People are literally starving. so I doubt food is ever thrown away.

1