Can we have a thread where we talk about giant buildings and how they work?

The controlled-demo narrative is something I still encounter among leftists sometimes and it drives me fucking crazy. It seems like a lot of people understand it’s wasn’t a controlled demo but feel that trying to understand the actual mechanics are too complex unless you’re an engineer. I’m just some bitch who isn’t at all an engineer, but I’ll chime in with what I know about this situation. I hope other people will add more and better insight.

Jet fuel doesn’t burn hot enough to melt steel:

-First, the temperature of a fire is not only determined by the flash-point of its accelerant. If it were, we wouldn’t have had millennia of kilns and forges powered by wood.

  • Steel comes in different “grades” that indicate it’s strength. This is determined by how it is tempered at different temperatures. Have you ever noticed how chocolate bars are shiny and have a more snapping texture, but if you leave them on a warm dashboard they become dull and brittle? Chocolate is tempered by being heated up to the exact temperature to get this effect, there are variations of this effect in many materials. The heat from the fire undid the tempering and made it brittle, this is why it collapsed.

Swaying buildings:

Dan’s right they’re built to sway for weather and also earthquakes. Sky scrapers weren’t built until steel was invented, it’s lightness combined with strength and flexibility are what was needed to build them. The flexibility is crucial to the existence of this type of building in the first place.

Also skyscrapers are on wheels, I don’t think this is related but I just think it’s cool.

Why did the building absorb the plane and collapse downward instead of being knocked over like a domino?

Skyscrapers are built to withstand horizontal impact, wind and earthquakes are both horizontal impact. Under normal circumstances what is going to fall on top of a sky-scraper? In this case the top part of building fell downward on itself once the area around the fire buckled.

Anyways, thoughts? Can we demystify this shit?

Posted Nov 21, 2022, 6:08 PM UTC

4244
ItsJonahGee•

You sound like someone that would enjoy Well There’s Your Problem a pod about big engineering and related issues.

16
Mumblerumble•

Great recommendation. Love WTYP

6

And now is a great time to start listening because next episode is about the Tacoma Narrows Bridge Disaster!

6
StraightPorkin•

The podcast that hates you back!

Yay Liam!

3
crypticthree“You know what perjury is?”•

With slides

2
Cherenkov-EffectDoing some research with my mind•

Prrraaaaaaxxxiiiiiissss

1
thefatstoner•

As someone who works with structural engineers, i can promise that anyone advocates 9/11 conspiracy narratives has never said a single correct statemtn regarding the structural stability of buildings. They just dont get it. Theyre the same people who cant explain how a building stands up, if they cant do that, they couldnt begin to understand how one comes down

13
TheBaddestPatsyOP•

My point is that I don’t think people should assume some basic scientific literacy is out of reach for anyone who is not an engineer.

3
thefatstoner•

No i do agree with you. I thinknim one of those people. Im no structural engineer, but ive learned enough to not make a fool of myself. My point is that none of the people who argue about the structural stability know what theyre talking about, if they did they wouldnt argue it

Edit: example. One person tried to tell me that building 7 was a controlled demolition. I pulled out the engineers report on building 7 and asked them where the math is wrong, or where its a lie. They just said they wouldnt read it because it came from the government. I think im arguing its impossible to both have basic structural knowledge, and believe 9/11 was anything other than the result of 2 planes colliding with two buildings

5
anaccountthatis•

Just show them this: https://youtu.be/FzF1KySHmUA

Also, the ‘doesn’t melt steel beams’ is only half of the stupidity. Anyone who has worked in demolitions knows how absurd it is to suggest you could clandestinely rig those buildings for a controlled dem. A lot of people get unrealistic expectations as to how much explosive is required because their entire ‘knowledge’ of explosives comes from 80s action movies.

2
TheBaddestPatsyOP•

I’m from Oregon so we still have collective trauma from failed whale-demolition

6
taybay462•

To be fair, you can believe in a 9/11 conspiracy while still believing real planes flew into the buildings. Here are things I've picked up on over the years and if anyone has any info refuting them I'd be glad to hear them: I swear I read something about insurance for the world trade center being updated within like a year prior to specifically include a plane crash. Over a billion dollars was paid out. No one did anything when one of the pilots said at American training that he didn't need to know how to land. The fact that it gave the government perfect sway with the public to pass the Patriot Act, decimating our privacy. Were they taking advantage of a bad situation, or creating the bad situation? I think we can agree that the elite stoke the fires of inter-peasant conflict, the hate that was directed towards Muslims after 911 wasn't unparalleled but you get what I mean, it was intense. I've become too cynical to see that as impossible

0
boopbaboopHaving a Perry Mason moment•

I swear I read something about insurance for the world trade center being updated within like a year prior to specifically include a plane crash. Over a billion dollars was paid out.

That is untrue. TL;DR: when you buy or rent a new place, you need to get insurance for it, even if the previous owner had insurance or if other people have insurance policies for the same property (like how my landlord and I both have insurance for the same house: he has homeowner's insurance and I have renter's insurance). Terrorism was routinely included in insurance policies pre-9/11 for the same reason that pandemics were routinely included in other kinds of insurance (like wedding insurance) pre-COVID: at the time, it was considered such an unlikely event that it didn't matter if it was covered or not.

No one did anything when one of the pilots said at American training that he didn't need to know how to land.

That is definitely not true. The guy who said he didn't need to know how to land was, in fact, the only guy actually arrested, charged, and convicted in connection to 9/11, precisely because of how suspiciously he was acting.

The fact that it gave the government perfect sway with the public to pass the Patriot Act, decimating our privacy. Were they taking advantage of a bad situation, or creating the bad situation?

So, the problem with this line of thinking is that you're assuming that the point of the PATRIOT Act was to invade citizens' privacy, with "protecting Americans from terrorism" as the justification... as opposed to the point being to protect Americans from terrorism, and not caring what privacy they needed to invade to achieve that goal.

Like, which makes more sense: an entire government conspiring to fake multiple terrorist attacks (because it wasn't just in response to 9/11, it was also in response to the anthrax attacks around the same time) specifically in order to destroy privacy (presumably to control the populace for nefarious reasons), or a bunch of authoritarians making decisions out of fear and deciding civil liberties were an acceptable sacrifice to mitigate that fear?

And honestly, the biggest indication to me that 9/11 was not planned or permitted to happen in order to advance political goals is because we saw what that actually looks like. The war in Iraq had no justification beyond alleged links between Saddam Hussein and al-Qaeda and the whole WMDs thing (well, "they'll greet us as liberators," but that was definitely secondary), but the war went ahead anyway... and those justifications were easily disproven fairly quickly. I find it hard to believe that the American government would be able to either plan or permit one terrorist attack to happen with no leaks or evidence or paper trail to show it, but then be completely incapable of competently planting evidence against Saddam with the same level of security.

2
AppleEater421•

9/11 wasn't an inside job. The terrorists were just allowed to do it because the government is in the pockets of defense contractors, who knew keeping a forever war in the middle east would bring in big bucks. They needed a reason to go to war, and they found that reason in a group of Saudi Arabians who wanted to do a terrorism.

It's just like Pearl Harbor. Like, the Japanese literally sent a warning to us before hand and we ignored it.

0
Necessary_Row_4889•

The burning point of jet fuel is irrelevant when your building has been hit by a Jewish Space laser! Checkmate!!!!!

10
Rocking_the_Red•

Nobody expects the Jewish Space Laser.

3
Necessary_Row_4889•

I feel like some people do, a very specific subset of people definitely do but they are literally the only ones.

7
benbrahn•

Well There’s Your Problem is a great podcast for all things engineering disaster related. Also really funny gang on there. A little less.. tactful? Than KF but really good regardless.

They do a 9/11 episode that really helps explain it in layman’s terms

10
robotniquePolicy Wonk•

Beat me to it. I'm going to miss their annual 9/11 show presumably next year now that they've done building 7.

2
koala218•

I came here to mention the Building 7 episode. I only listened to it recently, I thought they dealt with the conspiracy theories very nicely.

3
robotniquePolicy Wonk•

Turns out you can't design a building with fire suppression that doesn't fail when the entire city water supply is cut. Or rather, you could, but it'd be insane and expensive and only worthwhile in this incredibly rare situation.

3
MJMrobotPowerful (like the State Puff Marshmallow Man)•

Engineer here: Jet fuel may not be able to melt steel beams, but it can ignite the rest of the building which can burn hot enough to turn the steel beams into al dente spaghetti. Steel beams break long before they get hot enough to turn into runny goo. I think at the temp jet fuel alone burns they loose around 50% of their structural integrity.

Steel doesn’t magically go right from hefty strong to a weak sauce when it hits a specific temperature. It gets bendy and fails long before it’s soup.

8
Agreeable_Hall458“fish with sad human eyes”•

Yeah, so I’m not a structural engineer, but I do have a degree in physics. Your point about forges and kilns is spot on. The impact wasn’t enough, but a fully loaded 747 can carry over 60,000 gallons of jet fuel. It most likely had already burned off a good bit before impact, but even 10,000 gallons of liquid jet fuel, pouring out of damaged tanks, seeping through the infrastructure and then catching on fire in what amounts to a large concrete forge is gonna weaken some things. I can get steel hot enough to bend in my little home forge with just wood - imagine what jet fuel could do. And all it has to do is bend enough, in enough places, that the top of the structure comes crashing down on the bottom part. FFS, it’s not rocket science.

7
Agreeable_Hall458“fish with sad human eyes”•

And yes, I was screaming at my radio in the car this morning while listening to the podcast.

6
Nuds1000•

Also more to this point, this was 2001. Those offices looked like the movie office space with beige ass printers, pcs and most importantly PAPER records and forms. Filing cabinets full of them. Whole floors of record storage. There were a lot of things that caught on fire from the jet fuel and continued the burn time. Also fire retardant coatings for the steel beams in the elevator shaft had been falling off from the elevators moving parts. Steel doesn't need to melt like others have said you just need to cook it for awhile and you get a different strength rating.a

3
Agreeable_Hall458“fish with sad human eyes”•

That’s kinda the point - there are dozens of reasons why it is totally plausible that it would happen. And there are none that back up the bullshit that it couldn’t. I grew up a few hours from NYC. Had been to the twin towers several times - there was a restaurant at the top of one of them with good food and a view. Those towers were icons, and more than that we all knew people that worked there. My uncle was supposed to work there that day doing some construction, but missed his train. He only got halfway there before they shut down the subways. He had to walk home - to Long Island - because that was the only way to get out. My Dad is a truck driver and was making weekly deliveries to lower Manhattan at that point. Us kids couldn’t get through to my Mom or Dad for hours to see if he was in the city or not - because the phone lines were so overloaded. Thankfully he wasn’t there that day. But that shit was real to a lot of us. I don’t put myself in the Sandy Hook parents class of anguish by a long shot - but I have a glimmer of understanding of the anger one experiences when someone takes something devastating and turns it into a bullshit conspiracy theory to get off on and make a few $.

5
pinko-perchikGremlin-Wraith•

Actually, given that the planes took off from Boston and were supposed to be heading to LAX, they would’ve still had most of their fuel on board

3
Agreeable_Hall458“fish with sad human eyes”•

Yeah, I’ll admit I didn’t really go back and check and just did a “even if it was the best possible case, that’s a fuck ton of fuel” - since they never run anywhere near empty to allow for weather redirects, etc. But yes, it was probably closer to the top end.

2
sachs1•

As to the pancaking vs tipping bit, I think the relevant question is going to be "is the momentum of the plane, applied via a perfectly inelastic collision, enough to move the center of gravity outside its footprint." At least based on my memory of 200 level physics classes

7
TheBaddestPatsyOP•

The ability to tip at all assumes that it will be rigid enough to still have a shared center of gravity. The top part of the building sure has a lot of inertia.

2
DRZ36•

Read some of the resources on this list. But just know you’re not going to win this argument. Once you start going into the depths required to explain these points, you’ve already lost.

https://www.cfr.org/blog/seven-resources-debunking-911-conspiracy-theories?amp

3
TheBaddestPatsyOP•

I think it’s worthwhile for non-wing-nuts to understand too.

1
unitedshoes•

At this point, I'm going with "The Twin Towers were holograms. As soon as it looked like those planes were going to fly through them (after, of course, being hijacked by terrorists from the EU), they quickly scrambled to shoot the planes down and run a hologram of the buildings being hit and exploding. Obviously, everyone who claimed to have been inside the buildings was actually the subject of a government mind control experiment that took place in a top secret underground replica of a skyscraper deep beneath Mount Rushmore." It makes as much sense as any other conspiracy theory, and it's easier than explaining how skyscrapers work to stupid people.

3
eltic3•

I often see people claiming it must have been a control demolition because the towers were supposedly Designed to survive being hit by larger planes. It never seems to occur to these people that sometimes things just don't work the way they were designed to.

3

First: controlled demolition always starts at the bottom of the structure un progress upward where the towers failed were hit somewhere around their top third and then collapsed from there.

Second: the towers were designed to survive a hit from the largest planes in service at the time of their design while the planes that actually hit were significantly larger

2
Vegan-Daddiowill eat neighbors ass•

Why are they on wheels? I could look it up but you seem cool and I liked reading your post

3
TheBaddestPatsyOP•

It’s a fail-safe for earth quakes. They’re actually a bit more like giant ball bearings in the foundation, enough force will cause them to roll back and forth in the foundations. But short of a really severe earthquake, there’s not enough force to actually make them roll

4
Capillarybroom6•

Just on Dan's point about buildings moving with the wind.

Where I went to uni, the main student residential campus was on top of a hill over looking the sea. It got real windy up there.

Most of the time not an issue as the halls were mostly ugly squat 2 storey buildings. However, there was one block that was much taller. This building swayed in the wind. No one who lived in the top few floors threw flat parties as a swaying building and hammered students is a recipe for puke.

Now, this building was not as tall or sophisticated as anything that could be called a sky scraper but you couldn't tell it moved unless you were in it.

2
K0stroun•

A couple years ago I spent a night on top of a lookout tower while backpacking, we were hiding there from heavy rain accompanied with strong gusts of wind. A buddy of mine legitimately got seasick.

1

Structural steel looses about half of it’s strength at about 1250 F and the plane debris traveling through the interior basically sand blasted off all of the fire protection/insulation from the steel I beams.

the attackers specifically chose transcontinental flights so that the aircraft would have the maximum fuel onboard.

both of the main towers were of a unique construction: they did not have a central concrete core and relied on pins to hold the floors to the columns on the exterior walls which were load bearing.

once the pins holding the floors to the exterior columns failed then the columns lost rigidity and turned into long wobbly noodles which triggered a progressive pancake collapse.

This is my best understanding as a computer engineer; grain of salt and all of that.

2
TheBaddestPatsyOP•

So it wasn’t a domino, it was a Jenga

1

I would love for any suggestions as to in-depth books about the physics behind the world trade center collapse, especially something available in an audiobook format.

2
byjenamiller•

Modern skyscrapers may also have water tanks to help with swaying (I did some marketing work for the company that built Philly’s Comcast towers) https://www.inquirer.com/philly/business/20070415_Water_to_tame_wind_atop_new_skyscraper.html

2
IvanTGBT•

I think the only thing you need to point out to throw out the controlled demo thing is the sound.

Controlled demo's are loud as fuck and very distinctive. It's a series of explosions...

By the time tower 7 came down there were a tonne of media all over the city filming the area. None of them caught any sound that was anywhere near what would be required to bring down a building.

It just doesn't stand up to the most cursory analysis.

2