Game freak needs to go back to pixel art

Discussion / Venting

Game freak needs to make a return to pixel art. There is no excuse for these new 3-D titles to look as they do, play as they do, perform as they do, other than the fact that they have no working idea on how to build a 3-D title. Every single large 3-D title from them has been an embarrassment, especially the ones on the switch. I don’t see why they couldn’t keep the original style of Pokémon while simply continuing to adapt, innovate, and flesh out sprites and pixel art technology. It’s what they were good at, it’s what they knew how to do perfectly. I don’t see why they needed to move to 3-D so badly if the games were only going to suffer.

Posted Nov 18, 2022, 8:04 AM UTC · edited

10765
Machokeabitch•

I just want them to port over heart gold to switch. Is that too much to ask for?

37
airpods12•

The monkey’s paw curls

30
oneofthescarybois•

They port over HGSS but it's at 10fps and every qol update is bugged or removed.

18
KiraCumslut•

Now with extra bdsp 3d chibi!

8
Ciclon92•

And everything after johto elite4 removed

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
flcn_sml•

I disagree, Scarlet and Violet are better then SW/SH so far.

16
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
flcn_sml•

I never said looked better. 🤔

-6
Murky_Spring_5070•

with all due respect, you replied to a post SOLELY talking about how the games looked claiming sword and shield was better. The ONLY assumption is you were talking about the graphics because that is the only thing the OP was talking about. Or you didn’t read the post lol

10
Wurmple_is_Cool•

I'd love to see a new Unovan game (be it 3, legends like, or a remake of 1 and 2) be done in a hand drawn style, like that'd be so cool! It'd essentially be super high resolution sprites!

15
Ghostofabird•

Gens 3-6 are looking more and more like the Golden Age. Getting rid of indoor spaces is the most ridiculous design decision.

Remember how deep hoenn sinnoh and unova felt? Then X/Y came along and revamped things without taking away too much. Since then it seems like 1 step forward, 2 steps back....

(Although I did really enjoy ultra sun nuzlocke)

15
mrsinger186Pokemon Insurgence Music Director•

Exclude Gen 6 from this and you’d be right. Gens 3-5 have created the best games. Platinum, B2W2… HGSS (as much as I dislike the game, it has a ton of content in it).

3D modeling and its consequences were a disaster for Pokémon mainline games.

6
Ghostofabird•

Really? I've played since yellow and I think x/y might be the best the series have to offer.

The story not so much, but Kalos in general has something for everybody, megas seem to be overwhelmingly the most popular "new-age" pokemon mechanic, and the gen 6 roster is stacked with an overall solid list of mons including my personal favorites dragalae and talonflame

I see it as the best bridge between OG 1-4, tween 5, and new age pokemon 6-9

2
mrsinger186Pokemon Insurgence Music Director•

I see where you’re coming from; I was just wholly disappointed by it. 3D models looked bad and washed out, the region felt incomplete, and I didn’t really care for most of the new mons. Good for you that you enjoyed XY, I just didn’t like it.

2
Smugg-FruitEasy EVs and IVs For Eevees•

Unova and Kalos had top-tier interior variety.

I'm still shocked Lumiose City has as many interior spaces as it does.

5
Ghostofabird•

Don't get me wrong! Kalos was my absolute favorite and peak new pokemon vs old

1
Ivaryzz•

I loved gen 5 and still do, but let's not forget how a big amount of the community hated those games for years. Sometimes it is just like this ''new=bad''.

Scarlet and Violet just need to be optimized to play at 30 solid FPS, because I don't necessarily think they are bad pokemon games. Let's see if they can patch this mess.

3
TheEdes•

Lmao the opinion has been shifted to gen 6 good now

-3
CoolMintMC•

Just because XY didn't get a sequel/third version & were just okay, ORAS are genuinely amazing games yet still are a part of Gen 6.

Everyone is biased, but ORAS oozes features & polish, that's NOT an opinion.

1
fresh6171•

gens 3-6 are massively overrated on pokemon reddit... a lot of fans got driven out by the repetitiveness of them so all you have left is people who stuck with it through the absolute garbage all of those gens were or people who were too young to care. There's a reason gen 1 and now recent gens are the biggest the games have ever been.

-8
D4RKNESSAW1LD:150::094:•

Instead of trying to copy the BOTW engine, they should have just used 3D + pixel art type of style. Then I think they’ll get it.

13
rictopher•

I thought Let's Go was solid. The only issue with that game is the fact it's limited to Gen 1 Pokémon and doesn't give the option to fight wild Pokémon for those that prefer it.

So they're clearly capable of making decent 3D games, but for some reason everything past let's go has been a disaster. Must be some kind of internal pressure to spit out main line games faster, because the let's go spin off was great.

13
PostModernPerseus•

Let's Go! Isn't a spin off.

0
ZVAARIVillain number one•

sadly that would not be acceptable to investors. I'm not sure people would even accept it in 2022. I'm sure the games would be better technically but this was never a viable direction.

The problem lies in their lack of time and resources investment, they could definitely make these games run normally if management let them. If the devs aren't competent enough, they should get training, not be belittled. The entire issue has always lied with TPCi

6
trademeple•

I don't really care who makes the games there are some really good rom hacks with good features despite not being made by Nintendo/gamefreak yeah they are pretty much gba graphics' but you can't really except any thing better as they are only made by 1 or a few people in their spare time. Only thing we can really do is make it ourself even if that means going back to pixel art to make it even manageable to make.

-1
ZVAARIVillain number one•

this is much more complicated than making a romhack, we're talking about a multi million international franchise here. Strictly speaking about the games, when you make a feature there are a whole bunch of processes you must follow that someone making a romhack doesn't have to adhere to, not to mention that they are often building on top of already existing work. Game Freak is under a lot of constraints that we just don't see, and whoever gets to work on Pokemon will have to follow these same guidelines (and they probably won't get through them any faster).

Now is there a feature problem with the games? Probably. It's true that romhacks have offerings that are often far more in line with what players want than the mainline games do. But the "core" playerbase is not the main playerbase, and that's taken into consideration whenever they design the games. I agree that they are somewhat tonedeaf and that fresh blood at Game Freak would do them some good, but it's sadly not as easy as making a romhack. It takes months, maybe years to write a design document and it's often hard to go back and make changes, which again is not a problem you have when you're making a romhack.

As for the graphics, I guarantee you the quasi-totality of the playerbase would not like going back to sprites. There are kids out there who were born at the same time as X/Y, and they might not even know what we're talking about. I would be totally fine with a side game made this way like Sonic Mania was, but the future does not belong there. Which would be a much more convincing argument if Game Freak could make their games run at all these days, but they're not quite there

In the end I agree with you that we're only gonna get what we want if we make it ourselves. Romhacks like Pokemon Unbound, Delta Emerald and such offer an experience that is much closer to what the people here would want. I wish TPCi would actually understand that and work with the community, but alas this is a japanese multinational company. No dice.

tl;dr administrative processes suck

4
CoolMintMC•

Corporate greed spares NOTHING.

You can have the most skilled developers & the best technology, but TPC in this case couldn't give a single fuck less even if they tried.

All the devs have probably been sucked lifeless of their passion for game development because of the higher-ups making the worst decisions for a video game you've ever seen.

Said decisions might be amazing for making a ton of profit, but it has a VERY REAL COST of the games' quality & the passion/sanity of all the people who work hard to develop these games.

1
Slade4Lucas•

Because the benefits of being in 3D outweigh the issues they have had. Pokemon feel more tangible in 3D which makes it easier to connect with them. And PLA gave plenty of reason why it could be excellent in terms of gameplay. Going back to pixel graphics would improve nothing and would gut the games of much of the improvements they HAVE made.

5†
Tarzan_OIC•

Counterpoint: Stardew Valley has the most hours on my switch and I'm deeply connected to the NPCs and world of that game

16
Slade4Lucas•

And Pokemon isn't Stardew Valley.

Yes, pixel art games can have characters and a world you connect with, old Pokemon titles did. But Pokemon thrives on the connections you make with Pokemon and since the introduction of 3D, it is a standard to have not just fully animated Pokemon that feel more like real, alive creatures, but you also have side modes where you can pet them, feed them, wash them, play with them, watch them running around or just watching them interact with each other. All of this really builds to your bond with your Pokemon as they feel more like friends, or pets. Taking it back to 2D would make all of that so much less effective and thus harm that area of the game.

3†
SGRiuka•

Do they feel more alive? Multitudes of people dont participate in the petting minigames and the 3D models in battles mostly just have a basic pose. The sprites have a ton of life put into them and I think you're really underestimating how effective 2D animation can be.

7
Tarzan_OIC•

Yeah the 3D animations are not expressive and are all kind of dead eyed. Sometimes simpler is better. I love my Stardew farm animals and roommate Krobus.

1
Slade4Lucas•

With the 3D models you can see their movements, their normal idle movements. The BW sprites don't do a good job at modeling realistic idle movement and so they are more animated in their idle, but they don't feel more alive. They feel more like... Well, moving sprites. The 3D models attack, they react, they BREATHE, all those things that make them feel much more tangible. The 2D sprites in BW were effective for what they are... but they don't really feel like much more than animated sprites floating in space. It isn't anywhere near the same as something in 3D space, acting and reacting like a real, living, breathing creature would.

-5
Wurmple_is_Cool•

And Pokemon isn't Stardew Valley.

As someone who spent half of my most recent oras play through caring for berries and being sad that your neighbor doesn't say anything new after the Delta episode, I strongly disagree.

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Slade4Lucas•

That's great for you if you get a lot out of it, but that isn’t the focus of the franchise and it wouldn't be better for most people if it was.

-4†

If they never made the leap to 3D models in that Pokémon app for 3DS, I wouldn’t have minded Pokémon just staying pixel creatures. We received a Pokémon movie with beautiful models and that would forever be my favorite Pokémon movie. (Detective Pikachu oust Pokémon 2000 for the top slot). The movies would be enough to satisfy seeing 3D Pokémon. The medias have their different art forms still, so it’ll be unique. The anime, pixel monsters, 3D animated movies/live action.

4
Rubyruben12345:758::416::542::609::713::658:•

GF cannot gives us good 3D and performance, but if they return to pixelart, I highly doubt it would be beter than nowadays pixelart.

Pokémon's graphics have never been the best, it's just that using pixelart was less noticeable, but there are much better looking games on GBA and NDS.

4
sisho88•

I disagree, the Pokemon look amazing this go around. Sure some of the environment leaves a bit to be desired, but I'm here for Pokemon, not hyper realistic, beautiful environment.

2†
G3Kappa•

How does a bike with legs look amazing. It's worse than trubbish

1
oneofthescarybois•

People gas up Breath of the wild but go look at those trees and grass again. Tbh they look like shit too and people just have a hard on for BOTW.

-2†
w0mpers:683: •

Finally someone says it.

-4
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
YoRHa2B_•

Let's be real OP, I don't think Gamefreak will ever go back to pixel/2D art at all. I do miss the 2D style but I don't really mind the move to 3D anymore

1
blukirbi•

Or someone could just do a pixel-art (I know TemTem is a thing, but supposedly it's too different apparently, plus it's not pixel based) Pokemon-like game kinda like how people made "Wargroove" (Advance Wars) and "Bug Fables" (Older Paper Marios) ... and just alter it enough so it doesn't scream Pokemon and get C&D'd.

1
mercuric_drake•
1
blukirbi•

I've heard the name before, but haven't seen screencaps/footage

1
Lastyz•

I think the Pokemon look great in this game, are textured well and show lots of personality. There's many complaints about this game but I feel this is easily the best the pokemon have looked since HG/SS. I didn't like the way B/W and BW2 looked pls dont hate me.

1
FrostedBooty:shiny: collector •

3d/pixel art mash or just highly stylized 3d. This new game looks like an asset flip 💀

1
joshuakyle94Gen 3 Best•

I love when companies have adored and praised games for being simple and the gameplay being one of the best.

And then completely throwing it all out the window for “open world” and “3D”

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Monsterusercustomise me! :025::906::909::912:•

Sadly I don't expect them to

1

this is what I've been saying since xy. Do not care about graphics, just focus on making good gameplay & pokemon designs

1