unseenboxUSA•

I've watched a lot of this show called Air Disasters, and sometimes the theory/thinking changes a lot during the course of the investigation. This investigation will take some time to be completed, and right now we're only in the preliminary stages. Yesterday everybody knew it was a Ruzzian missile, and now today everybody knows it was Ukrainian AA, and who knows what we might learn about the situation tomorrow.

I think it's really important not to get too conspiratorial about the process of reviewing the evidence and coming to a conclusion about the cause. It may be one we dislike, but there's no reason to believe anyone is intentionally lying (except Ruzzia), so much as not knowing the complete picture yet.

30
IchbinsderTodGermany•

You are literally gigachad. Not switching to any side or conspiracy before everything is fully investigated.

2
unseenboxUSA•

I'll take an L because I straight up thought it was Ruzzia yesterday, too. But that's why I'm just a random person talking on a subreddit and not a member of NATO. :P

11
HelperNoHelper•

Any reasonable person would assume it was ruzzia, it was right in the middle of a barrage of nearly a hundred ruzzian missiles and they are known to have serious defect and error potential.

8
unseenboxUSA•

Right, and since Ukraine was almost certainly tracking a Ruzzian missile in the area so they could hit it, that explains why Ukraine was/is really convinced about it, too.

3
shibiwanUSA•

The current narrative we have seems like it was designed to defuse tensions. Investigations are still ongoing and based on some of the evidence retrieved, it looks like a Russian Kh-101 cruise missile and not an AA missile, contrary to the preliminary report that was released.

Perhaps that information will never be released.

2
IchbinsderTodGermany•

But how bad is that? Are we really that afraid of a inferior superpower that we have to keep the reality of russian aggression against poland secret? I don‘t get it. NATOs fundamental rule is the defending of every ally state of any absolutely any attack or aggression. And to possibly break that rule because of fear of russia gives very good perspectives of how the future will be for europe if we can‘t count on our Nato alliance to actually help us when we are in danger.

4
Ask_Me_Who•

Russia being weak is actually bad in the prospect of war, because the breaking point for nukes is generally accepted to the the point at which one side feels an existential threat to its existence. With Russia's modern military already practically defeated and only a (very large) conscript force remaining, almost all of whom are currently engaged in a slow defeat against Ukraine, any NATO direct action would represent a direct existential threat.

This was almost certainly not a deliberate strike, so escalating from it isn't worth the cost or risk involved... but NATO can't say that out loud because it would open a door for deliberate provocations being made without response - and in geopolitics at this scale being consistent and vocal is the key to legitimacy, that's why nobody takes Russia's repeatedly claimed and violated 'red lines' seriously.

Defusing the situation with a nice calming narrative about 'maybe Ukrainian misfire?' steps NATO back from the escalation without admitting they've stepped back from prior promises to respond to any violation of NATO territory. The preferred option would likely to have been Russia admitting it was an accident, which is why Russia was called to make a statement so early, but Russia refused to deescalate the situation because they're Russia.

0
DJwalrus•

People are just fucking sick and tired of Russian antics and state sponsored terrorism. Specific facts are becoming less important.

Not saying I agree with this...but I understand the reaction.

1
Floofyboy•

Correct me if i am wrong guys, but why is this "likely" news being treated as the confirmed truth? Sounds like it isn't 100% proven yet where it came from, and Ukraine itself does not seem to agree with this conclusion.

6
ToCool74•

The question I mainly have is why are some of the people here treating it as if it's not possible and then throwing out conspiracies? This isn't out of the realm of possibilities and this kind of thing happens in war. All it takes is for debris from some of those 7 confirmed missiles over Lviv to fall into Poland as a result of Ukraine shooting them out of the sky in defense, the brunt of the blame is still on Russia but accidents do happen and if that the case own up to it and move forward.

13
unseenboxUSA•

Turns out even if you intercept a Ruzzian missile, all that debris still has to go somewhere.

3
Responsible-Earth674Bulgaria•

What bugs me is that they are all saying the "missile" but there were 2 missiles. So were they both Ukrainian AA and how likely is for one of them to fall exactly over the power lines...Makes no sense and if I am right NATO is starting to look a lot more Lukashenko.

2†
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Ask_Me_Who•

This is a propaganda narrative. It steps NATO down from Art.5 while keeping the option open to blame Russia in the future if the narrative calls for it. No definative statements will be made until the various nations of NATO are assured that one narrative is more useful than the other long-term, or they're placed in a position of needing to make a firm comment on the matter. The second missiles has also been entirely forgotten from reporting to make the chance of a misfire or technical problem more likely, when the chance of two identical failures is low.

Whatever the truth, and nobody can quite agree on that, this is the politically expedient narrative for now - EDIT: instantly down to -5, and the bots are out in force to enforce this narrative as the only option.

-1†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
Ask_Me_Who•

If this is a Russian missile, NATO absolutely need to find a way of stepping back from escalation while also maintaining their hardline stance on any territorial violation being grounds for escalation. 'every inch of territory' being the previous statement. To step back from that threat would be weakness and open the door to further violations, to enact the threatened escalation for what is almost definitely isn't a deliberate provocation would be a bull-headed path to unnecessary destruction.

-2†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
J-t-Architect•

I'm a bit skeptical of the image showing the crater and a tractors trailer on its side. The crater is huge. Many, many images of similar sized craters had absolute destruction adjacent the crater. The wheels here are intact and not even melted. Seems too gentle a landing so close to such an explosion.

2
AutoModeratorMOD•

Hello u/dirkt,

This community is focused on important or vital information and high-effort content. Please make sure your post follows the rules

Want to support Ukraine? Here's a list of charities by subject.

DO / DON'T - Art Friday - Podcasts - Kyiv sunrise

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
DecapitatedApple•

What's Zelensky gonna do now lol. He openly blamed Russia within minutes of it happening. What a crazy thing to just come out and say

-11
unseenboxUSA•

If Ruzzia is launching hundreds of missiles at me and a missile lands ten feet or so from my border, yeah, I'm gonna immediately assume it was Ruzzia without any hesitation at all. Turns out he might've been wrong, but hey, so was this entire subreddit yesterday.

12
DecapitatedApple•

Massive difference between me and you saying it compared to the fucking Ukraine President. You just can't do that as a world leader based off no verifying information. And look what statements like that did to this stupid website and the internet. All the absolutely insane war hungry losers were calling for Article 5. There's been MUCH worse that's happened with no retaliation because simply no one wants an actual world war

-9
subatomicbuckeye•

Russia is still to blame. Had Russia not invaded Ukraine and fired so many missiles yesterday, Ukrainian AA wouldn’t have to fire back and cause this to happen. Russia is at fault no matter who’s missile it was

2
kris533d•

Russia IS to blame either way. Ukraine HAS to shoot down every missile fired at them. Atleast they have to try. Accidents happen, BUT they wouldn't happen if Russia did not fire missiles so close to the border. Zelensky should not apologize either way. He should only offer sympathy towards Poland and the victims. I don't doubt the Polish will blame Russia either.

6
DecapitatedApple•

Yea I know that. And I know this is r/Ukraine where y’all can do nothing wrong but my point is just about Zelensky outright saying it’s Russian aggression. It’s a blatant lie that caused massive turmoil on the internet. Owning up to mistakes is ok

-9
unseenboxUSA•

I don't think it was either a blatant lie (he was acting off the information he had, which turns out might've been incorrect) or the cause of massive turmoil. What caused massive turmoil was A MISSILE LANDING IN POLAND. Zelenskyy could've said nothing and we'd still have been calling for Article 5 all night.

5
Sea_Incident3720•

There hasn't been one definitive, fact based explanation from any official, it's all "might have been", „may have happened", "likely this is what happened". We will not know. Sorry to break it to you, but you're not better than any of those other people making comments, you simply want to believe Ukraine has failed and they want to believe it's russia.

2
ThunderPreachaNetherlands•

It doesn't matter. It is like a bank robber and a guard fired at each other inside the bank and some bystander outside of the bank go hit. Whoever's bullet it was the bank robber is the one most responsible according to usual jurisprudence.

2
BansheeGator2•

Well had Russia not launched a barrage of cruise missiles, none of this would have actually happened.

So yes, Zelensky has all the open rights to blame Russia.

1