r/ACL•
ASDF123vr

Why do we believe some studies but not others?

Genuinely curious.

I know I rub some of you on here the the wrong way. I think where a lot of that comes from is people have strong opinions and if a view opposes that, people don’t like it. In general this sub has strong feelings on exactly how acl recovery should be and truly black and white views. Each acl is it’s own journey but not when it comes to things like when to do certain activities. In that case, most believe it is the same for all.

At the end of the day, I don’t believe in any of these studies people like to post over and over or quote. You can find a study that would support any argument with acl recovery (it is honestly crazy). I’m about do prove that again haha

What I did for my recovery was to focus on finding the best surgeon and PT possible and listening to their advice 100%. I don’t debate with them. I chose them for a reason and their track record that I asked about before using them.

Many here post black and white views on everything from graft to return to sports. (I am sure I have done this myself early on) Like their information is fact and can’t be debated. We don’t know these people. Don’t tell someone you know best based on a study. My favorite is when someone is running and cutting and people try to tell them you shouldn’t be doing that. Then the posters says they were cleared and we still tell them it is a bad idea.

We should be encouraging people to seek quality medical support and not to read a study. Their are more positive stories with acl than negative and each personal IS different. Not to mention research does always change with medical and what we once thought to be try can change many years later. We may find out retears have nothing to do with biology of graft healing and maybe it is something as simple as a certain vitamin deficiency. Or we may come to a conclusion that it is all related and correlated to amount of times the acl recovered person engages in high risk activity.

Point is the medical community does not have consensus and things are not black and white. So why do we choose to believe some research so strongly and assume we know so much that any study or surgeon that opposes that view is crazy. Again, not saying I have not done this myself at times.l but why are we not open to alternative views?

I know this was already a long post. Thanks for reading and hopeful some of you will be willing to read these studies linked and say why or why not you believe rather than just downvoting because you don’t like what it says.

Very new study - Risks odds of retear (notice return to sport)

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40279-022-01747-3

Older study but highly controlled with single surgeons data

https://moscow.sci-hub.se/2761/e453ad5e691a5bd642d60b02d7890945/shelbourne2009.pdf?download=true

Posted Oct 18, 2022, 4:59 PM UTC

34
Just-Judge-1142•

When I look for research paper and studies, I sort by most recent, since that gives the technology and techniques are most relevant to the present. If you look at studies of long-term outcomes, remember that the surgery was maybe not what you had! Also, it takes time to analyze the data, so add 1 to 2 years even on to that. I am a research tech, so I know that setting up a human subjects study is actually quite complicated, and getting enough consented qualified subjects to reach statistical significance is often an issue. A lot of the literature has either low sample numbers, or is a review of several studies. Combining studies means the surgeon, technology, and rehab are different. If you really want to predict your individual outcome, your surgeon's and PT's experience is more relevant anyway.

3
ASDF123vrOP•

Agree and good approach.

I agree on those vast sample pulls. The irony is those are most quoted. It is why I found the most recent study interesting. It is another vast sample pool but says different than other recent studies with similar data set.

It is also why I like the other study. While it is older, it is one surgeons data, one graft type etc. still chance for issues but at less some consistency. Then with newer tech, should only improve - in theory

The data is all over the place, agree, that is why I chose to ignore it the further I got into rehab and just listen to my PT and surgeon

Think it is good to be open too

1
Johnny_Oats•

One important note about the first study is that it's looking at odds of graft rupture while the second is looking at repeat ACL injury (either leg).

Activity level and RTS time are highly confounded variables so studies that make no attempt to separate them will always incorrectly conclude waiting to RTS is better, and even any attempt to correctly separate them will be prone to error and unknown variables (i.e. risk aversion).

I think you just need to take every study as a data point. Things that show up across every study are likely to have a cause, things that oscillate between studies may just be more complicated than we understand.

2
ASDF123vrOP•

Your call out on activity level and RTS stats/debate. As I said, I mainly just followed my PT and surgeon and gave up on trying to find the right data. However, at this point, I am genuinely interested in it.

You have always been fact based and level headed poster on here. Hoping you can help me square something in my head.

So… your call out on that seems obvious to me. I have seen that in the data and felt that was obvious for some time now.

How are these researchers not seeing those 2 variables as an issue and the need to dig deeper. Not to mention differences in graft, rehab adherence etc is never noted. It is almost like they play with the data to get the outcome they want for their conclusion.

I keep telling myself there is something I have to be missing. Maybe people just trust things at face value and mainly read the headlines? That can’t be the case for so many in the PT community (which seem much more vocal about graft rupture rates than surgeons). Maybe they want people in PT longer? (I partially kid)

Which leads me to my favorite study. Like… how is this not almost willfully a click bate headline?

“Young Athletes Who Return to Sport Before 9 Months After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction Have a Rate of New Injury 7 Times That of Those Who Delay Return”

Then… when you dig deeper

First - there is a built in hazard ratio due to activity level they will likely go back to, which they start off by saying right away.

“Athletes with a higher preinjury Tegner Activity Scale score had a higher rate of second ACL injury (hazard ratio = 2.1; 95% confidence interval: 1.2, 3.6; P<.01).”

Then way further down.

“When data from athletes, irrespective of whether they had performed the tests of muscle function, were analyzed (n = 264; 20 new ACL injuries), athletes who returned to knee-strenuous sport earlier than 9 months after ACL reconstruction had an approximately 3-fold higher rate of new ACL injury compared with those who returned at 9 months or later (HR = 2.7; 95% CI: 1.1, 6.7; P = .027). There was no relationship between time to return to sport and new ACL injury when we excluded the 10% of events with the strongest influence on the analysis.”

So, there is a built in hazard ration due to high activity. 2.1. Then you get to the root data of the wider data set which says the hazed ratio is 2.7 for earlier than 9 months. This is already in the margin of error and basically saying the high activity level is the issue and not RTS time.

Then the last statement says if you throw out the top and bottom 10% it is no difference. Been awhile since I was in stats etc but in general throwing out the outliers is usually sound.

Talk about making the data say what you want it to. Heck, maybe that is what I am doing haha

People throw that headline around everywhere. I have read PTs quote it like crazy. What am I missing?

Directionally, even if you account for the extra exposure, I am sure there is some added risk with early rts but man.. the numbers that get thrown around are made to sound huge and it seems very small when you dig.

Tell me how I am the crazy one haha. Thanks in advance

1