What are your thoughts on Deep Madness?

Question

How does it compare to Nemesis or Cthulhu Death May Die? Is it a need to own if you have games like that already?

Posted Oct 13, 2022, 4:33 AM UTC

179
robaanrobioConcordia•

Same as the other commenter, I've not played the games you mention, but I have played Deep Madness. I used to own it, backed the last Kickstarter, but I have since sold it.
As mentioned, the setup and teardown is a chore, but that is fine with me if I have the time for it, or I can leave it on the table to play again. What killed it for us was that it's extremely hard, and that at the start of the game you can see the puzzle that needs to be solved, so the first 10-20 minutes of the game is an optimizing math game of what character does what and when. Then you start the game and it starts throwing bad guys at you. You can easily see the point where you know it's impossible to win, and it's frankly quite discouraging. I don't mind losing, it's not that, it's when you have half the game left and you know it's over, that's no fun. It would be better if it would be closer to the last turn, a win or lose situation.
While also being hard, the upkeep with tokens, movement, air, special rules for each monster, madness and all other stuff made it feel like a job and the fun-return was not enough.
But this is their third Kickstarter, so I guess other people like it. :)

9
elberoftorou•

I don't know those games, so I can't speak to them.

I've enjoyed the games I've played, but the 30-min setup time & 20-min teardown time makes it hard to recommend casually. It's definitely an Event game.

4

I like the idea of Deep Madness, but the rules as written are a bit too punishing and/or finicky. Whenever I play I tend to house-rule some things to make it a bit more manageable, it's been awhile since I've played a game, so I may be misremembering some things.

  • There's a token that you're supposed to play on each and every room on the board and each one of those has a different icon/effect on them, I tend to play without those to simplify the game, otherwise you spend alot of time doing maintenance to track that stuff, and to me it doesn't add that much and just creates more complexity/difficulty than is needed. I think I've just gone with a universal effect rather than every room having a different effect.
  • The rule is that if a single investigator dies, you fail the scenario. I find that rule to be kind of ridiculously punishing and house-rule it such that all investigators have to "die" to lose the scenario, the others just get "knocked out" or something. The only reason I can think of for the original rule is so that the narrative parts of the story make sense, since they have specific characters with dialogue in the story parts, so I think they just added that rule to keep from having narrative "plot holes" where an investigator dies in game, but then does something in the story.

It is a bit of a slog though, even with these house-rules, the game is still quite hard, probably harder than it should be. The aesthetics and the miniatures are all nice though.

3
lunatic4ever•

I stayed away from it because lots of people complained about the difficulty and it looks like all fixes are just outside of the game variants and house rules. I was hoping the new KS would seize the opportunity to redesign the game and embed these options in the game but it looks like it’s mostly a lazy reprint so I won’t back it again and that‘s probably the end of that

3
MomoGamez•

The teach and setup is too much for the fun had.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Ju1ss1•

I have the game and I don't really think the setup is a chore. Especially if you ignore the madness tokens you should add to the tiles, the game is plenty hard already without those.
The game itself is a horror themed Zombicide, but much better. There missions are more varied, the monsters are more varied, the activation order is much better, and the game is deeper in mechanisms.
But that also means that the game takes quite a lot of time, and do remember that the game is really hard! The first scenario is something I have never won, but it seems to be more difficult than some of the others.

1

I think they even specifically created another intro scenario after the game released that's supposed to be a bit less punishing than the original first scenario.

1
Dice_and_DragonsDescent•

I have played Deep Madness and it ranks at the bottom of my gameplay experiences for the type of game it is. Setup is long and the play time is long. As others have said it’s hard and not always in the fun and challenging way. In fact our first game we may have one but a few rules got messed up and everyone was just glad it was over no one wanted to walk back the game.

Death May Die is probably the best coop game in our collection and everyone they had played it so far with me has loved it highly recommend

1