Getting better at Combat.

Howdy y'all. I'm pretty new to TW and constantly find myself doing worse than the auto resolve. I've turned Close Victory into Defeat sometimes.

What advice would you give to getting better in combat? I don't want to always click auto resolve.

Thanks.

Posted Oct 19, 2022, 3:55 PM UTC

3663
SgtWaffleSound•

Just practice. Use slow mo and try not to have any idle units. Hammer and anvil tactics, use cavalry to go after ranged, use heroes to snipe high value targets. It takes a bit of time to remember what unit types are good against others but you'll learn as you practice.

29
Agrafo•

Tar pitting with tank characters/summons and rain artillery/ranged on them works for me too. Low/none friendly fire and more dmg to enemy unit.

Focusing pistols/good accuracy ranged on large entities. Expecially the ones that's reck formations fast

Corner camping and boxing are good nobish tattics for defence factions. Rush factions usually just bait and kill the fast flanking units with mobile heroes or cav until the AI start charging forward. Then it's brace with spears and folding or assisting with dmg dealers/monstrous inf, or just counter charge with rush factions.

Having monstrous infantry in the middle of regular infantry it's better for both.

Thats what I being doing too since I tend to forget units or I'm slow with micro. Hate need to keep spamming move to retreat locked units. Corrections are accepted.

Edit :chevrons and check board formations are great and easy too

3
L192837465•

Repeat battles over and over to your hearts content. Takes almost no load time and will drastically help as you try new tactics with units against a familiar enemy, then you can apply those tactics to other races/battles

21
Tactif00l•

Before you go into a battle take a look at your army and the enemy army. Look what is the biggest threat in the enemy army and think how you can deal with that. Do they have lot of ranged? Use Cav, mortars or other fast unit.

Also what helped me a lot is countering the faction you are going against. You gotta plan ahead like chess. If you are going to war with bretonnia you don't want an army full of archer. You want a lot of spears and maybe monster Units. You are facing high elves? Then get a lot of Cav, flying or artillery in your army. This makes it way easier.

Tldr plan ahead an make a strat

14
GuzzlesOP•

Bah, learning.

Lol I'll take this into mind.

Thanks!

6
Tactif00l•

:D If you don't wanna learn, play ikit claw and spam nukes xD

7
GuzzlesOP•

Lol those words mean nothing to me yet but I'm interested to find out. Skaven is my want to play race

3
JoeyJoeJoeRM•

I'm playing Deathnaster Snikth (clan eshin) ATM - pretty much my first hard campaign with hard battle difficulty. Gutter runners and stuff that are fast and can fire while moving are so pesky... Use them to harass and lure units where you want them to go... Lots of units with stalk are great for springing ambushes... It's made me feel like a better player 😊

1
Burntoutaspie•

Dont start with skaven! Low leadership is so hard on micro early on! I would start Vampire Counts, no guns, powerful wizard lords that doesnt get sniped easy.

But dwarves or Khorne also has aspects that make them easier.

1
sintos-compa•

100% you gotta know the AI game or those nukes will be wasted

1
Tactif00l•

Lol just throw some clanrats at them to hold them in place and blow them up too skaven don't care

1
3xstatechamp•

Unless you’re CoC and have to just take what units you can get in early campaign lol.

1
Anthrillien•

No shame in this OP, and credit to you for wanting to get better rather than just throwing in the towel. Each faction has a (or a few) unique way(s) of playing, and it's not always entirely obvious how one should be doing things.

At the most basic, you need a frontline. It's good to have some ranged presence and some fast presence. But absolutely key to this is the frontline. I have a friend who is not amazing at Total War and I think that a lot of the problem could be solved if he just build an army comp with a more boring composition. It's not important to go for whatever the "meta" is against AI, but for what works for you, so I don't know how useful a lot of YouTube content will be given that they're usually very focussed on being at the cutting edge.

For example when I'm playing the Empire I like to focus on Artillery and Handgunners with a frontline mostly just focussed on holding them in place. Allies can be useful to get more durable units sometimes (Dwarfs, for example). When I play the High Elves, I like to focus on a strong long-ranged presence that's able to creep forward or back to obliterate whatever is trying to approach, more like a Soviet Artillery steamroller than lithe and graceful warriors! But when I play Vampire Counts I just like to have a solid line of Grave Guard and a few monsters to wipe everything out through sheer brute force.

None of these are particularly complex because I'm not all that good at micro-level army or unit management. Just find what you like doing and stick to it. Then, you can branch out from there. It's a strategy game, but the battles are fairly simple themselves once you get the basics down.

A final note: there are some factions that play very strangely that are somewhat unlike the normal Total War games. Some of the Chaos factions, for example, play very strangely so don't worry if you don't understand what the hell is going on.

10
GuzzlesOP•

Thanks!

Yeah it's an odd game to jump into. I really really wanna play Skaven, but I just don't grasp a lot of the mechanics. Probably because they're the strange ones lol.

The advice here has been really helpful because it's all echoing the same thing of learn the units and less "odd"diversity. I think I need to scrap some of my off hand units and just focus on some basics.

My experience with elves was interesting because I kinda "got" their gameplay intrinsically, but stretching out has been eye opening lol.

Anyways thanks for the info. Gonna just...do it lol.

2
NoGoodIDNames•

Ikit Claw is the best Skaven lord to start out with (and the most fun overall), you get great ranged units, a capital that almost never gets attacked, and even nukes to bail you out in a pinch.
You can establish a strong region and focus on exploring the mechanics from there.
If you can grab his DLC on sale, I highly recommend it. The units it adds to the Skaven roster are so good it’s honestly hard to play them without it.

2
JoeyJoeJoeRM•

Yeah Skaven have a tricky campaign when you start out as a new player.. you kind of need to think like a Skaven lol. You need to break the assumption that the more settlements you have the better. Get your starting region complete and then go for under empires until you have 2 decent armies.. you can sack settlements you have established under empires in for gold and xp (and stop the AI mustering to retaliate)

1
Zjwei•

2 things I focus on most of the time is making sure I have a strong Ranged setup with a decent enough Frontline to hold the enemy away from those Ranged. Any time the Ranged are not firing is time wasted not doing damage. Make sure to keep an eye on enemy flanking strats and react appropriately, in an ideal scenario you'll hold the flanks while creating a gap in their Frontline to take advantage of. What also helps a lot is turning off Skirmish Mode for your Ranged Units. This setting is on by default and makes Ranged run away if enemies get too close. Handy for units that can fire whilst moving, not useful for static Ranged. All you need to do is set up the Ranged with your Melee Frontline right behind them, when your enemy gets close move the Frontline forward through the Ranged. Guard Mode is optional for Melee, but I find it helps too. (Guard Mode means your units won't chase routing enemies in Battle which if turned off could expose holes in your Frontline for your enemy to push through and reach your Ranged.) Lotta text, I know. But these are some things I find help very well fighting Battles yourself.

3
Nohmerci•

I also struggled a great deal when I 1st started playing these games and this is what work for me. I am by no means an amazing player, but I feel like I hold my own at least against the AI.. Most of the time.

I highly recommend seeking out YouTube videos, there are many many hours of content on tactics for the Total War Warhammer games, And the cool thing is that a lot of the tactics will carry over from game to game; you can look at warhammer 2 Video and it will likely still apply. Tactics like flanking, hammer and anvil, and unit formations are good for pretty much any game of this type.

After you watched some of the basics on unit tactics, maybe look up some strategies on how to use the units in your preferred army. Again there is a wealth of information on YouTube Breaking down the pros and cons of each unit for every faction.

After your research just save a battle before playing it in it, and then play it and replay it and replay it. Even if you win go back and play the battle again to see how you could have done things differently.

Also, there is no shame in turning down the difficulty while you're learning. Even easy on these games can be fairly punishing until you get the hang of it.

2
GuzzlesOP•

Do you know any good videos to start with?

Hammer and Anvil I get, just haven't been able to pull it off. I try and use my calvary for that, but yeah range seems like a good idea.

1
Shifty76•

Zerkovich has great video guides on his youtube channel.

Don't be afraid to abuse the pause button during combat. Pause, issue your orders, then unpause.

4
DrBombay3030•

Just here to support the Zerk recommendation. His beginner battle guide videos are 1000x more helpful than the game "tutorial". Explains both tactics and controls in a super easy to digest format

3
Typhoon556•

He made my life so much easier when I started TWW. I had never really played these types of games before, and he made it to where I could enjoy the hell out of the immersion into the game, by helping me understand and employ the mechanics that make up the game.

3
Typhoon556•

Zerkovich has some really good videos. He has some videos that helped me out quite a bit when I was feeling overwhelmed at the start of my TWW experience, after not really being someone who enjoyed these types of games before. One massive difference for me, in dealing with cavalry, was learning how to cycle charge my cavalry to make them so much more effective. It sounds so dumb, but just pressing the J key, reverses the direction of a unit, and you can more easily prepare them for another charge. It made life so much easier for me when I realized I could move that unit more easily into and out of combat.

2
ironmaiden617•

Make use of pause button too. I frequently check the space bar for enemy range vs my own position and ranged units (it’s all about the cones!)

2
GuzzlesOP•

Lol I can't believe I didn't even think of this. It's so obvious.

Thanks!

3
ironmaiden617•

Cheers mate. Have fun!

2
x2x7xx•

Learn what counters what and focus the things you want to bring down. For example, sending a dragon into fight infantry is okay but the one of the best uses is to disrupt and deter archers while supporting your frontline with the breath attack whenever it is ready.

Try to find favorable matchups like anti infantry vs infantry, anti large vs large, etc. A lot of this comes from just playing the game and figuring out what works and what doesn’t.

2
sintos-compa•

Pause pause pause

Learn what the AI likes to do, they have a lot of “gotcha” things, like they are really good at finding weak spots in your lines to send flankers in and wreck your archers or casters.

They use their archers to snipe (focus fire) your lord so keep tabs on what they’re targeting.

2
GuzzlesOP•

!!!!!!

WHAT

omg thank you. I fuckin always wondered why my boy dropped so quick.

1
sintos-compa•

Yeah sometimes it gets super dumb if you have squishy heroes or lords they can’t get into firing range of enemy archers (press space to see their red firing arcs).

1
ParadoxandRiddles•

What factions are you playing with?

1
GuzzlesOP•

I did a campaign in TW2 with the high elves and did pretty good.

I'm doing an Empire campaign right now with the starting guy.

My economy is fine, I'm not "losing". If I auto resolve I do fine lol.

1
ParadoxandRiddles•

I build armies around tactics. I like tarpitting then using ranged and magic to wreck my opponents. I don't end up doing a lot of cavalry, usually just have them counter cavalry or fast attackers on my flanks.

It's a basic approach but too much micro always gets me in trouble.

1
GuzzlesOP•

Hmmm cool I'll try this out.

My army def has no "tactic".

1
velotro1•

dont blame yourself, there is some battles that are VERY hard to win even on normal and sometimes the game just give you a better auto-resolve.

for an exemple, grom the pounch x helmgart fort. that motherf*** just killed FIVE regiments of empire halberdiers before i managed to kill him. he had something like 300 kills before he routed. while if i auto resolved it. he would have been wiped half a stack loss on my fort.

1
Special-Estimate-165•

I wish I could give you advice but empire is one of the few races I don't play and every faction has their own tactics that work best for them.

1
GuzzlesOP•

It's all good my friend. I'll probably be back one day and you'll come in clutch then.

1
Special-Estimate-165•

Absolutely. If you ever want tips on Skaven, Brittonia or Vampire Counts; I'm your man. :)

1
Affectionate-Car-145•

Watch some guides.

Watch a good player do the first 10 moves of the campaign you're stuck on.

Watch some Tier lists for the faction you want to play as.

Lean into your factions strengths.

And be patient.

I was doing hard/hard on my first TW campaign as Cathay.

I switched to Ogres and got fucking wrecked instantly trying to play the same way. It felt like I had to learn the whole game all over again.. but that is why TW is so great.

1
SkavenManThingYes•

Learn formations. Formations can turn a decisive defeat to a heroic victory with the right units

This is super helpful https://imgur.io/a/NnQdt

1
GuzzlesOP•

This was extremely helpful

1
DathekOmegas•

Kill artillery with fast units or flyers

Spearmen in your flanks to take cavalry charges

When possible, get flank or rear charges

Distract the enemy

The game itself is super simple strategy wisez you just have to learn how to maximize units.

Ie anti large vs cav and monsters, shoot flyers down

Use heroes to neuter mages

1
DathekOmegas•

Also if you are having issues winning and want to play Skaven, play ikit claw and do a gun line

Rating guns, jezzails, warp lightning hiding behind slaves or clanrats, super easy wins

1
Typhoon556•

My most enjoyable campaign to date was doing multiplayer with my best friend while we both played Skaven, me playing Ikit. That campaign felt like it was on easy mode, and MASSIVELY enjoyable, compared to any other campaign. Ikit is warpstone powered fun.

1
TehOuchies•

Pause, Pause Pause.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
sojiblitz•

Read unit cards, compare stats. Categorise units e.g. shock infantry Vs holding infantry. Anti large cav Vs light shock cav. Figure out the fighting style of your chosen faction. Examples

Dwarfs - highly defensive infantry, can hold a long time, good artillery to deal damage and decent missiles, no cav for chasing down routed.

High elves - good defensive infantry to hold, excellent archers and magic to deal damage. Solid cav and dragons, weakness - expensive so vulnerable to flanking.

Try to create mismatches on your opponent's line. i.e send your high AP MA infantry to crunch through high value high armoured units. Does a cav unit have high charge bonus but low MA, cycle charge them. Does your enemy like to blob, use breath attacks and magic. Does a unit have expert charge defence, don't counter charge them.

Hope this helps, you'll learn as you go

1
MechaWASP•

A thing that helped me a lot was just focusing on making sure my units were all doing something. After the lines meet and I move any oddball units (monsters, steam tanks, targeting artillery on Archers while cav heads around the fight) I always check to make sure everyone is busy.

For harder fights, I just play in slow motion and do the same. Try it sometime, play in slow mo and watch a replay, makes you feel like a micro god. Lol

But yeah, basic, sensible armies are good. Don't necessarily need to spring for crazy expensive units either. For empire, I really like keeping a strong core of spears, crossbows and artillery, with a handful of special units for handling whatever I intend for them to fight. Keeps costs down, and you can still have some specialization to keep it fresh.

1