she looks like sammy and sammy looks good

Pretty much every one of her lines was funny to me

Not so much.

She shows a lot of determination by swimming back to the island, which isn't an easy feat.

We'll, she swam all the way from playa de losers (or at least, i asume they we're send there) to Pahkitew.

Thats some Big determination, and stamina.

Sad that all of that is focused on making Sammy life hell on earth.

She is good...

















At being the most hated character in Total Drama history.

https://www.fanfiction.net/s/14096032/1/Total-Drama-Action-Complicated-Chaos

I enjoy writing her as a villain in my fanfic I am doing

I feel like she'd be like Lightning. Antagonistic and athletic but not really "the main villain"

If she got to be on the show without Sammy, do you think it would have worked? Since even if she did shit talk Sammy, they'd only have her words to go off and wouldn't even know Sammy to really care about her

I don't know about that. She's manipulative sure but that kind of depends on her team being too stupid to realize her blatant mistreatment of Sammy, and she's much more focused on subjugating her sister than dominating the competition. Not that she can't be tweaked or motivated to be a villain, she just has a slightly uphill battle even if her determination is impressive. I don't think she's on Jo's level

She has great antagonist potential, on par with Jo in my eyes.

She's funny and "oh my gag" has found its way into the lexicon of several people I know. She also has a ridiculous amount of determination and her athletic skill is impressive

Her twin sister Sammy, who she calls Samey.

She can keep up with Sonic the Hedgehog, no wait, that’s a different Amy… meh, I don’t like that Amy either

Her determination to make Sammy's life a living hell, despite not having a real explanation behind it, is on another level. She may be an awful person, but she's an awful person who doesn't stop until she gets what she wants, which is an interesting trait to have. 

I still have no idea how she had the willpower and the strength to not only find the island after being eliminated, but swim all the way back just to get revenge against Sammy. That's impressive. Unrealistic, but impressive nonetheless.

As much as I don't really like her as of now, I still think she has the main antagonist potential

She has potential and a few funny lines. She can easily grow into more fully fleshed character.

She’s funny and pretty and smart and good at ballet and didn’t cheat did I mention she’s pretty?

I really like her! I think her exaggerated attitude and mannerisms are hilarious, and even though the show did not give us a reason why she hates Sammy, it's not hard to come up with one yourself, and I pretty much try to understand every character so I didn't have a problem with it. 

Admittedly, she's not a very effective villain, as she pretty much only succeeded a little bit because PI's characters weren't focused on the game enough to pay attention to other people, but in my opinion that's fine, not every character needs to be assigned a clear-cut role, and I'm okay with her not focusing in the competition and just trying to one-up Sammy. Not only that makes her unique in her motivations, but also makes her kind of sympathetic in my eyes, since being better than her sister is that important to her, I think she wants to be popular, but might actually feel bad or insecure deep down and be compensating for it by abusing her sister, or maybe she's jealous of her in some way... Of cour

She was a character, we know that

Her lines while mostly being childish do at least give her a little more personality and a mystery of her backstory

She could be so much better but hey there is that tiny decimal of effort so kudis

this is gonna be hard

edit: actually nvm i take that back

say one positive statement/opinion about: amy!