What do you guys think of this Cain t-shirt design? Please comment or critique!

What do you guys think of this Cain t-shirt design? Please comment or critique!

Posted Aug 17, 2012, 8:53 PM UTC

109
jeffambo31 Nen•

Cain knows hits? I'm lost.

14
Demonkid549OPsan francisco•

It's based on the Nike's "[Somebody] Knows" t-shirt design except here I highlighted the "NO" in the "KNOWS". So it's supposed to read "Cain Knows No Hits" to commemorate his perfect game.

3
bronzarelli8 Manwaring•

Yeah, that part kind of loses me too. I do like the concept, but it just doesn't make sense. If anything, you'd say that Cain doesn't know hits.

And I agree with Pookah about the SF logo... you don't want an official logo on that.

1
BlackestNight21•

Feels like a shirt I would find for sale in the parking lot on the way to the train.

Is that bad? Good? I don't know.

8
Danceswithdirewolves39 Krukow•

Not good honestly for multiple reasons. Knows hits makes zero sense when applauding a pitcher and no hits ignores the fact that it was a perfect game. There have been 23 perfect games and about 300 no hitters.

6
Pookah54 Romo•

You probably don't want to put the SF logo on there unless you want the MLB going after you.

5
Demonkid549OPsan francisco•

I wanted to print these out but wanted to know if I could improve on the design a little more. I'm hoping you guys could help me out.

  • Do you guys think there should be something on the back?

  • How about one that just says "Cain Knows Perfect"?

  • Any recommendations on a good place to print these in San Francisco?

  • Would anybody on r/sfgiants want one? Maybe we could do a mass order.

3
piss_n_bootsBAET LA!•

based on the other feedback, why not "Cain Knows Perfection"? (I'm not familiar with the Nike campaign. I don't really get the whole "knows" thing here but I assume that it all makes sense if you're used to this ad meme.)

THIS appears to be what you're after.

if that's the case then I would mix up the font here to show that you've added the end part. lemme see if I can explain with a picture...

EDIT: example of what I meant. (these fonts aren't quite right but I do think with something like this the fonts, kerning, and leading are pretty key...

3
Green2728 Posey•

I like the design, but I agree on the fact that it's a bit too complicated of a 'punchline' for most people. I applaud your creativity but would strongly suggest the perfection idea that others brought up. Also from a design perspective, I hate the lines on top of each other. The nike ones did a great job of putting it close but not on top.

1