How much does a trem affect tuning stability?

I'm thinking of getting a Strandberg and I've read that if you don't need a trem it's better to get a guitar that doesn't have one as they affect tuning stability, but I've also read that Strandbergs are incredibly stable when it comes to tuning.

What's the situation? Will I have to tune it every other day if I buy with a trem? Is it harder to tune with a trem than without or something? Even if it is harder, is it actually that hard or is it not really a concern.

Posted Nov 10, 2022, 1:48 PM UTC

37
brammers01•

Tuning with any trem is all about balance. Providing it's set up correctly you shouldn't really lose out much in regards to tuning stability but you will find it takes longer to tune.

If you think about how the trem works - it's the tension of the strings and the tension in the springs in the back of the trem that play against each other. If you adjust the tension of one string, it'll upset the balance of the trem and that will shift the pitch of all the other strings ever so slightly so tuning will typically take a number of passes, tuning each string until they're all in tune, with each pass needing a smaller and smaller adjustment.

This can make switching between drop d and standard a laborious task, for example. I would personally set up a guitar with a trem in a particular tuning and then leave it there.

If you don't need a trem, then I wouldn't buy a guitar with one. If you've never used a trem before but you're interested in trying one then go for it. Standberg have a 14 day, no questions asked return policy, after all!

3
WarPearOP•

Thanks for the reply. The Strandberg return policy is good, but I don't think it'll work for me as something I didn't mention in my post is that I'm a relatively new guitar player who has a good handle on the open chords, and strumming, but who hasn't really ventured in to soloing territory yet. I have a Ibanez GRX70QA, and while it does have a trem bar I found that it really just got in the way while I was practicing so I removed it pretty early on and haven't attached it since. I want to upgrade my guitar though, and I love the ergonomic style of the Strandberg, but I'd like to get something that I'll appreciate long term which is why I made this post.

I suppose there probably isn't a good answer here, as the reality of the situation will make itself apparent over time.

I guess it sort of sounds like if I would like a trem, but don't necessarily need one, and don't play in exotic tuning then get one, but if I will want to change tuning all the time then don't bother.

1
dehydratedH2O•

Once you get it in tune, it will be pretty stable unless you’re doing insane dive bombs on the bar constantly. Getting it in tune can be slightly trickier than a fixed bridge, though.

2
threeLetterMeyhem•

Mine stays in tune pretty well once I get it in tune. If the weather/temperature is consistent, mine can go weeks before needing to true up on tuning.

Getting a new set of strings on or changing to a different tuning takes longer, though. But if you enjoy playing with a trem it's probably worth it :)

2
WarPearOP•

Yeah that's kind of the crux of my problem. I don't actually know if I enjoy playing with a trem because I haven't actually got to trying to play with one. I think I'd like one, as I like the idea of playing Joe Satriani style solos atm, but idk: maybe as I get better I won't find myself playing that sort of thing much.

Like, part of my problem is I don't even know how to make the sound I want to make. Maybe I'll end up wanting a trem if I don't get one, or maybe if I get one I'll never use it.

Thanks for the reply :)

1
Mattshuku•

My classic 6 has incredibly tuning stability, better than almost any other guitar I own (although I attribute that partially to the roasted neck) - it does take more effort to restring and setup than a hardtail, but once it's good I never really have to worry about it, other than making micro-adjustments.

1

The double locking is even better than normal tuners. If you really want you can block the trem, so it acts like a fixed bridge but with double locking. A few guitars have fixed double locking standard, I can think of the Mick Thomson signature Jackson guitar and Meshuggah's 8 strings.

A floating tremolo is going to take way more time to get in tune, to get intonated, just about everything. Every change in tension in one string slightly moves the rest of the strings in the opposite direction. Forget about switching tunings without some sort of blocking system.

Once it's in tune though, it's going to stay in tune, even with a lot of abuse. That's what makes it fun. Your strings need to already be stretched out, so you'll be working on new strings to get in tune for a little bit, as they progressively go flat from tension.

You can see Steve Vai for some of the mastery and abuse a floating trem can do: https://youtu.be/K2xnQJQWlM4

0