What happened to Abundant Harvest in legacy?

SCD

I remember it getting modest use in bant lists by platers like Anzid last year, but then it disappeared. Was it not good enough, or did the those decks pivot in another direction?

Posted Nov 11, 2022, 2:05 AM UTC

4712
Trohck•

It was never good enough, but people needed to experiment with it for a bit to confirm that.

47
Smythe28•

Once Upon a Time just fits that slot better, and even that’s not seeing the crazy amount of play it used to…

Mostly because it’s just better to add UR to the deck and play EI.

25
Alucart333I DONT KNOW WHAT I AM PLAYING ANYMORE•

why play harvest when you can just EI

25
Skrappyross•

I mean, not being in Blue or Red are reasons. More realistically, why play Abundant Harvest when you can play Once Upon a Time.

8
Alucart333I DONT KNOW WHAT I AM PLAYING ANYMORE•

because abundant harvest never misses the land drop

6
Pongoid•

It slowly dwindled to 1-ofs in lists. Then many lists stoped using them all together. Then it was hard to find lists with any. Now, you never see them.

I think the card is fine, but sadly just not quite good enough.

15
terfsfugoff•

The issue is more with the color than the card, at this point, imo.

4
mtgkobygrinder has been•

I still play 4 of it in my Battle of Wits deck; after Brainstorm Ponder Preordain EI Peek Explore and Limdul’s Vault

11
gizlowStryfo/Tempo DD/Miracles•

I’ve seen it in some Chain of Smog style combo decks recently, but like others have said, if you’re in blue there’s a bunch of other cards you’ll look to before Abundant Harvest.

7
viking_•

If you're in blue, ponder and brainstorm are better. They give you more precise control over the cards you end up with. EI is probably also better if you can splash red. If you wanted to try to play a non-blue xerox deck, then harvest would be something to try, but I don't know what removing blue from xerox would accomplish.

6
oOOoOphidianRUG Delver, Aluren, Snow, TES•

cutting lands and playing it doesnt work as well when delver and d&t are among the most popular decks

4
cbc776•

Card is simply not very good (also sees almost no modern play). I found it helpful to not think of it like a cantrip but instead like one of the zendikar flip lands that has “random spell, casts G extra” on one side and “random tap land” on the other — which is much more clearly a weak card for eternal formats.

3