[Meta] SRD, I think we need to talk about people getting banned "just for shiggles." (link to drama in r/SRDD inside)
This is probably gonna get wordy, so I'll put the TL;DR up top:
TL;DR: A user responded negatively to the mods' prank by posting a critical comment 6 times in the deleted post. After apologizing and say it won't happen again, he's unbanned. Then u/syncretic rebans him again "just for shiggles." We have rules and guidelines in the sidebar that a lot of people agree with. The moderators can't just ban a user just on a whim, or if they do, they should be accountable for it.
I'm pretty disappointed with a ban that happened yesterday, so I'm defending one of the users against what I deem to be some pretty heavy-handed moderation. You may have seen the moderators' prank post a couple days ago, when they changed the CSS to make it look like AlyoshaV was now a moderator at SRD. Reactions were mixed, with a sizable majority being against it. GameOfTrolls tried to get in on the action by claiming they coordinated the trolling with syncretic. One user, u/MisterAndristson saw that it was only a CSS trick and decided to post this comment:
Mods deleted my comment. For a community that has a zero tolerance policy on trolls, you should be setting an example.
Click on AlyoshaV, or disable CSS. They just renamed zahlman to AlyoshaV.
I was pleasantly surprised to see that they did this, only to find out this is a troll by the mod team. Mod team, if you want to make long lasting effects, you should have actually just modded them and removed zahlman for a day.
This is kindergarten level trolling.
The moderators deleted this comment so that they could keep the joke going, so he decided to post it 5 more times in the thread. After that, he was banned. Now, whether that ban was justified or not, I won't say. Although it's annoying to copypasta the same comment over and again, there's definitely no rule against it and I think most people would agree that a warning would have been more appropriate. It was a prank post anyways, there's no reason for the moderators to be uptight when they're trolling their own users.
MisterAndristson then crossposted the SRD drama [over into r/SubredditDramaDrama](http://www.reddit.com/r/SubredditDramaDrama/comments/z3z03/mods_edit_css_to_make_zahlmans_name_in_the_mod/) and while over there has a talk with syncretic. (I'm gonna break down that conversation here, unless you want to just read it for yourself). He says he thinks the users are losers (for not seeing through the prank and because he actually likes AlyoshaV) but apologizes to syncretic couple more times. syncretic unbans him, with the message "It's cool, I unbanned you. I just wanted to make you sweat a little bit." He then asks why MisterAndristson is trying to get unbanned if he thinks everyone is losers, to which MisterAndristson replies that it wouldn't be the end of the world but he does really enjoy the reading and commenting on the drama. Then syncretic bans him again, "just for shiggles."
And that brings us here. When I saw that convo in SRDD yesterday, I reached out to the mods, hoping there would be another voice of reason that could see the guy is just getting fucked with. Only one got back, who responded that MisterAndristson should just apologize and then he'll get unbanned. The problem is, he's already apologized here, here, here, and here and one other time in modmail.
I'm not trying to bring out the pitchforks against the moderators, I'm just asking them to be a bit more fair about this whole ordeal. Beyond this one incident, I'm worried about setting a precedent that a moderator can ban any user just because they're in a trolling mood and want to fuck with somebody. Although it may seem like I'm making this some srsbusiness, the fact is I just really like SRD and don't want to see severe and subjective moderation that's based on the whims of one person. And I'm hoping that this isn't just the start to some new trend.
Posted Sep 1, 2012, 8:23 PM UTC