Tattoo question!

Hello! I have a question regarding a tattoo I am hoping to get, and I have looked through a fair share of threads about tattoos and unfortunately not found an answer yet (though I have learned a lot of other stuff!). For context, I am not Jewish.

I recently saw someone ask their family members to draw stars in order to get a "night sky" tattoo, and found the idea very cute! I have asked some of my family to draw me some stars, and my grandparents drew ones with six points, essentially the star of David.

I felt that it would be good to ask people who actually are Jewish what their opinion on the tattoo would be, rather than my parents, lol.

The tattoo would have no color (it wouldn't have had anyway, but it feels relevant to point out) and the stars would be two of ca 9, if not more. Well, three depending on how my other grandmother draws stars, I suppose.

If it is slightly tasteless, but not too bad, would it help to angle it slightly (so that two points are facing up/down rather than one)? If not I'll ask them to change it, of course! The main reason I'm asking rather than telling them to change it immediately is that I would like it to be their first drawing, since it's so personal.

Sorry if the post is longer than necessary, and thanks for any answers! 🥰

Posted Oct 6, 2022, 10:22 PM UTC

112
ummmbaconSpace Laser Reserves•

my grandparents drew ones with six points, essentially the star of David.

The association with Judaism is new-ish (depending on how you want to define it) and the six-pointed star has been used in other cultures as well.

Thanks for asking but it is fine.

10
HelloThisIsFrodeOP•

Okay, good to know! My mum and I looked into it, but were a bit confused and we figured that it's better to be safe than sorry 😊 since there are some associations i want to be sure ^-^

3
DosTristesTigresSephardi•

To add to what others have said, I would recommend you to at least consider that whether you intend for it or not, if it is visible, it may lead to people assuming you are Jewish, along with all which that entails

9
HelloThisIsFrodeOP•

Hm, that's a part of it i hadn't really considered. Thank you for your input 😊

3
chabadgirl770Chabad•

Not a problem

6
HelloThisIsFrodeOP•

Okay, thanks for the feedback!

2

You should be totally fine.

I appreciate you caring how we felt.

5
HelloThisIsFrodeOP•

Thabk you for the input! I appreciate it 😊

1
Neenknits•

That doesn’t sound like the tattoo will “read” as Jewish. Although, seeing the design would make it easier to judge, it sounds ok.

3
HelloThisIsFrodeOP•

If I had the design finished I'd show it! Unfortunately it's very much in it's early stages, my grandparents were top priority since grandpa is terminally ill 😓 i did make a very rough sketch, though. The idea is that when my siblings and I eventually have children more stars will be added, too.

2
Neenknits•

Oh, that is absolutely fine. No one will question anything about the 6 pointed ones. They are just stars, one of a gajillion ways of drawing stars! You get full points for sensitivity, but no, you are good! I sincerely doubt anyone will wonder or associate it with Judaism in any way. It reads as the star field you wanted. Enjoy the tattoo, and I’m glad you got your grandpa’s in time!

7
HelloThisIsFrodeOP•

Thank you so much for the response 😊 I'm hoping that in time there will be even more design variations, as I get more people that can add stars!

1