jollyhoop•

Good. Removing all traces of the monarchy in our constitution should not be a priority but stopping elected officials from seating in parliament because they won't swear loyalty to the king of another country is ridiculous.

40
Glassnoser•

He's our king too.

4†
hey_rowsdower•

I didn't vote for him.

9
YuGiOhippie•

Kings don’t exist

The are the same as dragons and fairies: remnants of folk tales

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

2
CanadaPolitics-ModTeamMOD•

Removed for rule 2.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
auric0m•

way to demonstrate lack of understanding of our system. the canadian monarchy exists wholly outside of the british monarchy. charles is the king of canada. if england removes him tomorrow then sinks into the sea, he is still the king of canada

3†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

24
formulabrian•

If you have siblings you could also say the person that gave birth to you is someone else's mother.

I don't know about you, but I've never referred to my mom as someone else's mom, even though it is objectively true, I'd still be crazy for saying that.

-4
arcticsharkQuebec•

I mean, if your mum basically ignored your existence and spent 99% of their time and energy on your sibling, you might very well start referring to her as their mum, not yours.

7
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
makingwaronthecarCatholic, urbanist, distributist•

But they're not swearing loyalty to "the king of another country". They're swearing loyalty to His Majesty the King of Canada, and if they can't do that then they have no business in positions of public office.

-1†
Gravitas_free•

It baffles me that there are people that think that the "Canadian monarchy", a technicality born out of the Westminster Statute for convenience, is a meaningful institution. And even worse, that lack of loyalty to that "institution" should disqualify you from public office.

28
Radix2309•

Last I checked he doesn't live here. He doesn't even regularly visit. The queen across her 60+reign visited maybe 20 times for a few weeks at most each time.

What makes him Canadian? Cause he just looks like a foreign monarch to me.

10
AethyPragmatist | QC•

Well, evidently the Quebec legislature disagrees. I do too.

5
hey_rowsdower•

Imagine if Indians had to swear oath to the King of England to take office. That's how Quebec politicians feel.

4
SnarkHuntrBritish Columbian Misanthrope•

What we really need is an independant way to acquire our own monarch. It could be a process similar to how we select governors general, or maybe a lottery - sort of a 'bean king' thing. Eligible canadians can put their name in the running and every year (or two, whatever) one of them is randomly selected to be monarch for a term. Since we wouldn't need a monarch and a GG - the Canadian Monarch would be able to live at the official residence and perform all the solemn ceremonial duties of the GG.

Hell, put an entry fee on it and it could pay for itself.

At least then the Monarch would have some actual connection to this country.

1

He's literally the king of Canada. You know what, let's start using words like incumbent too, wouldn't want to stomp on people's first amendment rights.

-3†
formulabrian•

He's literally the king of our country

-3†
PlentifulOrgans•

I don't think it is at all. If you can't or refuse to perform the most basic requirement of your job, then you shouldn't have that job.

-7
AethyPragmatist | QC•

I mean, it's clearly not a basic requirement of the job; the article is literally about them about to legislate it away, because it's irrelevant.

19
AbnormalAviator:NDP: New Democratic Party of Canada•

Maybe this is mean, but I think I speak for everyone who doesn't have a day nurse or a bingo night when I say I don't give a damn about the monarchy - and may just as well scrap it after QE2.

4
AutoModeratorMOD•

###This is a reminder to read the rules before posting in this subreddit.

  1. Headline titles should be changed only when the original headline is unclear
  2. Be respectful.
  3. Keep submissions and comments substantive.
  4. Avoid direct advocacy.
  5. Link submissions must be about Canadian politics and recent.
  6. Post only one news article per story. (with one exception)
  7. Replies to removed comments or removal notices will be removed without notice, at the discretion of the moderators.
  8. Downvoting posts or comments, along with urging others to downvote, is not allowed in this subreddit. Bans will be given on the first offence.
  9. Do not copy & paste the entire content of articles in comments. If you want to read the contents of a paywalled article, please consider supporting the media outlet.

Please message the moderators if you wish to discuss a removal. Do not reply to the removal notice in-thread, you will not receive a response and your comment will be removed. Thanks.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1

I’m sure there are bigger fish to fry…instead the National Assembly will waste a considerable number of hours on this non-issue while they could work in, I don’t know…housing, health care, education problems….

-1

Well I still don't agree that can do it (because of where the obligation is located i.e. in the constitution), at least they doing it more legitimately than:

I don't like this legally required oath so I'm going to not do it but I'll still require court participants, Quebec public servants and others to take their oaths (and other all other obligations) as required by the laws of this assembly and expect you to follow.

-2†
riyehn•

The obligation isn't in the constitution, but it is required by Quebec law (which the Quebec legislature can change).

7

Is it? Do yo know which law, I'd like to read it (not that I don't believe you, I very often work with legislation so I like to interpret myself as well)?

If the obligation is under provincial law then sure, they can change it (although I still think it would be hypocritical to have public servants swear by law an oath when some legislators act as if they don't have to follow their own laws).

​

My reference is section 128 of the Constitution

https://laws.justice.gc.ca/eng/Const/page-4.html#h-27

Oath of Allegiance, etc.

128 Every Member of the Senate or House of Commons of Canada shall before taking his Seat therein take and subscribe before the Governor General or some Person authorized by him, and every Member of a Legislative Council or Legislative Assembly of any Province shall before taking his Seat therein take and subscribe before the Lieutenant Governor of the Province or some Person authorized by him, the Oath of Allegiance contained in the Fifth Schedule to this Act; and every Member of the Senate of Canada and every Member of the Legislative Council of Quebec shall also, before taking his Seat therein, take and subscribe before the Governor General, or some Person authorized by him, the Declaration of Qualification contained in the same Schedule.

​

THE FIFTH SCHEDULE

Oath of Allegiance

I A.B. do swear, That I will be faithful and bear true Allegiance to Her Majesty Queen Victoria.

Note. — The Name of the King or Queen of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland for the Time being is to be substituted from Time to Time, with proper Terms of Reference thereto.

5
riyehn•

The Speaker found it wasn't constitutionally required and could be changed by legislation.

7
lapsed_pacifist451°F | Official•

Yeah, well -- there may be some other opinions on the subject that will need to be addressed. Recall: for a time Scheer was the speaker of the house for the HoC. I sure as fuck wouldn't trust his understanding of constitutional law in Canada. Not sure why you think being speaker gives you any kind of authority or legal weight.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
EyeLikeTheStonk•

because of where the obligation is located i.e. in the constitution

You do not understand the Constitution

Provincial governments are self-regulating bodies in Canada, as such, the Canadian Constitution allows them to unilaterally amend parts of the Constitution that have to do with their provincial jurisdictions.

The Lieutenant Governors of the provinces do not represent federal power

The Lieutenant Governors of the provinces represent the Crown inside the provinces, but not the Canadian Crown, they represent the Crown in Right of the Province and the Monarch of the provinces. If The Lieutenant Governor of Quebec was a federal representative, there would be a Canadian flag in front of his office, it is not.

The confusion comes from:

The Monarch of the Provinces is the same human person as the Monarch of Canada but not the same legal entity.

Each province has a King right now, the King (in Right) of Alberta, the King (in Right) of Ontario, the King (in Right) of Quebec and so on...

Legally speaking the King in Rigth of Quebec can sue the King in Right of Canada (simplified to the "King of Canada") and vice-verse, the two different legal personas allow one government, which acts under the authority of the Crown, to sue another government which also acts under the authority of the Crown... Since the Crown cannot sue itself, both Crowns have to be different.

Another confusion comes from

The fact that the King nominates provincial Lieutenant governors under advice of the Canadian Prime Minister, which is a quirk of history that really holds no legal meaning at all since the "responsible government" has relegated the offices of the Governor General and Lieutenant Governors to a symbolic role.

Proof the "Crowns" are not the same

In Canada, all "Crown land" belong to the King, but not all Crown land belong to the same King. Only 4% of the Crown land found in provinces is federal while 96% of Crown land found in provinces is provincial. This means that the King of Canada rules over 4% of Crown land situated in the provinces while the Kings of the various provinces rule over the other 96% of the Crown land.

The Lieutenant Governor of Quebec represents the Crown of Quebec and the Monarch of Quebec, not of Canada, even if they are the same physical guy

As such, Provincial Legislature members swear an oath to the King of their province, not the King of Canada.

Article 45 of the Constitution

What is a Constitution but a "owner's manual for a government? And this is exactly why Article 45 of the Canadian Constitution allows Provincial governments to unilaterally amend their Constitutions albeit with a few restrictions:

  • Not allowed to cancel the Office of the Monarchy, the Lieutenant Governor or GG
  • Minimum of MP to match number of Senators representing that province
  • Not allowed to cancel French or English as official languages (Must adopt one of the two or both, no other language can become official in a province)
  • Not allowed to change the composition of the Supreme Court
  • Not allowed to cancel those restrictions

Everything else, including the Oath, is fair game. For instance, a province can decide to change from First Past the Post to a proportional representation system and amend the Constitution unilaterally to make it work.

So yes, Quebec can reword the Oath, change the Oath or cancel the Oath and unilaterally amend the Canadian Constitution to do so.

6
SnarkHuntrBritish Columbian Misanthrope•

Is there any path to amend the succession? If there's a dispute about the legitimate heir of the Monarch - who decides the inheritance.

Can we redefine the monarchy to select our own domestic monarch? Personally, I'd like to see it offered up randomly to qualified Canadians for short terms, but would be open to other options.

I don't understand why every government employee should be asked to swear an oath of fealty to an office occupied by a citizen and permanent resident of a distant country.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

-21
[deleted]•

[removed]

14
[deleted]•

[removed]

-2
[deleted]•

[removed]

4
[deleted]•

[removed]

8
[deleted]•

[removed]

-2
[deleted]•

[removed]

4
[deleted]•

[removed]

5
[deleted]•

[removed]

-1
[deleted]•

[removed]

4
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
CanadaPolitics-ModTeamMOD•

Removed for rule 2.

1