r/synology•
zoells

Upgrade DSM during RAID expansion?

DSM

I am currently expanding a 3-drive SHR1 setup to an 8-drive SHR2 setup. It'll take a while.

Is it safe to upgrade DSM versions (and therefore reboot) during this time? I couldn't find anything in Synology KBs.

Posted Oct 29, 2022, 1:34 PM UTC

08
Taylor904•

I recommend against it. If there’s one thing that probably wasn’t tested well for their upgrades, it’s stuff like this.

6
frazell•

Why would you even risk this?

Just upgrade when done…

4
zoellsOP•

Mostly looking at the OpenSSL critical vuln that will be announced Tuesday...

0
Jrreid•

Unless your nas is publicly accessible it's a concern but not worth that much risk. If it is, maybe make it not publicly accessible until after patches are out.

Plus the openssl vulnerability only affects 3.x, which I'm pretty sure Synology isn't using.

6
ADB-UK•

Nope - never - avoid like the plague.

Keep risk to the minimum - make sure your system is 100% healthy and RAID and backups are fine before doing the update.

Changing OS is the riskiest bit in server operations so make sure backups are good and everything / everyone that can be is off the server.

3
blorgobot•

Consider that the raid is managed by mdadm, a software application running under the hood, not by a discrete raid controller. What happens when the mdadm service is killed becuase the package is getting updated, or when the synology reboots?

Tooooooooo much risk.

1
ImLessOfADickIRL•

Dear god no.

1
NoLateArrivals•

Don’t even think about it- unless you want to find out the hard way if your backup really works.

1