End of the Dance, hypothetical scenario

SpoilerSpoilers Default

Let’s say Rhaenyra has already been driven out of Kings Landing with Aegon III. Joffrey and Heleana are dead. Everybody still alive hates each other. But hasn’t gone to Dragon Stone yet.

Were there any paths to victory or at least survival for her still? Such as going North? If she retook Kings Landing could she possibly hold it again after the disaster of her half year reign?

Conversely did Aegon II have a shot at victory/survival or with the Starks marching north and Sunfyre fatally injured he was a dead man walking?

Posted Nov 18, 2022, 5:03 PM UTC

187
Wadege•

If she went to the Vale instead she would have been fine, Sunfyre's mortally wounded at this point, and without Aegon III as a hostage, Aegon II probably can't retake King's Landing. Rhaenyra has tons of allies with armies at this point while the Green forces are mostly spent by this time.

19
MILF_Lawyer_Esq•

Yeah, come to think of it, all Rhaenyra had to do to win the war was go anywhere but Dragonstone. Pretty interesting.

15
Ierax29Baratheons of Storms End•

Yeah, she still has the upper hand imao.

Aegon has the Westerlands and the Hightower with more than a bloody nose, his only unscathed ally is Borros. The black have the Vale, the Riverlands and the North, the first and the latter basically unscathed at this point.

Edit : because I ignored good part of your question : No, I don't think she'd have an easy time holding King's landing after her flight, best thing she could do is to abdicate to Aegon III and use her allies troops to garrison the city while she sends pardons to the last greens, maybe in the name of Aegon so he can start building a good rep.

As for Aegon II, I don't really see him in a good spot : his only assets are the royal treasury, which I can't really see him convert in any kind of military asset (all the good merc were taken) and Borros. The best thing he could hope for is a white peace, maybe, which neither he nor his mother would propose and I don't think his enemies would accept unless Borros manged to defeat a good chunk of the Riverlands army in a field battle before they can be joined by the Vale and by the lord of Winter fell army. Maybe then he could make peace with the River Lords, forcing the north and the Vale to naval invade, but with the Velaryons siding with the black I don't think he could do much to hold em off.

Edit #2 : Maybe Aegon II could have tried winning the Tyrells to join on his side with the promise of money/positions and a good marriage? Even if the combined Reach /Stormlands force wasn't enough to match the Riverland/Vale/North alliance they could try peace-mealing them or at the very least make them thing again about a white peace

7
Famous_End_474•

If she went to the vale, she would later meet up with Cregan and his host. It is likely she would have married him for the Harvin nostalgia

5
BlazeBitchHouse Tully•

Yeah, all the martial advantages were in her favor - all she had to do was touch down in Gulltown instead of Dragonstone. Aegon II wasn't going to kill Aegon III regardless of her position, so this goes whether he escaped with her or not.

That being said, I don't think she'd hold the throne long anyways. Half mad, paranoid, split Kingsguard, having broken the trust of her closest allies, spurned by the smallfolk, best case scenario she goes out like Aegon II or Maegor with a relatively peaceful death. Worst case scenario the dynasty ends with her after she oversteps.

2
AutoModeratorMOD•

Welcome to r/PureASOIAF!

Just a brief reminder that this subreddit is focused only on the written ASOIAF universe. Comments that include discussion of the HBO adaptations will be removed, and serious or repeated infractions may result in a ban. Moderators employ a zero tolerance policy.

Users should assume that any mention of the show is subject to removal.

If you see a comment which violates the rules, please use the report function to notify moderators!

Read our discussion policy in full.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
Turnipator01•

All Rhaneeya had to do was travel to the Vale instead of Dragonstone. From there, she could've rallied her armies and pushed back down to King's Landing. She wouldn't have faced much resistance. Sunfyre was mortally wounded and Aegon was presumed dead. The Greens remaining forces would most likely have folded; Borros, lacking any motivation to fight now that the marriage pact between Aemond and his daughter had become void, would probably return to Storm's End. Remember, the Vale and the North had been relatively unscathed from the war, so they would've been able to field a much larger host against their depleted opponents. At tyat point, her victory was all but assured.

As for Aegon, a white peace is the best outcome he could've hoped for. He should've listened to Corlys; pardoning the lords loyal to Rhanerya and marrying his daughter to Aegon the younger should have satisfied the remaining Blacks.

1