[Goodberry] I feel like we use "play calling" as a catch-all for coaching things we disagree with.
Posted Oct 13, 2022, 4:05 PM UTC
Posted Oct 13, 2022, 4:05 PM UTC
I feel like fans, including me, are people with little to no understanding of pro football that are fed constantly that players provide a certain value that is reliable.
This combined with the fact that our understanding that good playcalls are the ones that work and bad playcalls are the ones that don't combined with the celebrity worship we give to star players or even just players we like narrows a lot of our criticism to coaching.
The NFL is a razor-thin margin league. Renfrow sees Adams is open, slows his pace on the route, Raiders win in KC and are 2-3. Instead he ran into Adams and they're 1-4. To an even more extreme, we've lost three games on the very last plays of the game.
The difference between good teams and bad teams is incredibly thin and execution in critical moments is usually the deciding factor. There's a reason NFL coaching has ridiculously high turnover. There's a reason NFL front offices have ridiculously high turnover. Chaos for three hours and whoever gets the most points at the end of it more often than not keeps their job and the other gets fired.
The people paid to know how to identify and quantify what's good for a team and what's bad for a team don't really even know. And yet as fans, we insist that we do.
Last year, this was a very, very similar team and we executed and made huge plays in critical moments and Cincy was electric with love for everyone. So far, we haven't been as good in those moments and with higher expectations, fans are frothing at the mouth.
But that's the nature of this league. Nobody really knows shit, the best of the best have awful days and the worst of the worst have great days and fans only care about winning.
Basically all opinions on the matter are just us being upset our team is losing and trying to Skip Bayless our way to sounding like we know what the hell we're talking about when we obviously don't because no one really does. Fucking Troy Polamalu believed God told him when and what to do in basically all his career. Yet Dick Lebeau, a guy who flamed out here and other places is a genius because of those teams and the plays he made.
Much like humans and essentially anything in reality, we experience mostly pure chaos and notice half assed patterns and retroactively use them to try to apply order to it all. If they're useful patterns, they work until they don't and the person using them is a genius until he's not. And as spectators we have the luxury of only working in hindsight and no one ever testing our amazing ideas.
Exactly right. Thank you for articulating it so well. I’m personally not stressed about 2-3 as I’ve seen the talent on this team, seconds away from a SB win, and I’ve seen the coaching staff consistently be willing to adjust and it has played out well for the team. Winning fixes everything, and as you said the margin is razor thin, especially in our case as we are 3 FG outcomes away from an undefeated season.
especially in our case as we are 3 FG outcomes away from an undefeated season.
But that’s the point. We’re talented enough to win but seem to always make bad decisions and have to rely on 2nd half D being lockdown to have a chance to win.
Agreed, and it’s much easier for coaching to make changes than to upgrade talent. In fact we are already seeing that to some degree, for example less conservative playcalling and more power run since the zone blocking scheme wasn’t working.
In the Marvin Lewis days we would be stuck with guys like Carman starting because of investment over talent and stubbornly sticking with schemes and plays that don’t work.
It’s unpopular to say right now but maybe give the coaching staff time to figure it out before calling for the heads of the guys who just brought us our first playoff wins this side of the millennium and even made it to the last few plays of the SB. It’s all still there no reason these guys can’t be a little better, which would be enough to win these close games. If we start getting blown out or doing the same shit every week I’ll be right there on the fire Zac train but I watched this same narrative play out at the beginning of last year and the same crowd were eating their words at the end of the year. Now a couple close losses, better blow it all up, dejavú.
Thing is the barrier to being a player is merit based whereas being hired as a coach in the nfl seems to be based on nepotism the vast majority of the time. So I think fans are skeptical that coaches aren’t making good decisions.
There are so many decisions that coaches make that are obviously incorrect to even casual fans. So while I am sure coaches know much more about some of the aspects of the game I don’t understand, the fact that they are bad at easy decisions leads me to believe they are bad at those too.
Coaches also have an incentive to not get fired that doesn’t always align with winning. For example making safe traditional decisions will get a coach less criticism than riskier but better decisions.
It also seem that coaches tend to favor a strategy that loses more but keeps the game close which I suspect they feel makes them look better.
[removed]
You nailed it. Absolutely
Yeah but we still voluntarily ran 12 yards backwards on 2nd & goal with 2 yards to go. There's being armchair playcallers, and then there's knowing that 1) running backwards is usually bad, particularly on the goal line, and 2) the QB sneak is the most successful play in football.
I don't think anything excuses Taylor for calling a play where we lose 12 yards on the goal line.
Tyler Boyd is the one that ran backwards and didn’t throw the ball away.
The same play has resulted in quite a few touchdowns.
Maybe Boyd should've thrown it away rather than running backward 12 yards.
No matter what we think of the playcall, there's literally no part of that play that calls for running backward 12 yards and eating the ball as you get hit.
Goodberry can be such a ballwasher sometimes.
He can have it his way, I guess I’ll just start saying “I disagree with the coaching things that are making this team bad”
Sometimes him and those in his Twitterverse do get a little contrarian to the fanbase for the sake of appearing unbiased, despite them thinking the same thing as most of the fans.
I’ve never liked him. He’s always come off as a know it all dick and a contrarian just for the sake of it, as if he’s more enlightened than the average football fan, which I’ve never found him to be whatsoever. I blocked him on Twitter long ago because I got too tired of his edgy takes and douchey responses to people. The guy is no expert and people shouldn’t listen to him
I responded to one of his tweets poking fun at him like two years ago and was instantly blocked
You and the rest of these Joe Goodberry Haters clearly haven’t met the dude. I had the pleasure of meeting him and his brother and sister in law before last years Thursday Night game at a bengals media meet and greet. Super nice guy. Don’t always agree with his takes but I’m not on here trying to be an internet tough guy talking shit about a guy who in his free time tries to cover the bengals.
Lmao calling him out for acting like an asshole isn’t “being an internet tough guy” 😂😂 I love how that’s always the generic answer people use when someone calls out someone they like because they just want to defend and pretend like all criticism is invalid. Calling him out for acting like a dick doesn’t mean I’m an internet tough guy. Maybe he is a nice guy, but then maybe he should realize that not everyone is going to meet him in person and that if he doesn’t want to be perceived as an asshole then he shouldn’t present himself in that way on social media when that’s the only impression most people get of him. He constantly responds to people asking basic harmless questions like a douchebag. If he doesn’t like that some people think of him that way, then he should present himself differently because that’s often the only interaction people are going to have with him
If he doesn’t like that some people think of him that way, then he should present himself differently because that’s often the only interaction people are going to have with him
Coffin nails! BAM BAM BAM
Agreed his analysis of games isn’t really that in depth yet he acts like he’s some football savant
This is the goal. I'm not making content for football experts. If I did that, nobody would read/watch/listen. 90% of football fans are casual fans. Maybe 40% of them want to know just a LITTLE more about the game. All I do is try to aim a microscope at interesting things and discuss them. I've never tried to come off as "all-knowing" or a "football savant". I just acted like myself and wanted to talk football.
Exactly lmao I think people just started to listen to what he said due to the lack of that sort of Bengals coverage. Why wouldn’t he be working for PFF or some place similar if he actually knew what he was talking about? He’s a clown
Is PFF some place that's hiring and paying VERY well? Let me know. Otherwise, I can't take most jobs in sports. I have a family and they come first. Thanks for looking out though.
I've long had this opinion of him. He doesn't take to criticism or alternative points of view at all. I still follow him, because I like to see multiple takes or opinions to meld with my own, the Athletic writers, Rapien, Egger, Conway and others. I just don't bow down to worship him like thousands of his followers do.
And if he's so damn football smart, get a coaching job with a high school or small college. Become a grad assistant, something. Instead he sits back and critiques from his couch.
And that goes for most of these “analysts” on Twitter. I’ll keep names to myself but a lot of them who act like they know a lot, in reality don’t know nearly as much as they think they do. Always fun when former players dispute their “analysis”
I'll tell you right now, I don't know shit. But I'm open to learning.
Name them!
[deleted]
Yeah excuse me if I disagree with looking off your hot rb on the goaline, running cute gadget plays (even ones the other team runs all the time and easily identify), and leaving points on the field in several games. How dare I expect better from an nfl coach
Loved when I DMed him that Hendrickson was putting up similar numbers (according to PFF) as Lawson and he disagreed with it….guess who was better 😂
He’s right. They don’t beat cover 2 because they don’t have plays to beat it.
What if…
Now hear me out.
We steal other teams’ plays!
Maybe the problem is ZT is watching Thursday Night Football.
[deleted]
Eh, I think, after 4 new Linemen (with the interior playing very well). And with the best 3 WR set in the league, an upgrade at TE, and a Top 10 QB, personnel should be the last excuse for this team.
[deleted]
Burrow is actually slightly below average in percentage of drop backs under pressure.
I disagree with the line playing well
We are at the very bottom of the league in pressure rate over the last 3 weeks
Nope. That isn’t it.
[deleted]
[deleted]
Are you high lol
[deleted]
Trash take. Bengals can beat cover two shells as long as the coaches give them what they need
For those that missed the point of my tweets, it was an effort to clarify what we're talking about as a community. When I'm trying to have a conversation about "play calling" with somebody but they actually mean a decision to go for it on 4th down, that's not beneficial to a healthy conversation. So, I wanted to clarify what each issue with the offense is. That way we can dissect it, have a discussion and look for improvements as the season goes.
Happy cake day, Joe! Big fan on Twitter.
Thank you!
While technically correct, to the average fan you're just arguing semantics.
Philly Special on 3rd and goal?
How is that NOT the playcalling?
It was 2nd and goal because we lost 15 yards on it and then Chase pass to the 1 then shuffle pass.
his point is there are many other problems with the offense other than those 2 horrible calls on the goal line that fans lump in with play calling as well
Play call - "Field Goal Attempt from 2 yard Line"
Also Play call - "Shuffle Pass from 2 yard line"
That pretty much sums up my issue. What "analytics" could you possibly be using to convince you to not take points, especially when your success rate of converting on 4th is in the bottom 5 of the NFL.
I mean this says going for it makes it more likely that we win the game. If we score a TD there I think we win, field goal we still likely lose. I’m fine with the decision, just hate the playcall.
Exactly. If we tie the game there, Harbaugh goes for the touchdown on the next drive.
The worst thing about analytics is when coaches forget that their decisions drive analytics.
Hard miss by Goodberry.
Outside of playcalling and using certain personnel in certain situations, I don't really have any qualms with Zac Taylor the HC.
I think his point is we blame ZT's play-calling for BC's play design as well
Not necessarily. A play can have a good design, but terrible execution.
A lot of the time I feel Ike the design is terrible, and the playcall given the situation is terrible, so it kind of sets the execution up to fail
We just need to be more creative all around the board and not take unnecessary risks. Also we need to actually gameplan for the start of the game because more often than not we're playing from behind.
have you seen Ja'Marr's route tree compared to others? That is not calling that is design. If we had the plays in there they would get called at some point
I'm not disagreeing with you lol it's just that even considering play design, we put ourselves in dumb positions with playcalling.
Ex: not running the ball once in the red zone when we were tied with Baltimore even though the run game was working at that point, and passing all 4 downs instead of kicking a field goal to take the lead.
Don’t tell him that or you’ll get blocked
I mostly agree with him here. Against Baltimore I thought the calls were fine outside of that awful goal line sequence. It was mostly players not executing correctly. I have a bigger issue with the scheme overall than the plays being called.
That's where I am. Play calling is not as bad as some are acting. It's a combination of play design, play calling (play timing), and scheme (strategy).
He’s right. People say the play calling has been terrible, but what they really mean is that the play calling AND the play design have been terrible.
[removed]
Maybe it’s the trajectory of the season so far influencing my attitude but I am becoming increasingly annoyed with Bengals media personalities
I'm tired of this guy's takes. He just criricizes anyone who thinks the coaches are responsible for the team - cuz yanno, why would anyone believe that? - and tries to find excuses for Taylor.
What's his suggestion to improve the team? Prayer?
I like Joe but I feel like he missed the mark on this one. Of course we understand that there is a difference between play calling and play design, scheming concepts, and decision-making. But at the end of the day, those are all coaching responsibilities and fans expect to see the latter come through with the former. To a fan, colloquially they kind of all mean the same thing. What we're really saying is "start putting players in better positions to succeed"
Just because we say play calling doesn't mean we're stupid enough to not understand that there's more to it.
but that's his point. He doesn't want a catch-all term for everything. He wants to have a deeper conversation
Then have a deeper conversation with people that are capable of it. Don't clown the average fan that uses semi-incorrect terminology but has the same thoughts and desires as you.
Maybe it isn't the play call, it's the play design that's poor. Who gives a fuck? Design a good play and call that. Call good, well-designed plays. That's all any of us want. We don't have much insight into what plays are in the playbook and how they were designed, we just know the ones that get called and those outcomes. They've been shitty.
This whole tweet sequence by him comes off as "look how smart I am" and it's bordering on obnoxious. We know that the scheme needs a tweak, but you call plays within the framework of a scheme. Can't have one without the other. So, colloquially, they're the same thing.
The average fan wants to blame Zac for everything though. Play design is more Brian Callahan. He is making the point because so many people want Zac to give up play calling when that likely is not the biggest issue with the offense right now
This is a baseless assumption. To act like the one who calls the majority of the plays has no input in their design is ridiculous and I don't believe it for a single second.
Another total assumption that is predicated on your initial assumption. At this point it is just as likely that Zac both designs and calls shitty plays as it is that Brian designs shitty plays for Zac to call. Not that it would ever be that black and white, anyway, but either way the onus for either situation is on ZAC
If it’s not the biggest, it’s certainly up at the top. But to his point, sure, play design sucks too. Who cares if you call it design or play calling, it sucks.
Well yeah, you usually blame the guy in charge when things aren't working. That's the burden of being in charge. The world isn't suddenly going to treat the guy in charge differently because somebody else also has skin in the game.
I agree with you and him both. We, as fans on reddit or other sports messaging boards, more than likely do understand the distinction. However, I think there are a good amount of much more casual fans out there that do not.
Sure, but to what extent does that distinction even matter? Like if a casual fan says "coach is bad at playcalling", and actually it's schemes that are bad, what real difference does it make (outside of the coaching staff themselves)? Just seems like a weird point to make (and also false given the specific plays people called out last game)
I've noticed he's being a bit of a ZT ass-kisser right now. I don't know what's in it for him but he seems desperate to tell fans they're wrong for noticing that Zac's maybe not always the best coach.
Okay, so all the Zac apologists and hardcore Goodberry followers got ahold of my comment. Interesting that none of them have anything to counter with though. We all know this a correct observation.