Can we have a thread where we talk about giant buildings and how they work?
The controlled-demo narrative is something I still encounter among leftists sometimes and it drives me fucking crazy. It seems like a lot of people understand it’s wasn’t a controlled demo but feel that trying to understand the actual mechanics are too complex unless you’re an engineer. I’m just some bitch who isn’t at all an engineer, but I’ll chime in with what I know about this situation. I hope other people will add more and better insight.
Jet fuel doesn’t burn hot enough to melt steel:
-First, the temperature of a fire is not only determined by the flash-point of its accelerant. If it were, we wouldn’t have had millennia of kilns and forges powered by wood.
- Steel comes in different “grades” that indicate it’s strength. This is determined by how it is tempered at different temperatures. Have you ever noticed how chocolate bars are shiny and have a more snapping texture, but if you leave them on a warm dashboard they become dull and brittle? Chocolate is tempered by being heated up to the exact temperature to get this effect, there are variations of this effect in many materials. The heat from the fire undid the tempering and made it brittle, this is why it collapsed.
Swaying buildings:
Dan’s right they’re built to sway for weather and also earthquakes. Sky scrapers weren’t built until steel was invented, it’s lightness combined with strength and flexibility are what was needed to build them. The flexibility is crucial to the existence of this type of building in the first place.
Also skyscrapers are on wheels, I don’t think this is related but I just think it’s cool.
Why did the building absorb the plane and collapse downward instead of being knocked over like a domino?
Skyscrapers are built to withstand horizontal impact, wind and earthquakes are both horizontal impact. Under normal circumstances what is going to fall on top of a sky-scraper? In this case the top part of building fell downward on itself once the area around the fire buckled.
Anyways, thoughts? Can we demystify this shit?
Posted Nov 21, 2022, 6:08 PM UTC
You sound like someone that would enjoy Well There’s Your Problem a pod about big engineering and related issues.
Great recommendation. Love WTYP
And now is a great time to start listening because next episode is about the Tacoma Narrows Bridge Disaster!
The podcast that hates you back!
Yay Liam!
With slides
Prrraaaaaaxxxiiiiiissss