Stand alone or built into the wall?

Hi all, I am going to be turning the third bay of our garage into a workshop, and my plan is workbenches along the walls. Do you recommend building stand alone benches to place along the wall, or the built in style, mounted to the wall?

Posted Oct 21, 2022, 6:54 PM UTC

3722
OleCuss•

My preference would be stand-alone and on casters. This gives you lots of flexibility if you decide you want to try doing things differently than originally planned.

Others seem to go built-in.

31
jubjubjubify•

I agree with this. I work out of a two car garage and have ended up rearranging several times before I’ve really found positions for my tools that I’ve stuck with. It’s also been nice to wheel my benches out when necessary. You could always go this route initially and if you find you are very happy with the placement you can modify/replace with built-ins in the future.

8
notshiftycow•

another upvote for casters. I have 4 benches on casters, and have changed layouts many times. Currently, I have a couple against the wall, and will probably move them again.

I do recommend leveling casters, instead of just wheels. I have both, and a very sloped floor. If you are not going to move often, you will appreciate a level surface.

3
pug_nuts•

Standalone placed against the wall. You can always lag it to the wall if you don't want it to move, and it can be moved easily if desired.

9
hlvd•

Stand alone every time

8
rccola712•

this is the (only) way

3
Anbucleric•

Do you ever plan on moving and wanting to take them with you?

5
Vlad_the_Homeowner•

Both! But only if you have the space.

I have shallow (~20") benches on one wall, with pegboard behind it for hand tools. It's standalone, but I have it firmly secured to the wall since I don't move it and I keep a vice, drill press and a place to hammer on it. In the middle of the room I have a large bench on casters that has my table saw, router, miter, etc. It mostly stays put but if I'm ripping a long piece or working on something odd shaped I can move the bench around to fit my needs.

Both have their uses.

4

Depends on the work you would like to do really, I use a stand-alone bench for woodworking, but for something like electronics or maybe mechanical work a built in table wood be fine.

4
Big_Distance_4376•

One advantage of being built into the wall is that if you ever drop something, it will be much easier to retrieve.

3
localfartcrafter•

Depends on what you're using it to hold. Big things? I like a bench I can walk around. Small? Against the wall with small parts and tools against the wall.

2
AdaminCalgary•

Mine is built to be stand alone, in case I ever want to move it, but is bolted to the wall because I dont have enough space to move it out. One big advantage of attached is that I can put something in the attached vise and reef in it when needed. If the bench was free standing it would move and I couldn’t get the torque needed to free a rusted bolt. Of course freestanding gives better access. It’s a trade off… like leaving enough space for my wife to park her car in my workshop.

2
freddymerckx•

Both. Make a locking mechanism that will anchor onto the wall, and can also be moved around to accommodate project requirments

2
CryptoFuturo•

Have any examples of the locking mechanism? Much appreciated!

1

I have a small 2 car garage shop. I don’t do as much furniture builds or “fun” projects as I’d like (or what I initially set it up to do). I’m a residential finish carpenter by trade and my shop has turned out to be mostly used for doing mill work, occasional built ins/one off cabinets and just odds and ends for weird trim/railing details or the like that are just easier to do in the shop than on site. Those are the jobs I get paid for so it’s great but also not what I intended my home shop to be used for. Long story long, I’ve found that in a small shop area, versatility and adaptability are crucial! I’ve converted all my benches/work areas to being on casters, wether they’re usually against a wall or sitting in the middle of the shop, being able to move them around to accommodate what I’m doing is huge. Just recently put mobile bases on all of my heavier equipment so I can freely and easily move them around. It’s been huge for both my production in the shop and ease of working in there. Not sure what you plan to do in your shop but I’d make at least one bench on casters that you can move. It’s really nice to be able to walk around a work bench for some projects.

2
puddinface808•

I would say standalone on casters, with latches on the underside to secure it to the wall. Sometimes that extra stability helps if you're really going to town on something, but it's really nice to take away from the wall, and even take outside. If you bring home some heavy sheets of ply or something it's nice to roll the bench out to the truck and then park it right up next to the table saw and start breaking it down without ever picking it up.

It's also nice to roll the bench outside on a nice day for some sanding and whatnot.

1
GregTheWoodworker•

Both, but because you make two benches that are appropriate for the work you do. I have a shorter one that is free standing that I use for traditional woodworking with hand tools, and another taller one that I use for other stuff with a miter saw integrated.

1
LifeFiasco•

Standalone. Ease of rearrangement, access, repair, and it doesn’t transmit extra sound into the adjoining wall.

There only a handful of positives of having a fixed bench. Most are entirely outweighed by the versatility of a floating bench.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Akeatsue79•

Ooh, third bay. Must be nice

1
ohimnotarealdoctor•

Stand alone. In my experience of fitting out workshops, work vans, etc - do things as simple as possible. Fast, cheap, replaceable, modular. Knock it up, see how it goes. Adapt.

1
3grg•

There are advantages to both and it is a matter of personal preference.

I had to share my garage with my car (especially in winter) so I built a bench that is attached to the wall and drops down. It started as a sheet of plywood and evolved into a legless Nicholson. It is great of for hand planing because it never moves. :)

https://imgur.com/a/FuArcDH

I bought a HF bench and found it to be next to useless except the top could set on some saw horses and serve as an assembly table. The legs and drawers got repurposed.

https://imgur.com/a/uJGLipg

I now have a space where my Nicholson bench (Naked Woodworker) can set in the middle of the room with the old hf top against the wall as assembly table/ horizontal surface. I like being able to get to all sides of the bench and it has a leg vise, too.

1
LexicalAnalysis•

Space definitely matters as well as size of the workbench. I have different sized ones and find myself using them all. I also have some on locking casters in case I want to or don’t want to move them. Some on casters I even use as temporary sawhorses. A sawhorse with shelves is pretty convenient but I would not wanna roll around a 12 foot long workbench either. I think a modular approach would do best. You could have a main table not on casters for more stability with smaller tables on casters for versatility. That’s what I did and it works and I love it.

1