Bass too big?

I have a fairly large bass that I feel is quite difficult to get around. Particularly the upper bout is quite big, it's a very deep flatback with very little slope on the back. Recently after doing a lot of thumb position work, for example in the Koussevitzky concerto, my left shoulder / upper arm has started to become quite fatigued, since I have to raise my left arm quite high to reach the notes. The neck is also quite thick, but that's something I can work around for orchestral playing. I'm a little bit out of shape, and my posture is not very good, though I'm working on improving it. I play standing with a Robpin. So I'm wondering whether this is something that is because of my overall lacking physical health, or if the bass is simply too big and I need to find myself a smaller bass to work with.

Posted Oct 24, 2022, 5:36 PM UTC

125
robotunderpants•

Hard to say without seeing you or your bass in action. You shouldn't have to reach up and over to get to thumbposition. Try different ways of sitting / standing. Short stool, tall stool, foot rest, straight endpin, high or low. Your arm should be able to naturally glide up to thumb position without issue. And from there, a bend at the hips should get you to the end of the fingerboard.

6
HungryTradie•

Lots of complicated body interactions & postures playing on "the ol' hunk of furniture". Get a couple of informed opinions on your current way of playing, and try some of their suggestions. Depending on how professional you are, there may be a sports physiologist that specialises in musicians posture, ask at your local university/conservatorium.

(Sorry for the commercial link, but this is the kind of thing I am trying to suggest. I don't know this company at all) https://www.easternsuburbsphysiotherapy.com.au/musicians-injuries

As general advice: doing gentle exercise and increasing your fitness is almost always a good thing. A small increase in physical ability may feel like a big improvement in your enjoyment of playing.

3
snoo-snooLamoo•

Just a few thought s that may be of use. First off Some times you have to admit that the bass and you do not fit (can you borrow a bass that is smaller and see how you feel... sorry to state the obvious). But think about things like end pin height, standing or sitting, and angle of the bass in relation to your body. Also use a mirror or a camera to record your playing, sometimes obvious things get lost. Also take regular breaks, a little and often is a good maxim, work on your physicality but be careful not to over do it.

1
avant_chard•

Standing with the bent pin (like you are) is about as ergonomic as you can be for thumb position. If it’s not working that way, it could definitely just be too big.

You could always try with the pin very tall and sloping back at more of a cello angle, someone like Elsen Price is a good example

1
guest2889•

Stand in front of your bass have someone hold it for you, put your arms straight down, your knuckles should be about at the bridge. If they’re lower or higher it might be the wrong size

1