I see people keep saying that Walt received

That Walt received the book (leaves of grass , the W.W book , omg s5 book) from Gale . Now, i feel like I've been a pretty adapt and paying attention closely but i can't seem to remember when this exchange took place. Im almost positive it's a case of people making things up in their mind to fill in the part of where Walt got the book but i thought i remembered Walt just having it when he moved back in in season 5.

Posted Sep 3, 2012, 4:32 PM UTC

04
[deleted]•

I don't recall a scene of Gale actually handing him the book, but we see Walt take it out of a box of things he took home from the superlab, smile and place it beside his bed.

2
DexterrrMorgan•

There was no exchange. We never saw a scene where Walt was given that book.

That is why people are saying the book was given to him by Gretchen. But as I've said in other threads, there is two major problems to this. Even if the writers reveal Gretchen's last name before marriage started with a B, or she referred to herself as "black" (since Shwartz = black in German) - you can't convince me that she would write both physically and stylistically similar to Gale, and would have also tied Walt to Walt Whitman.

It's too coincidental, and IMO just bad writing. Contrivance at its finest. So while I agree with you OP, we weren't physically shown Walt being given the book by Gale, all evidence leads to it being so. The fact that Gale quoted Walt Whitman in the lab, and Walt was mesmerized by Gale's reciting of his poem. The fact that Gale greatly admired Walt, and respected his ability and understanding of Chemistry as an art form.

This all leads to the book having been given to him by Gale at some point, off screen. Then you jut look at the fact that Gale's own handwriting in the journal was very similar (all caps, referring to Walt as W.W.)

1
gridmanOP•

Nah, although the Gretchen thing caught my eye and i thought about it for a second, that wasn't where i was aiming with this post. In some weird fantasy fan shit yeah maybe it would be Gretchen lol but i never really even considered it until i came here. Either way, all i wanted to clear up was that there was no scene with an actual exchange. I guess in my mind, i never really thought Gale gave it to him just because we weren't shown it happen. I sort of made up my own thoughts about how he got it (read: he just bought it) but all in all, it doesn't matter how he had acquired the book. It's clearly a reference to Gale "major Tom"

1
DexterrrMorgan•

My apologies then.

But you are correct, we did not get a scene that showed Gale giving him the book.

2