r/GenX•
gotarock

No thanks I’d rather starve to death.

Warning: Loud
No thanks I’d rather starve to death.

Posted Nov 22, 2022, 9:43 PM UTC

464117
Randygilesforpres•

I personally love them. Not sure why, though I do like banana flavored things. So you all can send them to me!

60
plusgoodduckspeak1970•

There are dozens of us!

I actually met a woman online early last year, and we hit it off. She is the only other person I think, that I have met, that actually liked them as well. You would think that this alone would be enough to shield our love from the rest of the world, but sadly, no. Love of Circus Peanuts wasn’t strong enough.

29
ygduf•

I introduced my 6 year olds to them this year and they love them. I swear they are just banana-ish compressed cotton candy though.

I love them, personally. And they are non-newtonian. The harder you bite them the more firm they are. The candy that time forgot.

6
HHSquadAtari Wave GenXer•

Not sure why the hate, loved them also. Banana was my favorite.

7
stopexploding•

Me too. Don't drink coke after though.

6
kypd•

What's your opinion of banana flavored Moon Pies? (RC Cola optional but allowed)

5
gordigor•

Just me, but I don't like Moon pies but love Circus peanuts. Different texture I think as I generally don't care for marshmallows.

4
Boxofbikeparts•

But, but... circus peanuts are marshmallows...

1
Randygilesforpres•

I’ve never had a moon pie. gasp

2
kypd•

Treat yourself sometime. Most gas stations have them. The double decker version is the best. Those are what are usually sold single-serve. IMHO the double decker has a better texture.

2
Honeymoomoo•

Scooter pie? I think they’re very similar if not the same.

2
karenmcgrane•

I LOVE THEM

Also banana Laffy Taffy

5
squirtloaf•

Same. My grandpa introduced me to them like 50 years ago at this great store that still carried all of the candy he had loved as a child in the early 1900s. These and the Brach's jelly nougats were my favorite.

He got some white chocolate covered pretzels there that were pretty amazing too.

I went back for the first time in 25 years last year, andthat store was not only still there, but they still had bins with all of those things (with scoops. You would buy by the pound.) Was SO happy.

3

Yes, these are a nice treat sometimes. Kind of like candy corn or classic jelly beans. I think that we are quite fortunate to have such a huge diversity of candy goodness.

Has anyone done Chunky yet?

3
SunshynePower•

I never got the banana flavor, so that's a conversation for another time. I loved these things. They hurt my teeth to eat but it's easy them anyway. I can't eat then now 😭 thanks a lot IBD

1
punkminkis•
1
Randygilesforpres•

Excellent. Subbed :)

1
Shelleyan_Orphan•

These may have been amazing fresh, sadly no human has ever consumed a fresh peanut candy... ever.

28
RandoMcNoob•

As this is Reddit, I must correct you .... for I, RandoMcnoob, have eaten FRESH CIRCUS PEANUTS. My dad worked for the company that owned Brach's and could get them fresh off the line. And let me tell ya.....

they still sucked.

Like really really bad ....

38
Shelleyan_Orphan•

Love it! I appreciate the clarification :-)

12

Or without any semblance of regret.

10
Ardea_herodias_20221972•

Now we're talking bottom of the barrel!

20
Osurdum•

Candy for children you hate.

18
Organized_Khaos•

So gross.

5
pm_me__your_drama•

I love marshmallows. I hate these with every fiber of my being and became irrationally angry when someone told me that these "candies" are just marshmallows.

LIARS.

17
kypd•

Have you tried "Stuffed Puffs" or "Big Bites"? Both are delicious marshmallow treats.

https://stuffedpuffs.com/

4
pm_me__your_drama•

Oh, those look amazing! Thanks for sharing!

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
NinnuxI assure you, we are open.•

Ever try true, real, fresh marshmallows? Not the kind you buy in the store. I mean the real deal made with the root of the marshmallow plant?

They are heavenly.

1
fitbit10k1970•

Absolutely gross!

15
WildColonialGirl•

My grandma always had them in a jar with a yellow lid. I buy them sometimes when I’m feeling nostalgic.

12
Kilo_Xray•

…so that you can just put them in a jar with a yellow lid and look at them.

5
WildColonialGirl•

Lmao. No, I’m one of those weirdos who actually likes them.

7
bk15dcx•

Gramma would leave these out because she didn't have to worry about the dog eating them

12
kypd•

Personally I like Circus Peanuts. It's my granddaddy's fault.

Anyone remember those hard-candy coated "Easter eggs" that were some kind of weird gritty marshmallow inside? I think those were made by Brach's (?) Those were rough.

11
Purple-Lemur•

Yes, gross! And I got them every Easter. Ate them last, if there was no other candy in the house.

4
thesturdygerman•

Do you mean malted milk balls? Like Whoppers? I believe those are Robin’s Eggs and they are the food of the gods.

3
kypd•

Those are all delicious. It's these terrors. How can they still exist! https://staging.brachs.com/products/easter/marshmallow-easter-hunt-eggs.html

5
thesturdygerman•

Oh wow, those are disgusting. I forgot they existed. Are they still made?

4

Little puffy clouds of baby aspirin flavored nastiness.

9
One_Random_Word•

I will admit these are hot garbage, but for some reason I love them.

9
Recklen•

My vote for WOAT candy!

8
thatguygreg•

Somebody was looking for cereal ideas and came up with Lucky Charms by cutting up pieces of circus peanuts and mixing them with a bowl of cheerios.

I'm not a fan of Lucky Charms either.

8
IntrepidReader•

I think each lucky charm is one circus peanut compressed under vast amounts of presssure.

2
Expat111•

I hated those but, because we very rarely had anything that was sweet ,( e.g, candy, lucky charms or other good cereal) in the house, I'd eat them just for the sugar high. Much better than that horrible carob gorp crap and other "healthy snacks" that my mother used to give us.

8
StrawberryMoonPie•

Carob. Pfffft. I’d rather eat dirt. Bad 70s flashback.

4
IHateCamping•

I didn't mind these as a kid. I don't think I've had them since I was about 12 though.

8
Chronically_me•

I can smell this photo...and i gagged

8
Harpeigh•

Instant phantom headache here at the thought of the smell 😆

3
Chronically_me•

My sister loved them and would obnoxiously chew them around me. I always left the room because the smell serially made me nauseous lol

2
Liv-N-Lrn•

Yummy 'Nanner Goodness...... dip them in peanut butter....then, chocolate syrup.....

7
gotarockOP•

You need Jesus.

I’d rather eat styrofoam packing peanuts dipped in pb and chocolate.

13
Liv-N-Lrn•

Hahahahahaha..... When I was really young and Mom was barely making it, paycheck to paycheck, that was candy. So, I grew up liking and eating them, without knowing how hated they were.

7
gotarockOP•

Well I love black licorice, candy corn, smarties, and coors light so I guess I can’t judge you too harshly.

7
Liv-N-Lrn•

I can damage some candy corn snd smarties. Black licorice and Coors not so much. But, you take that Anise flavor, add some grape juice, as well as, alcohol and call it Ouzo, I am there. Hahahahahaha

3
Brokenlinx•

I still love them today and had no clue of the hatorade that followed them until this post.

3

My blood sugar spiked just reading this.

2
24_7_cat_party•

Someone recently clued me into the fact that these fucking nasty monstrosities are banana flavored. No wonder they are so bad.

7
thesturdygerman•

Artificial banana flavor is the grossest flavor.

3
ApplianceHealer•

I showed this post to my wife. She grabbed the phone and threw it across the room.

7
DiscoSprinkles•

gags

6