Payoff Car Faster or Have Bigger Downpayment?

Debt

Looking into getting a house in 2024 and was wondering if it would make any difference to go in debt free ‘paid off car’ or with an extra $7000 down payment?

The payment is currently $305 a month and my take home pay is roughly $2000 a month it’s my only debt (after my credit card is paid off next month)

If I paid the car off I’d have a down payment of around $7000 but no debt. If I don’t pay the car off I’d have a down payment of around $14000.

The interest rate on the car is only .99% and at a gross income of $33k the bank estimated I’d be looking at a mortgage of around $100k if I had 5% down.

TDLR; Is less debt or higher down payment better for getting a mortgage?

Posted Nov 29, 2022, 3:56 AM UTC

14
Some_Camp_2898•

At a$30000 income, you can take a maximum mortgage of roughly $850 a month without any other debt and $650 a month with the car loan. That’s about $175,000 with a 20% down payment ($150,000 with a 5% down payment) vs $140,000 with the car loan and a 20% down payment (about $115,000 with a 5% down payment).

$7000 is a 5% down payment on a $140,000 home. $14,000 is a 5% down payment on a $280,000 loan.

My numbers are probably slightly off but as the limiting factor is your income and not the down payment, I’d use the money to free up some income.

However, if you’re not being limited by the mortgage amount (I.e you can find the house you want in the price range you can afford while keeping the car payment), the interest on the car payment is lower than that on the mortgage so it’ll be cheaper for you to pay that.

TLDR: If you want the highest possible mortgage, pay off the car. If not, keep the car loan

2
honourEachOther•

Paying off debt usually makes a bigger impact on purchasing power but, you also need to hit that 5% downpayment threshold. For a real answer, get a pre approval from a mortgage broker that works with multiple lenders (not the branch or bank rep) to find out what you really need to get into a home. Good luck

1
powderjunkie11•

At that interest rate I'd leave the car payments as is. It's generally not advisable to go for your maximum approvable mortgage so it will protect you from yourself (in addition to getting a 4-5% ROR on that 7k in a GIC).

If you really want to set yourself up better to buy a house you could pay off your car and sell it (obviously only if you can get by without a car or with a much cheaper car)

1
Opplebot•

Having no car payment will help you get approved. $2000 /month is low to be getting approved if you have monthly payments. I would pay off the car. Then save up an extra year for a bigger downpayment

1