r/DnD•
LittleRaptor

[D&D Encounters] My first experience, is this typical?

Hi r/DnD,

Yesterday was my first time going to a DnD Encounters event. Overall, I came out with some pretty mixed feelings about it and I'm wondering if anyone has any advise, or experiences to share. If I had an atypical experience, I think I would be willing to try it again at a different store, but if it is always like this, I think I'm done with the Encounters program.

Here is a list of my pros, cons, and a summary:

Pros/Things I enjoyed:

  • I got to play D&D as a player, instead of as my usual DM spot
  • The people were nice to me at the table and in the store
  • I had fun playing Cons/Things I did not enjoy:
  • We were running the wrong adventure. They were apparently a week behind. So, it was the level 3 adventure that ended the last 'season' instead of the new level 1 adventure.
  • Everyone else was level 3 with magical items and lots of hp. I was level 1, expecting the level 1 adventure, with no magical items and low hp. I still did OK, but I didn't like this.
  • Our group composition was terrible
  • Fighting a hard 5 player encounter with 3 level 3 people and a level 1 person D:
  • There didn't seem to be much interest in RP or out of the box thinking. Everyone else seemed to want to play it just as if it was a board game with no RP.
  • I feel like my tendency to do unusual or different (not just standard action, move action, next persons turn) didn't jive well with their play style. I think it was viewed more as 'trying to get things out of the DM' instead of as role playing.
  • The event was just one encounter with no RP but took almost 3 hours.
  • I felt very railroaded, probably since it was a WotC encounter the DM likely had almost no say in any deviations.
  • There was no mention of the Renown points rewards, fortune cards, renown point tracker, or bonuses for doing things, or anything to do with the WotC program that wasn't just running the encounter. It felt disjointed like the store just took the encounter and stripped out everything else.

Summary:

I feel almost like I had fun despite everything that happened, rather than having fun because of things that happened. Looking at the list, there was almost nothing that added fun above and beyond just the fun of playing D&D.

I would appreciate any advice or sharing of experience with the D&D Encounters program and otherwise!

Thanks,

-LittleRaptor

Posted Aug 23, 2012, 5:06 PM UTC

49
cahpahkah•

For starters, you had an off-level character that showed up for the finale of a long storyline...it's not your fault, but no, you're not going to have a good time in that situation.

You're not going to have any control over group composition; when I go to public play events where I don't know who else is in the party, I tend to bring characters for every role and audible as needed. Makes for a better overall experience.

I don't know what you mean by doing "unusual or different" things on your turn; can you clarify?

Basically, the store should stay on-schedule, both week to week and in a session (three hours is ridiculous). Players should be flexible and understand what they're getting into (i.e., at the end of the day, the Encounters program is designed to provide a mostly-standardized public play experience across DMs, which does result in a bit of railroading).

3
LittleRaptorOPDM•

Thanks for the response, I was considering making multiple characters but since it was my first time I just wanted to go in with something simple.

An example of something unusual, is there there were Drow wizards of some kind levitating off the ground. I was out of ranged weapons and my character had great athletics so I want to try run, jump, and tackle/grapple one of them. The DM allowed it, but everyone kind of looked at me like I was crazy.

I appreciate your feedback, do you often go to the encounters programs?

2
cahpahkah•

I've played in a few and DMed two seasons (Crystal Cave and Dark Sun); I also play and run a bunch of LFR games, so I know about the pitfalls of public play.

Basically, if you had a good time playing the game, I'd encourage you to stick with it; it sounds like the biggest stumbling blocks you hit were related to logistics. If your store is in fact starting the new season next week and you can get in on the ground floor, it could address most of the issues you faced last time around.

2
LittleRaptorOPDM•

I was also a bit bothered by the lack of 'extras' that WotC advertised for these events. Do you find that most people tend to ignore the "Renown points" and things like that?

1
cahpahkah•

Mileage may vary. Personally, I don't find the renown points to be relevant because the seasons I've DMed have had a single party all the way through -- they do provide continuity if you're hopping from table to table from week to week, I guess. I like them in principal, but I've never seen anyone actually care about them in a meaningful way.

2
Sigma7•

The DM allowed it, but everyone kind of looked at me like I was crazy.

What, they don't read the rulebook?

Given that the ceiling is 15' high, they couldn't be more than 10' off the ground, meaning it's only an athletics DC 10 to allow weapon attacks (this lifts you 1', which allows your reach to enter range of the target). It's a quite reasonable action as far as I know - you just happen to fall 1' at the end.

They're also supposed to do things like that. Use whatever you can to your advantage rather than just relying on powers. Sometimes it flops (e.g. I bull rushed an enemy into bubbling blood, but it didn't do anything), and other times it pays off (e.g. Kobold flavored rations given to an ogre).

1
LittleRaptorOPDM•

I guess that's just it, it was an action that wasn't on a power card. The DM allowed it and I rolled athletics check, grapple check, etc but I thought it wasn't all that out of the ordinary at least.

1
[deleted]•

That's very different from my experience. First off, are they even allowed to be off-schedule? I think usually Wizards is very careful about its events happening at the same time everywhere (for instance, Magic pre-releases can only be held on certain days).

RP quality can vary dramatically at Encounters. Some people are super involved in their characters, others are more there to just play a game. If you find people you enjoy playing with, request that you get placed at a table with them (assuming you have more than 1 table I suppose).

I would have just asked the DM if I could start at level 2 or 3. It's the final encounter, you only had 4 people, and it was a tough fight (my group of 5 level 3s finished it after using all our second winds, everyone was very bloodied except me, and our cleric was outright dead). I think it would have made it more enjoyable at both ends. In general, don't be afraid to ask the DM for things that would make it a more enjoyable game for people.

They probably weren't doing the trackers because it was the last week of the season. Still, it would be good to check if they are using them and if they allow fortune cards. I know some people think fortune cards are a gimmick, but most people at the store I play at like them. They add this extra element of randomness that can be fun.

Is it really surprising that you wanted to do something over than use an attack off your sheet? I've pushed people off ledges, tripped people, stabbed drow in their eyes to blind them, etc. Were your turns taking a ton of time? That can make people cranky.

1
LittleRaptorOPDM•

I tried to focus on making my turns as fast as possible so I didn't hold anything up, especially as it got later into the evening. It's not that anyone objected or was rude at all, they just all seemed very surprised. I was pretty involved in my character but character names weren't even introduced or used at all during the session :(

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1