r/ACL•
ASDF123vr

I’m out

Probably music to a few peoples ears but I’m done posting on here.

Been fully recovered for awhile now and haven’t needed any advice or support in a long time. Playing high level soccer, stronger than before and even faster. No issues or mental blocks either. Just came back from a game where ran full speed into the box and was taken out on my surgical leg. Popped right up. 7 months post up. Been playing for a bit now with full surgeon and PT support. Still go to PT 2 times a week but fully cleared.

Tried sharing advice so many times. Acl surgery is a mess and way too many PTs and surgeons are terrible at this procedure. While this is proven over and over, people still believe just because of their title.

The medical studies are all over the place and there is no great consensus on the majority of it. When there is any study posted that contradicts what their PT or online coach told them, they dismiss it.

I have come to the conclusion that the majority here don’t want to hear that things don’t have to be like this. It seems like there is comfort in misery (maybe harsh but something along those lines).

I have said many times I only posted here still to give back. I had a great outcome and wanted to share why. Ultimately though, my reason for leaving is it gets tiring putting tons of thought, having facts to back up points etc only to be mass downvoted with no reply at all. When facts are posted with a direct link showing the facts presented are wrong, just downvote. No discussion, no open minds, etc.

For anyone finding this in the future

  • the retear rate is low. 5% or so and even in worst case estimates, the large majority end up great even if “early” return to activity. We only talk about the bad outcomes even though they are the minority

  • surgeon is number 1 most important thing. They need to be an acl expert who does 100+ min per year. Doing it for 15/20 years.

  • graft does matter no matter what anyone tells you. A great surgeon would agree and most likely only offer one specific option. Especially if young and active

  • PT is key and you have to push it. Most things don’t even stress the acl. This data is easy to find and a quality PT knows this. A poor one spreads misinformation.

  • return to sport is about rehab. Time matters but only minor. Rehab matters way more. There are many, many studies that show this but people choose to cling to the ones that make them feel better about their timeline.

  • this sub is full, I mean full of misinformation. Most advice comes from those with poor outcomes. Some have been rehabbing for years and yet they post as if they know what they are talking about. Why people listen to them is crazy to me.

  • online coaching is not a PT and proper rehab is hands on.

  • knees over toes guy is not rehab

Take your time to find a surgeon and PT who are true acl experts. Listen to them and ignore 95% of what is posted here. Including me :)

Posted Nov 21, 2022, 4:42 AM UTC

7433
Loading comments…