r/vce•
bellals

Bachelor of Computer Science vs Bachelor of Science majoring in computational science?

General Question/comment

My partner's little sister is about to start year 11 next year, and she's been struggling through maths; weighing up whether to struggle through methods next year vs just drop it.

She wants to study computer science at uni. I'm wondering if anyone who knows about this field can please tell me about the difference between Bachelor of Computer Science vs doing a Bachelor of Science majoring in computational science? Not sure if "computer science" and "computational science" are actually different entities??? Tried looking on the uni websites but it's not really clearing things up for me who has no background knowledge of this yield.

Main point is Bachelor Science does NOT require methods, whereas Bachelor of Computer Science does.

Appreciate any insights y'all can offer!

Posted Dec 2, 2022, 3:32 AM UTC

1515
JPIE1082022: Chem [50] Bio [47] 2023: Phys Meth Spesh Englang•

struggles through maths

Comp sci is traditionally maths heavy so it might not be the best fit so there should be consideration there as well.

12
bellalsOP98.55 ‖ chem tutor >5yrs•

haha I figure as much. They're not super receptive to my advice but trying my best 😂

Do you happen to know if there are any VCE subjects that reflect the kind of content she'll be in for? e.g. VCE Applied Computing? Algorithmics? Maybe a VET subject?

I just know this'll be a disaster lol

6
JPIE1082022: Chem [50] Bio [47] 2023: Phys Meth Spesh Englang•

Id say algorithmics is the most pertinent as it is literally a first year course and is credited by monash as such.

5
toogodo•

Algorithmics is extremely useful as it not only gives credit points at unimelb and monash, but also covers a lot of content from the first year and gives a great foundation for computer science as a whole.

2
Frexie99.45 || 47 MM | 44 SM | 5.0 UniMath | 45 PHY | 41 ALGO•

From speaking to some people at Monash Open Day, the major in computer science is a smaller version of the Bach. of CompSci, which allows people to do other Sci subjects as well within the Bachelor of Science.

From my understanding, "computer science" generally refers to the more theoretical ish side of working with computers, and contains a whole lot of maths. Many parts of the field are just weird maths. At monash, both the major and Bach. require subjects that have Specialist as a prereq, let alone methods, meaning she'll have to do Specialist and Methods equivalent courses in Uni either way.

If she's more interested in actually making stuff with code, building websites, applications etc, that's more Software Engineering is for, though I believe that may require Methods at many unis. Though, I am generally quite skeptical around how unis teach software eng, and a lot can be self taught online. Probably a good idea to do more research in this area.

If she wants a taste of CompSci, VCE Algorithmics is basically first year compsci, if she does end up doing compsci at monash (or a few other unis i believe), Algo will give credit for first year subjects. Though, this only requires Methods Unit 1/2.

This is all specifically about monash. There are other options aswell I think Computer Science at either Deakin or Swinburne, don't require Methods.

EDIT: Also from what I can gather, CompSci at Swinburne and Deakin also lean on the more practical side, which has less importance on maths.

6
bellalsOP98.55 ‖ chem tutor >5yrs•

Thank you so much for your detailed response! Super helpful. I will pass this info on to her :)

2
SocraticMathTutor•

Just saw this response after writing my own. I agree with everything written here. Indeed I basically spent the last 30 mins reiterating your exact opinions....

2
SocraticMathTutor•

I have two degrees in Math and an incomplete degree in CompSci, so I'm in a pretty good position to answer this.

"She wants to study computer science at uni."

If she literally wants to study computer science, she'll need a LOT of math. Most computer science seems to involve using mathematics to analyse algorithms and data structures. I wouldn't recommend taking this route without a strong math background, it'll end badly.

However, she might also be interested in software engineering, which is much more practical and requires much less mathematics. Software engineering is about things like e.g. how do you build a website? How do you build Microsoft Word? How do you build Google docs? Etc. It's largely devoid of "formal" math, as far as I can tell.

As for computational science, I think it's basically somewhere between the two in terms of its "mathematicalness". More specifically, the idea is to build mathematical models of phenomena of interest to scientists, and then write code to implement these models. After that, you use math to analyse the efficiency and accuracy of these implementations.

"My partner's little sister is about to start year 11 next year, and she's been struggling through maths; weighing up whether to struggle through methods next year vs just drop it. "

If her heart is set on computer science or computational science, she should do methods. Honestly, she should probably do specialist, too. But if she just wants to do software engineering, it might be possible to avoid doing any more math.

"Main point is Bachelor Science does NOT require methods, whereas Bachelor of Computer Science does." <-- Ok so maybe she tries to get into Bachelor of Science and then transfers into a Software Engineering degree after a year or so.

3
bellalsOP98.55 ‖ chem tutor &gt;5yrs•

Thank you so much for your detailed reply!

2
SocraticMathTutor•

You are most welcome

2
donnellan0007•

Whilst the Bach science doesn’t have a methods requirement, will a computer science major have one?

2
bellalsOP98.55 ‖ chem tutor &gt;5yrs•

Good point! What I've gathered from the Monash website is that they require either:

  • 30 raw in VCE specialist maths, OR

  • pass MTH1020 with a mark of ≥60%

4
donnellan0007•

You should probably get her to put a lot more effort into maths and get her to do methods, as it will almost certainly be a prerequisite to having a chance at passing the MTH1020 test

4
bellalsOP98.55 ‖ chem tutor &gt;5yrs•

Yeah you're right. MTH1020 has the prereq of a 25 in methods or successful completion of MTH1010 (which essentially seems to be methods bridging, because people who have obtained a 25+ ss in methods are not permitted to take MTH1010)

3
Counter_Clockwise-99.00 atar•

please check the pinned post smh

1