[general] I'm halfway through Nona and this question is bugging me

SpoilerHarrow the Ninth Spoilers

In the John dreams, John consistently refers to people with just the first letter of their names, like A--- and M----. Based on context clues, it really seems like all these characters are the original lyctors/cavaliers.

However, the book notes specifically that John's eyes are golden at this point. So the reveal in Harrow that his original eyes were golden wouldn't make sense, then.

Does anyone know what I'm missing here, or have any theories? I don't mind light spoilers but I haven't finished Nona yet, so if it's a major spoiler please warn me!

Posted Oct 26, 2022, 2:24 PM UTC

2817
cat-se•

So impressed by all these people having theories in their first read, for pretty much all of Harrow and Nona I was just going 'What? Who?' whilst enjoying the vibes and giggling

97

Same here, friend

6
Ok_loop•

This is the way.

5
hugseverycat•

I don't want to give specific answers because the question of John's eyes and what's going on with the John dreams are some of the major reveals at the climax of the book. I will say that you're not missing anything.

50
sleeping_squire•

The people in the comments seem to consider it a spoiler but I feel like it got mentioned or at least hinted at in HtN, >!that the lyctors don’t necessarily remember everything that happened before the Resurrection.!<

39
MikeAGINX•

The answers to your questions lie ahead of you

30

tis not a spoiler, in harrow it’s said that the lyctors don’t remember anything or much pre resurrection so they wouldn’t have remembered that jod had golden eyes

26
Jmw566•

I think they mean “original” as “before becoming God” and not literally “was born with”

14
ae_bit•

John didn’t just magically know someone named Mercymorn, or Augustine, or Cassiopeia… those names were chosen

12
embracebecoming•

He literally renamed his amnesiac friends to fit his aesthetic. What a gaslight girlboss move

6
ae_bit•

Like little DOLLS.

1

I've decided Mercymorn was originally called Matilda. I have no evidence of this and do not intend to explain myself or change my mind! Thanks!!

3
bozwizard14•

Jod's original eyes are golden. The lyctors with their new names don't remember this, which is why Gideon's golden eyes are important as it makes it clear that alecto and jod achieved perfect lyctordom, contrary to what Jod has told them.

10
Huor_Celebrindolthe Sixth•

Big spoiler, keep reading

7

Jod is, canonically, a cult leader

3
Azula-Always-Lies•

I had the same thought while reading but don’t worry, an explanation is coming.

2
AutoModeratorMOD•

Thank you for submitting to r/TheNinthHouse! Please familiarize yourself with our Subreddit Rules, especially our Spoiler Policy for posts and comments. If you see a post or comment that breaks these rules, please report it!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1