What do you guys think of this Cain t-shirt design? Please comment or critique!
Posted Aug 17, 2012, 8:53 PM UTC
Posted Aug 17, 2012, 8:53 PM UTC
Feels like a shirt I would find for sale in the parking lot on the way to the train.
Is that bad? Good? I don't know.
Not good honestly for multiple reasons. Knows hits makes zero sense when applauding a pitcher and no hits ignores the fact that it was a perfect game. There have been 23 perfect games and about 300 no hitters.
You probably don't want to put the SF logo on there unless you want the MLB going after you.
I wanted to print these out but wanted to know if I could improve on the design a little more. I'm hoping you guys could help me out.
Do you guys think there should be something on the back?
How about one that just says "Cain Knows Perfect"?
Any recommendations on a good place to print these in San Francisco?
Would anybody on r/sfgiants want one? Maybe we could do a mass order.
based on the other feedback, why not "Cain Knows Perfection"? (I'm not familiar with the Nike campaign. I don't really get the whole "knows" thing here but I assume that it all makes sense if you're used to this ad meme.)
THIS appears to be what you're after.
if that's the case then I would mix up the font here to show that you've added the end part. lemme see if I can explain with a picture...
EDIT: example of what I meant. (these fonts aren't quite right but I do think with something like this the fonts, kerning, and leading are pretty key...
I like the design, but I agree on the fact that it's a bit too complicated of a 'punchline' for most people. I applaud your creativity but would strongly suggest the perfection idea that others brought up. Also from a design perspective, I hate the lines on top of each other. The nike ones did a great job of putting it close but not on top.
Cain knows hits? I'm lost.
It's based on the Nike's "[Somebody] Knows" t-shirt design except here I highlighted the "NO" in the "KNOWS". So it's supposed to read "Cain Knows No Hits" to commemorate his perfect game.
Yeah, that part kind of loses me too. I do like the concept, but it just doesn't make sense. If anything, you'd say that Cain doesn't know hits.
And I agree with Pookah about the SF logo... you don't want an official logo on that.