Conditions and DCs

Discussion

I was watching a video on some of the changed rules for One D&D, and was somehow dumbstruck by the simple change of making exhaustion also lower spell DCs. Such a simple and intuitive change that should’ve been in 5e from the get-go. In addition, now exhaustion is an incremental debuff, which is nice for berserker Barbarians.

That aside, my question is: what do you think would be a good homebrew reduction to Spell DC for conditions like exhaustion, poisoned, and frightened in 5e? An advantage to people making the save or a penalty for the Spell Save (like a minus 5)?

Posted Oct 26, 2022, 9:37 PM UTC

16
Otherwise_Card5279•

I think exhaustion, restrained, prone and frightened should all affect spell DC. If something makes it so you’re struggling to swing a sword well, how much harder would it to perform the exact somatic gestures to perform a spell?

Right now all a caster needs to do while debuffed is to switch from attack rolls to saves. It’s just a bit too easy.

4
ClickPauseOP•

Exactly, yeah. I’m not sure to what extent it should be, but considering that disadvantage is mechanically similar to a -5, I’m considering that as a possibility. That said, since you can’t get advantage on saving throws to balance it out, I might make it less debilitating.

1
Otherwise_Card5279•

That feels about right. Either that or you lose your proficiency bonus part of the DC. Parallel would be fighting with an improvised weapon since you’re not use to it.

2
ClickPauseOP•

That would make sense too!

1
Lucky-Hero•

Definitely a penalty to the save since the issue is with the source (the caster).

Frightened I don't think should affect the spell DC. There's nothing about being frightened that would affect your ability to cast.

Poisoned I think could be a simple -2 to spell DC, it's already fairly debilitating without going more than a -2.

Exhaustion, somewhat similarly to poisoned, I think could be a -2 to spell DC per level of exhaustion. That way it ramps up just like the other negative effects of exhaustion.

0
ClickPauseOP•

“A frightened creature has disadvantage on Ability Checks and Attack rolls while the source of its fear is within Line of Sight.”

It’s implied that the fear reduces the person’s ability to properly attack or cast attacking spells in a fight, and considering many spells that require a save also require you to see the target, it seems intuitive to extend this reduction to spell save DCs.

0