We can debate a couple players on the @USMNT roster, but the biggest takeaway from this is that the core and key players for the team are ALL on the plane to Qatar. It didn’t look so likely a few months ago and that’s what will decide success, not the fringe. #USMNT

Posted Nov 10, 2022, 1:27 AM UTC

11921
brandonesqueNorth Carolina•

This is a Stu Holden tweet, btw

60

This is true. There are only 3 games initially. Against some of the best competition in the world. Players 18-26 probably won’t see that much time. The big time players will be seeing the field and the success of the team is in their hands.

45
sebsasour•

He's completely right, I actually probably have the most disagreements with this squad than I've had for any prior to qualifying, but it's not like I think anyone is going to have a real tangible effect on our odds in Qatar.

I'm actually happy Shaq got the call, and if you're telling me to drop one of Cannon, Yedlin, or Shaq, IMO it should actually be Yedlin, but still Yedlin has speed and experience going for him, so my passion for that on a scale of 1 to 10 is a 1.

Steffen should make it over Horvath IMO, but if he's not gonna start (which he shouldn't) then whatever.

I would take Pefok over Haji, but I can't really confidently proclaim right now that Pefok is significantly more likely to get his head to a hopeful cross in the box

I think Arriola getting cut for Morris is the biggest travesty, but they're only likely to be late sub options anyway, and we are 2 matches removed from Morris scoring a 90th minute goal to save a result.

Pepi, Ferreira, and Sargent are all pretty samey to me at the moment, and you could make a case for starting or cutting either one. Sarge would probably be my choice for the cut, but his form is undeniable right now and he does provide cover in another position (though I don't think we really need help at that position)

45
MossHops•

This is almost exactly where I am at as well. I don't think I will be surprised by the starting XI, and that's what matters. The others that I quibble with aren't going to be particularly important to our chances and I can at least understand why GGG made the choice.

I might make different choices, but I'd think GGG got it mostly right.

12
GuteNunray•

This kind of eloquence is not allowed on this sub sir

10
-Skald•

“Am I a joke to you?” - Miles

27
bpinty•

I would feel so much better about our group chances if he was healthy

23
mojojojo1108_•

The Miles-Zim partnership was unreal.

3
ProfessorPablo1•

Of the healthy players, sure. But I still consider Miles Robinson and Chris Richards to be core players, so I don’t really agree with Stu Holden here. Our center back pairing is arguably the weakest it’s been in two years.

11
AmarilloCaballero•

I would have to triple check, but I am pretty sure the highest number of players we used in a 3 game WCQ window was 22. I'd be very surprised if more than 20 players actually see the field in this World Cup.

3
t_ran_asuarus_rex•

Fuck all the noise. Murica!

2
bossmt_2•

I would agree with Holden. Hopefully we are healthy enough.

Unfortunately the problem I have is I just don't see Long being good enough and he'll be starting. Hopefully Adams, Zimmerman and Jedi can cover his weaknesses.

1
cmb3248•

Assuming that core doesn't have a striker or a solid #1 keeper, and doesn't include Miles Robinson, sure.

-5
ProfessorPlum168•

No - literally the 3 best CBs are not on the plane - Richards, Brooks and Robinson. Yeah you can nitpick about Brooks yada but the point is to refute that the best players are on the plane.

-6
ktnash133Oregon•

Brooks is not one of our three best CBs and it's not nitpicking to point out that he has played one game in months while healthy at a club that was having a CB injury crisis. He just was not a reasonable choice for this World Cup.

11
ProfessorPlum168•

The best players are not on the plane.

Ask anyone, in isolation, who would you pick, Brooks or Long? If your answer is Long you are not being truthful.

-11
ktnash133Oregon•

My answer is that it's a bad question. Brooks and Long play different roles. Look at nearly any top club or national team that plays 4atb, very very few of them have a starting CB pair made up of two slow CBs.

We have three healthy CBs in the pool with pace: Long, McKenzie and (kind of) CCV. We're taking two of them as well as two slower CBs in Ream and Zimmerman. If Brooks were on this roster he's not replacing Long, he's replacing Zimmerman or Ream and he absolutely does not deserve it more than either of those guys.

9
ProfessorPlum168•

Without reading your answer you sound like a fucking politician.

-14
broncosuccotash•

Pepi and Tillman should be on the plane over Morris and Roldan. If we're talking core. And long term national team future.

-7†
InHisImage1•

Bring in Roldan as an honorary coach, don’t waste a roster spot. When it can go a young player with lots of potential. 2026 should’ve been a topic in mind when deciding on those last few roster spots. Pepi/Tillman should’ve gone over Roldan/Morris.

-2†