r/DnD•
Iamfivebears

Updates to /r/DnD Rules: New rules governing AI Artwork and Commission posts

Mod Post

Ah, adventurer, I see my wares have caught your eye. That ring is especially interesting, as it once belonged to....uh....a king! Yes that's right a king! Let me tell you about how...

For almost a month we ran a poll of the r/DnD community, coupled with a thread where users could leave feedback. We received over 2000 responses to the poll, and dozens of comments. We really appreciate the feedback, and are excited to announce the new rules.

##These rules will go into effect Friday, November 18th.

#AI Art is being added to the "Banned Subjects" list. This means you cannot make a link or image post of AI artwork, but can still link to or discuss it in text posts.

  • 39.5% It should be added to the Banned Subjects Image list. It cannot be posted as an image post/marked as original content, but can be discussed and linked in text posts.
  • 30.5% No rule change. It should be allowed without restriction.
  • 15.1% It should be banned from the subreddit entirely.

A combined 55% of the sub thinks that something needs to be done about AI artwork, and the conversations were similar. Between the issues of low-effort spam and the ethics of training AI models on artwork without artist consent, we agree something needs to be done. That being said, there have also been some passionate calls to still allow discussion of AI artwork and its uses at the table. Therefore we will be adding AI Artwork to the Banned Subjects list, with the likes of memes and NSFW artwork.

This means that you can discuss how you use AI artwork at your table, and even link to some you have created, but you cannot claim it as original content. We may revise these rules in the future, and we'll look forward to community feedback on how the rules shake out.

#Post seeking commissions must include the tag [Comm] in the title. We will be adding a filter for anyone seeking or seeking to avoid these posts.

  • 69.6% Require a commissions tag in titles [Comm]. This would require those seeking commissions to label their posts, making them easier to find and easier to filter.
  • 20.2% No rule change. Users are free to mention commissions in titles or not.

Dungeons & Dragons related artwork has been a staple of r/DnD for a long time, and has long been a popular outlet for artists showing of their creations! That being said, there is a large portion of the community that simply does not want to be advertised to, and we want to make it easier for that crowd to customize their feed. From now on any user posting their artwork with the aim of seeking commissions, or posting artwork that they had commissioned, will be required to include a [Comm] tag in the title. Like the [Art] and [OC] tags it must be exact, include the brackets.

It is very likely that there are edge cases we have not considered, so again we'll be looking for feedback on how this rule plays out in the coming months.

#Other Announcements

  • Giveaways will not be changing. We already require that giveaways only collect the bare minimum amount of information required to conduct the giveaway, and users voted OVERWHELMINGLY (76.5% to 21.3%) to not change the rules any further.
  • We're still reviewing the mod applications, with plans to reach out to those selected this weekend.
  • We will not be banning "new player/DM looking for help", "how to deal with problem player?", or "AITA/Relationship question" style posts. When we bring new mods on one of our first orders of business will be to create a new "Getting Started Guide" to replace the one in the sidebar, but these threads are not going to be banned. They're often full of legitimate information and the users posting them usually benefit immensely from the feedback of the community on their specific cases.

Posted Nov 15, 2022, 9:27 PM UTC

326209
leovaDM•

thanks for keeping this place healthy :)

92
Cero_KurnBard•

How is AI's art unhealthy?

-39
Bonty48•

Why are you so fixated on AI art? You commented on any comment here vaguely seems against ai art.

39
sealene_hatarinn•

Because they make and post AI "art" and are unhappy that now they can't get easy upvotes for something they didn't create.

44
Bonty48•

Ah heh serves them right

23
Kolaru•

It’s literally built on theft

26
Kayshin•

That's not how ai works...

10
SinstarMutation•

Or how theft works.

1
NoctuleArt•

AI art is a husk of real art, I’m glad it’s gone

19
LillianCalderon•

I'm an artist, and I use AI to bring my ideas to life, then work on them to make them my own. I see AI as a tool and hope that everyone else does as well.
I understand that some may use it to avoid hiring an artist or whatever, but banning AI is like prohibiting cameras and photography in the nineteenth century, when artists were afraid to use that new tool
Instead of forbidding something you don't understand, learn how to use it.

2
NoctuleArt•

Photography wasn’t created by stealing the work of other photographers.

3
RAMAR713Warlock•

It isn't. A lot of people on this thread are just wrong.

7
BaffledPlato•

Post seeking commissions must include the tag [Comm] in the title. We will be adding a filter for anyone seeking or seeking to avoid these posts.

Thank you so much for this. Over 75% of the posts I see on this sub are advertisements and will love the ability to filter them out.

80
Drigr•

Too bad it does nothing on mobile but make them easier to down vote...

10
IamfivebearsOPMODNeon Disco Golem DMPC•

The official reddit mobile app doesn't have filtering, but basically all other reddit apps do. I personally suggest Sync for Reddit.

7
Tyvox_C•

Thank you!! AI "art" really messed up the way I look at people submissions and artwork.

62
RabbitPanicRogue•

Sounds like a you problem tbh.

5
OlympiaImperial•

Thank goodness. Any L for AI "artists" is a W for actual artists

56
GibsonJunkie•

I don't post here super often, but it seems like the only posts from this sub that hit my front page are advertisements disguised as giveaways. Is this something that can be looked at?

50
IamfivebearsOPMODNeon Disco Golem DMPC•

I explained this in the post, but no, we will not be changing how giveaways are handled. Users overwhelmingly voted to keep them the way they are.

Giveaways are undeniably ads, and are therefore subject to our advertisement rules. Because giveaways have such reach we instituted a second set of giveaway guidelines to protect the community (giveaways cannot collect data beyond the little bit necessary to function, cannot force you to share anything or tag anyone, etc). This system has been working pretty well the last few years, and the sub seems to agree!

We'll continue to monitor feedback, and we'll run more polls in the future. Things may change, but this is a pretty strong mandate at the moment.

19
alienblue88•

A humble suggestion? Require that the giveaway runner announce the winner publicly.

Just like in states that require you to claim a lottery prize publicly, this is a great measure to ensure things are above board (more or less). It not only provides evidence that a real account “won”, but also that the giveaway runner is actually following through and providing the “prize”.

64
IamfivebearsOPMODNeon Disco Golem DMPC•

This is a good idea. We'll look into this.

14
GibsonJunkie•

I must have missed that bit when I read the post, my bad. Thanks for the reply.

4
Nhobdy•

Y'all are doing great work. Keep it up!

2
CarlGauss•

What about requiring giveaways to include an [Ad] tag that can also be filtered? Lets the giveaways continue, but also allow those who don't want to see them to filter them.

(Side note, I'm not a savvy Redditor, but I don't see a way to filter out [comm], only a list of pre-defined filters set up by the mods. Is filtering out [comm] something that will be added, or am I not very smart and don't know how to set up custom filters?)

1
DubiousFoliageDM•

I’m okay with AI art, I voted to keep it. But I’ve also seen a ton of low-effort AI threads clogging up DND subs lately, so I really think this is a good middle ground.

Thanks for taking an even-handed stance on this that values both new tools that make art more accessible and talented, hardworking artists that make art a genuine craft.

38
Cero_KurnBard•

Clogging?

This community has less than 10 posts per day?!

-26
Kolaru•

There have been 21 posts in the 6h before I made this comment… not even at peak time

28
DubiousFoliageDM•

This is also not the only DND sub out there.

9
Drigr•

You posted the same piece of AI art twice in the same day buddy....

6
LongboardLiam•

Thank you! AI stuff is a pox on Reddit.

32
alienblue88•

Agreed! Some subs like r/creepy have been an absolute wasteland ever since DALL-E went public.

12
knoldpold1•

Personally disagree with the decision and think that just adding an AI tag would be enough, but i appreciate that the sub is being kept democratic.

If the majority of the sub thinks that AI art shouldn't be here, then that's how it is.

32
Tharnaal•

I’m a fan of AI art that is done well, which can take quite a bit of time and effort by the user to refine. That said, communities have rules and I agree that putting the rules in the hands of the community is a good choice. I would generally think the core Reddit upvote/downvote system would show what people want to see, but I respect the choice to do it this way.

AI or not, a character image with a backstory is interesting to me, but each to their own. As someone in this thread mentioned, if people don’t like the decision, there are other subs out there.

8
Drigr•

The problem with relying on up and down votes is the active vs the passive parts of the community. Look at some of the big art posts, thousands of up votes, tens of comments. Art gets a ton of easy up votes by nature of being able to be consumed right from the main feed, up voted, and moved on. A lot of subreddits go through this problem where the people who are actively commenting are looking for something that doesn't line up with what the people who just up vote from their main feed are showing they want. It's why a lot of subs that want to foster discussion end up banning memes and sometimes images.

5
Tharnaal•

That’s a really good point. I hadn’t though of that angle. The 3 second attention span screws up the embedded system. You have me convinced. 👍

1
Drigr•

People are welcome to create r/DnD_AI if they think it's the type of content worth supporting.

1
starstruckmon•

It's r/dndai

3
knoldpold1•

Yes, because people voted not to include it in this sub. If the vote had turned out different that would not have been the case.

2
override367•

It's kind of an insane overreaction to even ban links in discussions, even if I get banning ai art posts

-8
teSiatSa•

Didn't they specify, that you are allowed to link to AI images (within text), as long as you disclose that it's AI and don't claim ownership of the content.

10
override367•

I don't think you can own AI content unless you substantially transform it, but I don't have a problem with the disclosure

2
teSiatSa•

The ownership of AI content is quite a can of worms indeed.

4
theyreadmycomments•

Good shout lads

27
1000fists•

Good shit mods. Appreciate all of your guys' effort.

24
AlexD2003•

That’s good. AI art looks like blurry garbage and needs to destroyed. It’s disgusting and artless in itself

24
A_Hero_•

If it is disgusting, why do so many people enjoy AI art content? What if you look at AI art without realizing it is AI-made and enjoy it?

6

why do so many people enjoy AI art content?

Because most people have crap taste and just like things that look '' nice '' on the most base surface level.

4
AlexD2003•

. I thought the concept was interesting but deadass it will never replace the art made by people. Also there are some dead giveaway signs that art is AI art, like how the whole thing will look blurry or certain details will be missing, and to me that just makes the whole thing look uncanny and not talented.

3
A_Hero_•

There are many types of image models people can make themselves by just giving the SD model a couple of images to analyze. A small portfollio of images can be enough to have your own decent, modified image generator. People can upscale their images with other AI to increase image quality and clarity too.

there are some dead giveaway signs that art is AI art, like how the whole thing will look blurry or certain details will be missing, and to me that just makes the whole thing look uncanny and not talented.

I consider image generation as a sort of fascinating tool. It is not normally supposed to be something that creates a finished product, but something that helps in the process of someone's workflow. Or, used casually as just a hobby. It's potential as a tool can be very good.

3
cookiedough320DM•

(Implying AI art is fine to be submitted if it looks normal and regular art shouldn't be submitted if it looks bad)

1
Cero_KurnBard•

wtf

-17
ApeMunArts•

Stop replying to every anti ai theft bot comment in this thread.

especially this one, because from I've seen of your ai images, because they aren't art, they are "blurry garbage".

10
Drasha1•

How will this rule impact mixed media posts that include AI generated art? If someone writes an adventure and includes AI generated images on the page with the adventure text is posting that banned?

22
IamfivebearsOPMODNeon Disco Golem DMPC•

If AI generation was used at any point in the creation of the image then it can't be posted as an image to r/DnD.

Right now the stance has to be strict because it's a new rule that is going to be difficult to fully enforce. In the future we may be able to introduce some nuance to the rule, but at the moment it's a complete ban.

29
RabbitPanicRogue•

Is there a way to tell the difference between digital artwork and AI art?

3
Rushnik72•

This really made my day. Thanks for the decision to do this!

20
Adraius•

Great stuff, both the decisions themselves and the clear, thorough breakdown of what's being done. Appreciate it.

14
orangepunc•

One subject that wasn't directly addressed in the poll is the plethora of posts (including giveaways) that are nothing but ads for someone's Etsy dice shop.

These are both advertising and at best tenuously D&D related and I have no idea why they're allowed on the sub. Sure, the game uses dice, but I don't think anyone would be ok with Frito Lay posting about their latest junk food you can buy to share with your D&D group. The connection to D&D, such as it is, is mostly just that the target market is here, and so it's an attractive forum for advertisers. Same goes for dice towers and other vaguely D&D-related arts and crafts projects, particularly when the poster is selling them.

Will these posts and giveaways and kickstarters also be filtered by the new [Comm] filter? If not, the sub will still be mostly ads even after filtering.

13
yeetyfeety32•

I wouldn't hold your breath for the mods to actually fix that issue, I've spoken to them privately and posted about it before to the top mod just saying ads are a part of the sub and to suck it up.

1
orangepunc•

Yeah, the right thing to do is just leave the sub and stick to the somewhat useful D&D subs. But I figure it can't hurt to clearly describe the problem on the way out.

4
patchy_doll•

Appreciate the response to AI art.

I do want to say that I think the bit about commissions could use a very slight rewording (as someone who is both a provider and consumer of art services). The term 'seeking commissions' isn't completely wrong but it confused me at first as I am accustomed to seeing that term being used to describe someone who is seeking to commission work. I think it might be clearer if the text replaced 'seeking' with advertising, soliciting, promoting, or offering. Those are terms I see regularly used for that.

I would also appreciate a little clarification on a few cases for posting commissioned work:

  • If I post work I completed on commission for someone else, that would be [Comm], that's straightforward enough.
  • If I post work I commissioned someone to create for me, with the intent to share the art and the story behind it, and give a simple line of credit via URL... does that require [Comm], on that artist's behalf?
  • If I am posting work I have created for myself, with no intent of actively soliciting commissions from viewers, I would typically post with [Art]. Would I add the [Comm] tag if I include a link to my portfolio (which describes my commission services) in the main comment? What if I do not originally intend to link to my portfolio, but I receive comments requesting that information - would be post be in violation?
11
Kolaru•

I’m not a mod but to address point 2, there’s an overwhelming number of “oh I had this commissioned” from accounts that are effectively just a second hand advert. Same difference, filter them out asap.

Point 3 is literally an advert yes.

11
patchy_doll•

If both of your points were enforceable, though, would the only non-comm art be work done by someone who never takes commissions?

Point 2 - If there are people circumventing the comm tag by making throwaways to advertise, that's a separate problem. I want to see art that people commission that they love enough to share, and artists deserve credit.

Point 3 - You are saying posting any of my artwork is an advertisement, even if my intent is not to solicit commissions/I'm not taking commissions at the time? Or is its only way to qualify for not needing a comm tag to refuse to link to any of my portfolios, even if I'm not taking commission work?

2
Kolaru•

Yeah, any comm, wether posted by buyer or seller, should be tagged. It’s incredibly annoying seeing the literal non stop anime character spam. Credit them, absolutely, but tag it so the posts can be filtered out.

If you have your portfolio and/or commissions linked it is by default an advert. If at any point commissions get brought up, advert. You specifically may not intend it with that post, but it would inevitably end up like “oh look at this thing I drew, I guess I’ll just link to my commission page if you want to see more, wink wink”

1
patchy_doll•

I don't think it matters what the style is - not saying I'm here for the anime spam, I certainly don't enjoy a lot of shared art either and I'm looking forwards to the implementation of this rule and will be one of those who reports violating posts.

Titles cannot be edited after a post is submitted. If I post my art and the required whatever-word comment with no mention or links to anything that suggests I take commissions, but someone asks, "do you have social media?"... what am I supposed to do? Repost entirely with the title tag? Ask them to PM me? Ignore them? Would an artist even be able to say "You can see more of my work here:" with a link to social media, if they do not do commissions, because any exposure is advertisement?

Again, wholly agree with rules to limit exhausting advert posts, but from what you're saying... what art posts wouldn't require the comm tag? I'm still interested in a mod addressing my questions, as interesting as this discussion has been.

4

The fuck does anime have to do with this.
Just a weird jab and absurd gatekeeping out of nowhere.

0
Drigr•

I disagree with your stance on point 2. I've been working with an artist on commissions for over a year now. I pay for the commissions because, while I have the vision, I don't have the art skills to back it up. Why is your stance that the art I have custom created for my world be filtered, while "random image I found online" wouldn't be? It also ends up restricting things to the point where the only people who are allowed to share art here is the small percentage that can actually create art themselves. I'm curious, based on the stance of - no AI, no commissions, no commissioned - what art do you think should be allowed?

1
Kolaru•

Anything that is not transparently an advert, which is what 95% of commission posts are

4
IamfivebearsOPMODNeon Disco Golem DMPC•

We can certainly work on the wording to make it more straight-forward for everyone!

All three of your examples would require a [Comm] tag. We're taking a 100% hardline stance at the beginning that everything even touching commissions requires a [Comm] tag. In the future we may be able to introduce some nuance, but at the beginning everything will require the tag.

::EDIT:: In re-reading this, it looks like your third example would actually not require a [Comm] tag. Linking to a site where you have commission information, without actually mentioning commissions anywhere in the post, would not require a tag. Quite frankly, we as mods do not have the time or inclination to police every link.

If you link to anything in response to users questions, that counts the same as if you mentioned it in the main description. If your description has no links, but then you provide links in another comment responding to a user, that makes your post promotional. If you mention commissions in reply to a user, that requires the [Comm] tag. If you say something like, "check my profile" or "see one of my other posts" then that DOES NOT make the post promotional.

4
patchy_doll•

Thank you for clarifying, I certainly appreciate the broad enforcement as it's being introduced.

So I can only post my art without the [Comm] tag if I actively ignore any request by comments to see more of my work, regardless of whether or not I'm taking commissions?

2
IamfivebearsOPMODNeon Disco Golem DMPC•

I've edited my previous comment to clarify the position we're taking. Let me know if you still have any unanswered questions.

1
patchy_doll•

Ahh, thank you so much! I think that's a very reasonable position to take.

2
Drigr•

So realistically, the mod stance is now "only people who can create art themselves don't deserve to be filtered." It's not the art that makes me want to see less commission fishing, it's that they post it to 50 subs trying to get money and don't actually care about the communities they're posting in. That's a night and day difference from the person who pays an artist to create the art that they cannot and who wish to share it with others in the community it was created for.

-1
yeetyfeety32•

No it's, stop having advertisements on the sub without interaction without a way to filter it out. If you get a commissioned piece then you can still post it, but just can't link a page of who did it or direct people to their social media if it has commission info.

3
patchy_doll•

u/Iamfivebears Sorry to bother you directly. I'm still interested in seeing moderation's answer to some questions I asked; I discussed them a little with another user but I'd like to make sure I better understand the rules in case I want to post my art in the coming year. Thank you!

2
DuoVandalRanger•

Good choices

9
behemothbowks•

Fuck yeah!

9
Ace_Ruffles•

YESSS. Thank you for announcing this, it really makes me feel a lot better in general to see a change like that introduced. I legitimately feel uncomfortable interacting with AI creations so that helps a lot

8
NoxSyndrome•

Thank God. Much prefer seeing art coming from actual artists, here. Not AI. Great call.

8