Working my way up to the 10k swing challenge. what bell?

Advice Needed

I've decided I am doing the challenge this January. I have pairs for 12/16/20kg and I am getting the point where I am in the market for a 24kg

How I have been buying bells so far is one at a time, So I had a pair of 12's and when I progressed past those I bought a 16, then another 16, then a 20 etc. Probably pretty standard how most do it. Right now I have all cast iron bells.

I am not dead set on comp or cast iron style, but does it make sense to switch to the comp style now for this size? Or should I cut the crap of rationalizing buying more gym equipment and just do it with the 20kg bell I have.

Posted Nov 20, 2022, 12:19 PM UTC

27
blrgeekcomrade swingmo•

Get an adjustable comp bell 16-32kg - will save you more money, and will let you improve technique consistently as your bell size goes up.

The only caveat is that you'll have to either use a double overhand hammer grip or do single handed swings for the 10k swing challenge

4
vartz04OP•

Good point about the grip. I do think having 1 adjustable comp and various sizes of cast iron bells in pairs is a good idea. Lots of options.

5
blrgeekcomrade swingmo•

A loadable t-handle for heavy swings (see intelligent sweet posts) is better than buying heavy cast iron bells imho. That way you can go really heavy at low cost - just go to your gym and load it with plates.

Comp bell adjustable pair is the ultimate choice if you're serious with kb work.

One way to think about it is what do the professional kb lifters use --- they don't do cast iron for very good reasons..

2
anima99•

Personally, I'd recommend cast irons until you hit 32 kg because beyond that, you'd want something more consistent in size so you can just perfect the technique.

For the 10k, if two hands, a 24 kg should be a good challenge if you regulary do double 20s. Single swings, I'd revert to a 20 because 24 kg for 10,000 single arm swings and your body's not used to a 24 yet, that won't be good.

2
vartz04OP•

That's more or less what I was thinking, but wasn't sure what the best weight was to make the switch. Does that apply for everything or just swings?

I'm only doing two handed swings with a single 20kg right now. I feel like I could do heavier but not for 500 reps a day yet.

1
anima99•

It's a personal take, but I'd like to think it applies to everything, especially cleans and snatches.

The issue with cast iron is the handles and size of the bell change too much that it feels like re-learning what should have been basic to you. Not to mention significant changes in size can mean forearm bruising, a weaker grip/hold, and possible shoulder banging when you're starting out.

You can make an argument for cast irons over 32 kg with two hand swings and maybe TGUs, but I'm just not a fan of using it for anything else.

With competition/sports/GS bells, the size remains the same regardless of weight, so the "feel" you have at 32 would be more or less the same even at 36 or 48. The difference would be the amount of strength and endurance, but your technique should be solid.

1
wryruss•

Looks like you are in the same boat as me. I've got 12, 16 and 20 in cast iron. I want more bells. So I've decided I want to get another 12,16 and 20 in iron to match what I have, but when I get a 24, I'll get comp style.

I might even skip the 24 and go 28. Because 2x12 is 24.

1