Seeding could ruin this major

Discussion | Esports

Navi, Faze, Vitality and Cloud9 are the 4 best teams in the world currently and because of ESLs seeding one of these teams will be guaranteed to go 0-2 and potentially go out before the playoffs.

THIS SHOULDN'T BE HAPPENING

Posted Nov 5, 2022, 10:52 PM UTC

032
GhostOfLight:TeamLiquid:•

Just win 4Head

40
Stipe57OP•

If one of the four best team is guaranteed to be 0-2 that means seeding isn't doing its job

-25
[deleted]•

No that means those teams didn't do their job.

Seeding is entirely based off results, win games and you get a higher seed. Everybody deserves whatever seed they have because they went out and earned it.

28

It’s a bo1 where teams meet in their middle map. Bo1s mean nothing. Run a proper tournament with seeding based off proper world rankings and all bo3. There will NOT and almost CAN NOT be any flukes in such a scenario. That is why cologne and Katowices produce superior games and narratives compared to vavle majors. The seeding is an absolute joke. There is no way c9 and faze get to go head to head in their opener whereas sprout and big get to dick around. This is nonsense.

1
StrollinRollin:Heroic:•

Shouldn't go 3-2 in challangers if you don't want to play top dogs then

15
SpectralHydra:TeamLiquid:•

So if an upset happens that means it’s the fault of the seeding?

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ToastEating•

That means vit and c9 shouldn't be considered 2 of the top 4 teams if their seeding is so low.

5
SpectralHydra:TeamLiquid:•

Honestly, all four of them are good enough to go from 0-2 to 3-2 pretty comfortably. How is it because of ESL’s seeding if the only reason Vitality and Cloud9 got lower seeds was because they barely made the legends stage?

29
FlyingThunder_:BIG:•

Imo this is great and makes it so much more interesting.

23
randomnooblord:ENCE:•

Maybe these top 4 teams should've done better than going 3-2 in Challenger stage.

16
Jonas276:HowlPin:•

This is what happens when you play BO1s though. It's fine to decide who goes through because eventually you get to play BO3s, but it's just horrible if it's used for seeding.

3
randomnooblord:ENCE:•

I don't see how you can justify giving a worse seed to the 3-0 team compared to the 3-2 team though

4
Jonas276:HowlPin:•

I don't think it should really matter if you are 3-2 or 3-0 in this kind of format though.

-1
muricansth•

navi and faze weren't in the challengers huh

2†
randomnooblord:ENCE:•

well I clearly meant the two who where, otherwise this whole situation wouldn't have happened

8
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
rifr9543•

Well, if they don't lose their games vs the other teams it won't happen. Just going 0-2 isn't a death sentence. If they lose, they don't deserve to win, and they aren't "the 4 best teams in the world currently", even if they are very good and were the best very recently

10
Stipe57OP•

I would agree if it wasn't for BO1, they got the bad seed because we still play fcking BO1 in the biggest tournament of the game

-10
StrollinRollin:Heroic:•

You want the major to go for 3-4 weeks?

6
l3wl123•

cologne and katowice have better formats and do not go for 3-4 weeks. bo3 double elim groups. for the major have 8 teams make it out instead of 6.

2
StrollinRollin:Heroic:•

Those tournaments don't have 24 teams attending. Also I think most people wouldn't like if it was possible for teams to just skip quarters after group stage

1
dgansta•

should determine seeds by player selected seeding, like 2019 kato major, or an expert panel/betting company

faze getting shafted over seeding they have no control over is bad

3
Jonas276:HowlPin:•

Yup this would make way more sense than having some BO1 games influence the tournament this much

2
unexpectedreboots:TeamLiquid:•

Win?

2
dying_ducks•

I dont think the problem is the seeding.

Its the whole swiss system with two bo1 at the start. And then the rmr direct into legends doenst help either based on such a system.

The 3 swiss rounds before playoffs are just odd.

2
PretAatma25:Outsiders: MAJOR CHAMPIONS :Trophy:•

Cry is free

2
VisualizeIt21:TeamLiquid:•

vitality has lost in groups of plenty of tournaments this year . dont be surprised if they lose in groups again

1

This seeding absolutely ruined this major. I can’t believe faze got c9 for their opener and then vitality. Whereas sprout gets to dick around with big.

Then the whole bne va faze, yes faze SHOULD have won but all bne did was knock out the reigning major champs and totally did Navi or liquid a favor to win. So stupid.

1
QuarantinedBean115•

it’s a tournament. best team wins. get it? someone has to be eliminated. move on

0