Didn't see a post on this. Doors acting as loading zones

Discussion

https://youtu.be/ecgrvh4kQRU?t=1706

you can see here the door wont open for the player until the zone loads in.

did I think that the castle would be 100% seamless with no load zones? No though I do think a zone like that should start a bit further back from the door.

Posted Nov 17, 2022, 4:27 AM UTC · edited

4457
nvrfndme:Hufflepuff: Hufflepuff•

the more i look at this sub the more i confused. do guys ever saw a videogame in your life? this shit existed since last generetion

140
Elden-Cringe:Gryffindor: Gryffindor•

Like even God of War Ragnarok, that barely received any review scores less than 10, has a good deal of hidden loading screens that are pretty obvious to most longtime gamers.

53
kidprodigy205:Gryffindor: Gryffindor•

Well most of the Wizarding World fan base have never played video games before so it'll likely be their first time. There's literally so many people getting a console just to play this game so they don't know how video games work like that

19
MyFavoriteDinoSpino:Ravenclaw: Ravenclaw•

Yea and I bet it will be those people that actually complain the least because they are going in with no real expectations. They don’t know what is possible. It’s the long time gamers that seem to be complaining about every tiny detail and have seem to suddenly forgotten how video games work

30
kidprodigy205:Gryffindor: Gryffindor•

Yeah most hardcore gamers do that and idk why lol

7
Donshio•

Because they actually expect some quality in the way the game runs ?

1
CoconutNL•

Im actually guessing the opposite because those people also dont know the limitations or what to expect and be dissappointed that certain things are not added or not perfectly realistic

5
MyFavoriteDinoSpino:Ravenclaw: Ravenclaw•

Idk from what I have seen new gamers are always just amazed by everything

6
ShatterUSNWOP•

Observing's not complaining

-2†
mikesstuff:Gryffindor: Gryffindor :LeakyCauldron:•

Yeah, good call. I always love seeing how devs hide loading screens. I do think on PS5 and powerful PCs that you won’t notice it at all.

4
bbgr8grow•

I kinda doubt that. You’re saying the Wizarding world is more popular then video games?

-1
kidprodigy205:Gryffindor: Gryffindor•

Absolutely not. You misunderstood me

2
Darkwing_Dork:Hufflepuff: Hufflepuff :LeakyCauldron:•

Most games hide them better. For example, in Jedi Fallen Order they'll have you slowly squeeze through a crack in the wall while it loads the next area so it is more seamless. Just locking the door and keeping you from opening it until the loading is done then having it swing open is a bit jarring.

They need a loading screen, no one is contesting that. The issue is how seamless it's integrated could be improved on. Maybe some sort of animation to slowly open the door to act as a buffer.

2†
TwizzledAndSizzled•

Strong disagree. The hidden loading screens that have you slowly push through a crack is jarring and even more obviously about loading to me than a door that takes a second to open.

10
ImaginationProof5734:Ravenclaw: Ravenclaw•

Whilst I think the Fallen Order style slow transition through a crack is pretty obvious it at least makes sense to have to be slow which reduces it's breach of immersion

A door delaying opening before it lets you through is really jarring unless there is an obvious reason (like a security check). If you need to load at a door make it open slowly or have you unlock it with alohamora etc .

1
Trickybuz93•

It’s a hidden loading screen. Lots of games use it, especially last gen. It’s probably going to be a lot more noticeable on PS4/Xbox One than PS5/Xbox Series X|S

60

It is, you have to sit and wait a couple seconds every-time you try to go through a door.

2
xxxMAZOKUxxx•

Indeed, I've also experienced a bit of a delay when trying to speak to someone. The game takes a few seconds after pressing X before the conversation begins.

1
Busy_Access_5892•

Is there no way to fix this? the amount of doors I have to go through just to travel between locations is brutal. Sitting 10 seconds each time adds up and is almost ruining the experience. Still better than games like Skyrim but I didn't know the experience I'm xb1 would be THIS bad

2
layyxa•

okay thank god it isnt just me . some people are saying its only 1 or 2 seconds but for me its like 20 seconds which is really annoying because of the amount of doors in this game and the game takes quite a bit to render so sometimes everybody will just be blobs of color ahhh im not patient so this is killing me

2
Busy_Access_5892•

Waiting for it to load when I go through two doors between corridor hallways that are 10 steps away is tough. I get it's not bad relative to other games but I thought it would be seamless. Time for a new gen console I guess

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
NataliaaTe:Ravenclaw: Ravenclaw•

I noticed but dont think anything bad about it, I can wait 1 second 😄.

54
sigmaocelote•

Do you expect your playstation to be able to keep the whole gargantuan castle loaded at all times? These things are smart choices, lods and progressively loading zones make a game with great graphics be playable. The game's magic, your pc or console isn't.

26
TacoMasters:Invitation: Your letter has arrived•

It has become abundantly clear that Hogwarts itself is going to be extremely detailed. Therefore, it makes virtually no sense for the game to render every room at the same time.

Talk about one way to kill performance.

8

Its the Switch version fault , the game is not that good looking to need loading between doors lol

-2
TacoMasters:Invitation: Your letter has arrived•

That's not how games work.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Arrogant_facade:Slytherin: Slytherin•

I honestly can’t say I noticed any noticeable pauses at the doors for loading.

I noticed the lighting change and realised it was probably a hidden loading sequence, but to me it looked relatively seamless?

24
ENLOfficial:Gryffindor: Gryffindor•

Watch the part of the video op linked. I at first thought they were talking about the flash of light at some doors (which will likely be fixed on release) but they’re actually talking bout a loading icon that appears at some doors.

12
marcio785:Gryffindor: Gryffindor•

I think this will be about seamless come release, this might just be a short performance issue. I do hope so.. I believe loading screens should be something of the past. I am fine with a 2 minute loading screen, if I get to play seamlessly afterwards. Looking at you RDR2!

13
sev-snape:Hufflepuff: Hufflepuff•

Also, the gameplay recorded for the "live" stream was recorded months ago.... So lots of things could have and will have changed

13
LeCaptainPootis15•

I've seen a few people mention this, but is there any credible sources?
The character in the playthrough was the character that XpectoGo designed in the beginning of the playthrough (at least they look similar), so that would mean it was recorded live. Or am I missing something?

4
sev-snape:Hufflepuff: Hufflepuff•

It was recorded live, but not at the time of the livestream, it was recorded live a couple months ago, according to expectogo himself ;) so no idea why i'm getting downvoted for just stating a fact. I think they could've and will have changed some minor things in the months between and leading up to february 7th

17
WimJongeneel•

But will this change? I feel that how you load the map is a very fundamental and architectural choice, not something you just swap out in the last months (or even year) of development. Its not like adding some more idle animations to the common room NPC's or speeding up the lip sync.

1
Relinge:Hufflepuff: Hufflepuff•

That’s only a concern if it was actually a loading screen that people have picked up on. It seems to be more of a stutter, especially when you watch it at slower speeds. In one case the pc jumps back by a single frame.

1
sev-snape:Hufflepuff: Hufflepuff•

You could be right, or this was a temporary fix because they were on a devbuild. Could go a million different ways i guess. I'm still extremely pumped to play this!

0
Morgan_713:Slytherin: Slytherin•

You mean when he stopped at the door while they were talking then carried on and went through the door no problem ? You guys love to try nit pick stuff and stir shite

10
IAmTaka_VG:Slytherin: Slytherin•

I mean it's very clearly paused for a loading screen but who the fuck cares. It's a video game, shit needs to be loaded into memory.

2
ShatterUSNWOP•
1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
real_dado500:Slytherin: Slytherin•

what if it is autosave icon?

5
PepperjackJig•

Pretty sure it is

7
ENLOfficial:Gryffindor: Gryffindor•

Based on what?

0
ENLOfficial:Gryffindor: Gryffindor•

It times up perfectly with the door animation and doesn’t show up again even after completing tasks. So probably not.

1
miskos3:Ravenclaw: Ravenclaw•

It showed up after he got the field guide page. It's definitely an auto save

4
Trickybuz93•

The auto save trigger would usually be after you step through, not before

-3
SthGr•

Autosave more than often happens when you stop moving, which is exactly what transpired in that moment

2
RunsonCoffee96•

If you want your platform to catch fire, overloading your ram and graphics card with no load zones is a surefire way to do it.

6
Strong_Actuator_3380:Ravenclaw: Ravenclaw•

It just looks like Andrew stopped walking for a second. The loading icon popping up from time to time is very normal in video games.

5
SthGr•

I think it's an auto save icon actually.

15
Strong_Actuator_3380:Ravenclaw: Ravenclaw•

You're right! Sorry, I didn't know what to call that icon haha

5
Lmeryoul_Lmeghboun:Ravenclaw: Ravenclaw•

yea saw that and I expected them to do exactly just that. Half Blood Prince game did the exact same thing and I don't think we could have the same level of detail in the castle without those load zones.

I think that's the only time during the showcase where they had to stop. all other doors opened seamlessly, or it felt that way to me.

5
RoyalPersona:Gryffindor: Gryffindor•
4
Darkwing_Dork:Hufflepuff: Hufflepuff :LeakyCauldron:•

I like how in your post you say that you know load zones need to exist, but just think it is implemented poorly. Yet you have people in the comments acting like you're asking there to be no loading buffers at all.

2
ShatterUSNWOP•

<3

0
W9Deaner1996•

For me it's taking anywhere from 5 to 30 seconds open a door not annoying really but slightly irritating just hoping a future update helps xbox one/PS4 but it just got released so again not a big deal

2
Crazylamph1:Ravenclaw: Ravenclaw•

Why don't they just make the open door animation slower?

1
bbgr8grow•

Yeah it’s called the god of war special

1
Gloria_64:Hufflepuff: Hufflepuff :LeakyCauldron:•

Some Hidden loading zones just like Raise of the Tomb Raider

1
ExtraHotPepperoni•

Remember when OOTP Wii game had no loading screens and full open-world Hogwarts to explore? It was slow af and the graphics left a lot to be desired. I don't care about waiting an extra second if the castle looks so unbelievably beautiful.

1
Imadummyboi•

I feel like they'll be able to fix it in time so that it happens well before you even reach the door but I agree they should be loading further out to be better prepared for the player wanted to pass through. The fact that they coded a little loading icon for it tells me they're not expecting to eliminate it entirely especially from old-gen.It's hard to say though because their games build was extremely basic and definitely not optimized. At first I thought players were being told not to leave the castle area to avoid spoilers but now I think it was more that they probably didn't load in any assets out in the world other than around the castle and the linear story quest to make things run smoother.With that big random update the other day to the xbox pre-loaders, no doubt a lot has already improved.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1