r/Tiki•
LetterD

I think i need two more bottles:

Currently own:

  • Plantation 3 star

  • Hampden Estate Single Jamaican Overproof

  • Diplomatico Mantuano dark

What would you add to this? Ive tried the link in the sidebar to the website that supposedly allows you to build your digital bar, and I find it extremely tedious.

EDIT: thank you for all the suggestions! I added a bottle of Don Q gold because it was the least expensive and im broke from Christmas shopping. So, NOW what do i need? ))

Posted Dec 16, 2022, 4:28 PM UTC · edited

425
Rancor418•

I currently have over 40 different rums for my Tiki bar but I will give you two that I think every tiki bar should have.

Plantation OTFD and Hamilton Zombie.

11
LetterDOP•

Thank you!

2
bigkinggorilla•

Why the zombie? I’ve been avoiding that one since I don’t know how utilitarian it is.

1
Rancor418•

Because it's easier for making Zombies, Cobra Fangs, and Jet Pilots if you are looking to add only two rums to your collection. A 34 Zombie called for three rums if I'm not mistaken, so your rum usage would be lower.

It's also really good.

1
bigkinggorilla•

I suppose for the purposes of making as many of the classic drinks as possible with the fewest bottles that makes sense.

How does it compare to the OFTD? Decent substitute or too different?

I’m almost out of that particular bottle and would definitely give the zombie blend (or the Grog blend) a try if they fill the same role well enough.

1
Rancor418•

Pulled this up after replying.

Beachbum Berry Site

1
hakupaku42•

A few options I can think of:

  • Hamilton 151 (instead of OFTD)
  • A Cuban/PR-style lightly aged rum (Don Q, maybe)
  • A lightly-aged Jamaican pot still that isn't overproof nor black (Rum Bar Gold, for example)
8

Extra points for the False Idol Hamilton 151 blend which has a bit of Jamaican rum mixed in with the Demerara rum for the regular 151 label

3
LetterDOP•

Thank you!

2
sevan06•

I would add Hamilton 86 and Denizen’s Merchant Reserve 8. Both of those are my workhorses. Anything that calls for aged rum will get Denizen’s 8 and of course Hamilton covers the demerara category. I have gone through Hamilton 86 the most. I don’t drink often but I’ve gone through two bottles of Hamilton in under a year. I also think you could use a demerara 151(Lemon Hart or Hamilton).

6
LetterDOP•

Thank you!

2
ratmonkey888•

I like smith and cross.

6
LetterDOP•

thank you! had one of them, and enjoyed it a lot.

2

Don Q Gold

Denizen Vatted Dark or Coruba

Clemént Canne Bleue (or any other 100-110 proof agricole blanc)

Barbancourt 3 Star

Hamilton 151

3
ChiefBobbert•

I feel like I always have Appleton signature and 12 on hand. They work horses and very good.

3
NoFalseModesty•

I'm less informed than some, but I keep El Dorado 12 on hand because it seems to work with everything. That, a Hamilton 86, a Jamaican rum, and maybe a black strap or 151 will work for a lot of drinks.

3
bigkinggorilla•

I’d say your best bet is to pick a couple of drinks you want to try and then go from there.

Much more efficient than adding random bottles and hoping they line up with what you want.

And I say that as someone who has bought more than a few bottles of rum and liqueur only to realize later that I didn’t really have a use for them.

Now that I’m playing around more with riffs on existing recipes, that stuff’s great to have. But if you’re still really only following others’ recipes - discovering what’s out there and what you do and don’t like - your wallet will appreciate you buying things you need rather than things others say you should have.

3
MsMargo•

Much more efficient than adding random bottles and hoping they line up with what you want.

This! The smartest way to do it.

3
LetterDOP•

Totally agree. Just looking to see what would link up nicely with what I own, or what hole needs to be filled.

2
blazentaze2000•

I find the Hampden, while very good, doesn’t bring the Funk like you would want from a Jamaican. I really love Smith and Cross for a mixing Jamaican. Some folks also swear by Dr Bird though when I bought a bottle it was a very different sort of funk than the sort of “haut gaut” over ripe banana flavour one may expect. It could have just been my taste buds.

2
LetterDOP•

Thank you! I find the Hampden pretty funky, as far as the three i own are. always looking for the funkiest

2
blazentaze2000•

I may have a different Hampden. Anyhow I can def recommend trying smith and cross and dr bird then!

2
Lledr•

I’d immediately head for Worthy Park 109. I would replace Diplomatico when it empties for El Dorado 12. Personally, my second addition would be a daily sipper - probably Bajan - but if you’re looking to mix then I’d go for a rhum agricole. Probably a Clément.

2
LetterDOP•

I am looking to mix, thank you. Not really a neat guy.

1
Lenfantscocktails•

Hamilton 151 and Appleton 12

2