My local John of Arthur Ave…. Peanut Butter & Jelly pizza

Cursed
My local John of Arthur Ave…. Peanut Butter & Jelly pizza

Posted Nov 13, 2022, 6:54 PM UTC

1.4K103
groovehouse•

Dessert pizza is not a crime.

393
Sovdark•

It is however not a pizza. Delicious things on pizza crust do not a pizza make

39
MiracuMAHt•

Club penguin begs to differ

32
Every_of_the_it•

Sure they do. What's your bare minimum definition of pizza?

25
Sovdark•

Crust, tomato based sauce/tomatoes, cheese

Anything less than that is a flatbread

-3
eeelisabeth•

What about white pies?

5
BaconSoul•

If you subscribe to the teleological argument, pizza is anything that we treat like pizza and eat in a similar enough context to pizza.

If you’re eating a dessert pizza, it’s very likely that you’ve just had pizza as your main course. You also eat it like pizza. It’s hard to deny that argument unless you can find some sort of material constant for pizza, and that doesn’t seem to be discernible.

10
Synchro_Shoukan•

I agree

2
Spelt666•

Wtf is dessert pizza?

6
LightsSoundAction•

cicis had a dope dessert pizza. i think chocolate? coupled with the cinnimon things it was almost enough to forget you were at cicis

15
Pancerules•

Oof, Cici’s ownership should be arraigned at The Hague for pizza crimes against humanity. Those hot discs of garbage should only be served in the deepest, darkest prison and only to the worst criminals.

4
mspacman69•

Something that should be a crime!

-16
rdcarr2•

Many legit Italian pizza places sell pizza with nutella as dessert/for kids

6
septiclizardkid•

Cheese and Sauce Is delicious and those are the key Ingredients to regular pizza, therefore dessert pizza Is pizza

1
reeniedreamOP•

Maybe because I don’t like peanut butter to begin with? Lol it seemed kinda gross to me.

-105
halt-l-am-reptar•

I don't like olives, but I'm not going to start posting any pizza with olives.

94
reeniedreamOP•

Jeez I thought this sub was all in good fun lol. If one enjoys peanut butter, then more power to them :)

-20
FuckingShitRobots•

Don’t come for peanut butter. Ever.

39
Jane-Sadwoman•

I think people are just tired of seeing dessert pizzas posted. The general consensus is that dessert pizzas (and pickle pizzas) are not a crime.

This one does look bottom of the barrel in the dessert pizza arena tho. If you’re gonna make a dessert pizza you gotta put a little more creativity/effort into it!

26
SmileAndDeny•

You’ve done a disservice to pizza crimes.

57

The ADAP (Assistant District Attorney of Pizza) will bring charges against the OP for this post.

Allegations:

False Reporting of a Pizza Crime - Misdemeanor

May the jury have mercy on OPs soul...though it's probably just like probation or whatever for a first offender so likely not that big of a deal.

14
Pickerington•

As self appointed jury foreman; guilty on all counts. Sentenced immediately to 5 minutes of community service and a PBJ sandwich with extra peanut butter.

2
bubblegrubs•

Yeah I think if you personally dislike something then it's a bit different.

I know people who don't like cheese for instance.

20
honeybearbottle•

I would eat this!

181
Chunk_Simpson•

I bet this pizza is so good tbh

24
honeybearbottle•

A hot gooey pbj oooh man!!

13
Chunk_Simpson•

Oh shit don’t get me going

3
abom-badass-mofo•

I love peanut butter and jelly.. and weed, so this is a beautiful thing.

87
lukas_maximus•

Yeah I was just thinking how nice this would be when high ayylmao

15
ghost_of_dongerbot•

ヽ༼ ຈل͜ຈ༽ ノ Raise ur dongers!

^^Dongers ^^Raised: ^^68559

^^Check ^^Out ^^/r/AyyLmao2DongerBot ^^For ^^More ^^Info

-8
UnemployedMod420•

why not jelly circles for the peperoni effect?

62
burnthamt•

For presentation it would be great but it takes longer so maybe not as viable for a restaurant

16
mangomilkmilkman•

Total missed opportunity

11
QueenMelle•

Ah yes, the most efficient way to eat pb and j. Warm and open faced. Won't make a humungus mess at all!

31
reyadeyat•

My friend, have you heard of peanut butter on toast.

58
bubblegrubs•

That's literally the only way I eat peanut butter.

Well, toast or a bagel. The bagel is far superior btw, especially with a liberal amount of butter.

19
QueenMelle•

Is you're toast all thin and floppy like this leg burn waiting to happen is?

-6
happyhomemaker29•

Oh God, I’m so torn! When I was a kid, I used to eat peanut butter and jelly straight from a bowl, just skip the bread. Now I have to have just an inkling of jelly on my sandwiches, but definitely go hard on the peanut butter. The kid in me is screaming that this looks so good right now, while the adult in me is telling me sit the hell down and not eat the war crime. I’m so torn!

13
hackthekenku•

Sigh… I’ll take a large

12
Trueloveis4u•

How is this cursed it's basically a warm open faced pb and j. I'd 100% eat this.

7

Would

6
clamboozled•

This is a perfect way to incorporate pizza into every meal. A dedicated breakfast slice that leaves you lusting for an afternoon pepperoni 🤌

5
happyhomemaker29•

Cooked peanut butter tastes so much better than in the jar for some reason. I agree, this for breakfast, cheese for lunch, and pepperoni for dinner. Pizza all day would make me very happy!

1
i-am-adrift•

I’d smash

4
icooktoeat•

Looks good…I’d prefer more jelly though.

4
Mario_Creeper•

There's more jelly under the pb

1
reddawg95•

you got that in NY?? blasphemy

3†
MotherofChoad•

It looks like it’s a chain and not actually on Arthur Ave in the Bronx

7
myfirstnuzlocke•

I was gonna say I lived there until a few years ago and there certainly was none of this on Arthur Ave.

I assumed gentrification was hitting hard.

2
reeniedreamOP•

Pennsylvania

0†
Mycotoxicjoy•

Milford? That place was great and had a massive 27 inch pie that was great for a party

1

But I want it

3
Radioactive_Kompot•

I would smash

2
auberific•

That actually looks really, really delicious 🤤

2
Skelakitty92•

I would not hesitate to eat this! 😜

2
avelineaurora•

Ngl I'd probably fuck with this...

2
vjrmedina•

Blessed*

2
JAYCEE--•

I’m interested in this one.

2