Kalashtar in Ravnica

Question

So in my Ravnica Campaign the way I started it is that the pc's met each other in a dream. One of my players is a Kalashtar. I kind of disregarded that Kalashtar can't dream for the sake of what I have planned using this "Dreamscape" occasionally. Cuz the loop I have is pc's have a dream, wake up go about their day/adventures in Ravnica, party disband goes to bed and sometimes have dreams/nightmares.

So basically I'm looking for a reasonable reason for a race that can't dream suddenly be able to dream.

Posted Oct 29, 2022, 5:06 AM UTC · edited

413
BasicExp•

Seems to me how the memory stealing abilities of House Dimir operate, they're might some potential of the "memory" of dreaming which is actually been planted by Dimir agents who have no idea they shouldn't be able to dream.

4
G-VALOROP•

Well that's kinda helpful.

2
SonTyp_OhneNamenOrzhov Syndicate•

For the player character this is a waking nightmare. Imagine: You never dream. Your entire people doesn’t have the ability to dream. One day, you sleep as usual, and you suddenly see things happen despite being asleep. You’re startled but can’t look away or force yourself awake. Once the dream is over, you wake up drenched in cold sweat and you scream until you‘re out of breath. Existential dread sets in. Is all your life a lie? You feel you just have to investigate, if only for the sake of your peace of mind.

Who was supposed to be causing the dreams in your story? Feels like starting the game with a gimmick and making the reason for that gimmick up only later on is kind of going backwards from the usual way. Dreams and larger-than-life horrors sound pretty eldritch/lovecraftian to me, so maybe look into the Nephilim, Ravnica-specific beings of ancient times which a secret cult of deranged world-destroyers try to awaken so they can get rid of civilization and the false gods of the guilds…

3
G-VALOROP•

Well the cause of the dream is the bbeg. They're a citizen of Ravnica that's hopped between 3 guilds and has seen the discourse the guild's bring. They deem themselves the judge, jury, and executioner of Ravnica, aiming to erase it all and rebuild it anew.

But yeah I'm trying to figure out a plausible reason for Kalashtar to suddenly be able to dream.

2
SonTyp_OhneNamenOrzhov Syndicate•

And how are they doing the dream thing? Either using a magical macguffin or with a homebrewed spell. Either way the dream can affect dreamless creatures, because it’s magic, a wizard did it. Done.

2
G-VALOROP•

Well I was making this villain a planeswalker so I would think more than enough power.

But of course Kalashtar have the "Severed from Dreams" trait Which makes them immune to spells that require you to dream.

It also states they don't dream but rather experience memories from the quori spirit they're connected to.

1
SonTyp_OhneNamenOrzhov Syndicate•

Yes. I’m aware. I‘ve been trying to tell you that you as the DM with literally no boundaries to what you can create in your game actually do have the the power necessary to create something that forces a dream onto a Kalashtar. Look across the features of official creatures or magic items, hell, look at the wish spell - there’s tons of precedents for even wotc saying „we made up this rule but we need to go around it for the plot to happen so uh boom, legendary magic item that does exactly that“. You’re overthinking things. The BBEG has the power, because the power is necessary to the narrative. Nobody would accuse Tolkien of being a hack because no previous rules allowed for the creation of the one ring. This is literally the same - create something nobody’s ever heard of, then make up how it was created, what was its purpose, why it was abandoned, why it recently resurfaced and how the world reacts to it. It is that easy.

4
DeficitDragons•

Pretty sure the average Kalashtar would be familiar enough with the concept of dreaming to not be alarmed by it. Their Quori spirit are native dreamers.

1
DeficitDragons•

Okay bear with me for a second, this might seem like criticism but its not.

Kalashtar aren’t for Ravnica.

Kalashtar can’t dream in Eberron.

Therefore, if you include Kalashtar in Ravnica, there’s no reason for them to be unable to dream.

In Eberron they can’t dream because they cut themselves off from the realm of dreams, the olace whrre their immortal enemies reside.

Ravnica has no realm of dreams, so dreams there are normal and mundane (except when they’re not).

So Kalashtar dream there, because dreaming there doesn’t send one to the realm of dreams.

Elves in 5e also don’t dream because they don’t sleep, although that doesn’t occur in MtG lore (the sleep spell definitely works on elves in MtG. Are there any elf characters? Do you have the same compunctions for them?

Honestly, don’t worry about it.

2
G-VALOROP•

Mmn it never really came up as the party doesn't have any elves, but I made the assumption that Elves can kinda dream while in their trance state?

As for Kalashtar , I guess your right about the realm of dreams being an Ebberon thing but I still wanna incorporate the realm of dreams in such a way that it makes sense for Ravnica.

So I could say there's a realm Of dreams on Ravnica but unlike Ebberon the Kalashtar here aren't cut off from it?

1
DeficitDragons•

Lore wise, I don’t think elves dream Wally trance, if I recall correctly the relive their past lives.

But essentially yeah, you can just have the Kalashtar dream in Ravnica, But keep the bit about them not being able to be forced to dream which is a part of their stat block

1
Killer-Of-Spades•

Shared hallucinations that they think are dreams

1
elfhelptomes•

I'm running it a bit like Wild Magic/Exhaustion. My PCs are traveling in the Dreamscape at the moment and something is after the Kalashtar but she is suffering some ill effects (or will be when we play again) can't collect all my players at once again. :(

1
G-VALOROP•

I know that feeling.

Unfortunately for me the discord I played my game in the admin kicked me after incident in a curse of strahd game. Plus he hated my guts.

1
elfhelptomes•

Well if you have interest in a badly run game, let me know

1
G-VALOROP•

Thanks for the offer but I've kind of just been burn out on d&d and after my experience there I've just been kinda bitter.

1
elfhelptomes•

I understand. Hope things work out soon!

1