r/DnD•
Raynor64

Amnesia backstory idea too sexist?

DMing

One of my players in a new campaign is playing a drow rogue with the spy variant of the criminal background. She works as a spy for a nobleman and decides she doesn't remember her childhood or anything before working for him.

I had an idea for a backstory that she is actually some sort of magic dagger under the effects of a true polymorph or wish spell to become a spy for the nobleman, explaining her amnesia and commitment to him, who is secretly the big bad. It would be a cool reveal that she's not a "real" person and I thought it was pretty interesting.

My only reservations are that I would basically be revealing that a female character is an object, obviously carrying heavily sexist connotations, and that I would be making an enormous choice for her character without asking. Do you guys think this would be a problem? How much permission do I need without spoiling the twist? Should I just abandon this backstory idea altogether?

Posted Dec 17, 2022, 1:20 AM UTC

066
JBloomf•

Take it up with her and see what she thinks. Sexist or not, and I’m not sure it is but that doesn’t matter here, I wouldn’t want the DM to decide that much of my character unless I explicitly left it up to them.

79
The_Emperor_Sloth•

Agreed. Whenever my dm wants something to happen with my backstory, they ask me. I know but my character doesn’t

20
Quantext609•

You're taking the word "objectify" too literally.

Objectification means to view someone or something in a purely utilitarian viewpoint. You don't see them as a person, but more of a tool to get what you want. While it's most commonly linked to the idea of sexual objectification, anything that causes a person to bend to the will of another without any views of their own can be seen as objectifying.

A character literally being an object is not objectification.

37
quuerdude•

Except they’re both literally an object and literally the property of another person.

-10
Darkestlight572•

Hello, regular far-leftists and feminist (though not a woman, so grain of salt of course)

Objectification is pretty close to how Mongoose described, though I think a more colloquial definition when used in terms of sexism, racism, transphobia, etc - would be: reducing someone to x quality, making you consider them as x instead of as a full human.

For example, considering a woman her sexual appeal and not her as a person.

In this plot, interestingly enough, her being having formerly been an object doesn't detract from the fact that she is now.. a person. So, I'd have to agree, the bigger "uh oh" is not telling your player.

100/100 the surprise is not worth making your player not trust you

12
HeftyMongoose9•

Everyone is literally an object:

https://www.google.com/search?q=define+object

a material thing that can be seen and touched.
a person or thing to which a specified action or feeling is directed.

And property is a legal designation. Whether or not the character is property depends on the laws of the fictional society, which were not specified by the OP.

https://www.google.com/search?q=define+objectification

the action of degrading someone to the status of a mere object.

Yes, the OP is taking "objectify" too literally. Being a literal object has nothing to do with objectification.

7
Sundaecide•

I would be making an enormous choice for her character without asking. Do you guys think this would be a problem?

I can see your issue, this isn't a story I would impose on a player but it is one I would work with if they brought it to me. It's a fundamental shift in how this player views their character.

How much permission do I need without spoiling the twist? Should I just abandon this backstory idea altogether?

Ask her about what she has in mind, what ideas she has and what things she definitely would not like. You can still surprise and subvert within those parameters - it's just a way of getting insight without giving the game away. I'd personally drop this one and see if you can find something in discussion with the player either from them directly or through a sense of what they're into that you can work with.

24
-metaphased-•

I understand that you're trying to avoid connotations here, but the plot hook has nothing to do with the character's sex. This plot hook is the same whether she's a he or undecided.

23
Nuada-Argetlam•

... how is that sexist?

17
PhantomSwagger•

I would basically be revealing that a female character is an object

5
Nuada-Argetlam•

you may be taking "objectify" a little too literally.

20
PhantomSwagger•

How so? I'm just pointing out the part in OP that answers your question.

1
Nuada-Argetlam•

oh- sorry, thought you were OP. my mistake!

1
ThePoorAristocrat•

But she isn't a female...its a dagger.

7
nabiscomb•

Lmao the media literacy of these jokers responding to you is adorable.

3
IIEarlGreyIIDM•

I would let them know that you have a cool idea involving their amnesia, but that you have concerns about doing so without their permission. Ask them if they would rather be involved in the process, or if they want to remain in the dark.

In my experience a lot, if not most, players would rather take the risk and keep it a secret. By just telling them outright without checking in with them first you could be taking away a really fun opportunity from them. If you are still concerned maybe ask them what topics they are sensitive about and see if any come even close to this scenario.

Overall I think it was a good catch to see this as literally objectifying someone. I think most of us are so caught up in a fantasy mindset that it wouldn't have even trigged any notice.

Maybe in the end even if you have to tell them everything it could still be a cool reveal for the rest of the party later.

14
Mactire404Druid•

I don't think this plot is inheritly sexist. It might as well have been a male character. And players are casting unseen servants all the time. Which is basically a similar thing as they have 'ownership' over that as well.

It makes for a very interesting hook as you now have a sentient dagger that the player will get invested in. The moment he or she becomes aware of this plot twisy he or she can choose to pursue to retain her form and become a free being. That way the character can get revenge on the BBG. As the other players will get invested as well it's likely they will help the spy.
In order to keep the plot twist I would not tell anything.
Interesting, I like it.

12
JakeEkissDM•

She works as a spy for a nobleman and decides she doesn't remember her childhood or anything before working for him.

Got it. Cool.

My only reservations are that I would basically be revealing that a female character is an object, obviously carrying heavily sexist connotations, and that I would be making an enormous choice for her character without asking. Do you guys think this would be a problem? How much permission do I need without spoiling the twist? Should I just abandon this backstory idea altogether?

Talk to the player about this idea. I know, you'll bristle at the notion, you'll think it ruins the surprise. And it does... for that player. But you have a whole table of players, and what you do if you include the player in this plan, and they go along with it, is they become a collaborator.

Now the surprise is for everyone else playing, and the surprise you used to have for that one player is now *suspense*. When will the other shoe drop? How? What will they do when they find out?

I don't think the issue here is so much that it's a sexist twist, obviously the notion is that the PC now has agency and can choose. It's the bad guy who views them as an object, but they have become more (it's a pretty standard plot regarding AI in fiction). The main issue in your game is that it's a very big twist for a player who probably needs to know in advance that it's coming. And if they aren't into it at all, go a different direction. Loads of other reasons for this to be the setup without that being the answer.

I would say the polymorph spell in this case is somehow special. The character might be, lore-wise a dagger, but don't hold them to the same rules that normal polymorphed creatures are (where they can be dispelled and turned back). They should be effectively, mechanically, the same as any PC. This is just their backstory.

10
waitbutwhatwhy•

I think the actual concern here is that you are making her character an object. And one basically created and controlled. Some people would think this cool, some people would feel like they’d be robbed of a whole lifetime of sentience and choice, their humanity (or drowity), and basically that their whole life is a lie/means less/is just part of a bigger plot by someone who sucks. For sure risky and would be best to try it suss out if something this drastic would vibe with them.

9

Umm what? How in the world is this sexist, this is pretty freaking cool if you ask me! That twist is awesome! I would ask her if she's alright with you including her in the main story and maybe tell her what it is without giving too much away.

8
SpicyDuckNugget•

FFS... No. Don't insert unecessary gender politics

6
Baalslegion07DM•

Right?! I dont see this as problematic at all in this sense. I think it is extremely problematic if we look at it from a player/DM communication standpoint. Why do so many people feel the need to ask Reddit before their own players? This DM should talk to their player about this backstory and ask them if they are fine with it. If they are nlt, than thats it. There is nothing sexist about this, it is taking the word objectification to such absurd degrees that it is laughable and I mean, even if you think about it in a sexist way, if you are concerned with it, why use it? I mean, if you as the DM, have a problem with this or think its problematic and have complete control over it, why even use it?! Its just baffling to me. So yeah, I agree, this is overthinking something simple.

4
SpicyDuckNugget•

☝️ Bingo

2
PhantomSwagger•

First, ask the player how confident they are in their own ability to maintain player knowledge separate from character knowledge. If they can't, at least tell them you are concerned your idea for a twist might potentially be problematic.

5
Kitchen_Laugh7735•

IMHO if a player writes a backstory with amnesia and no instructions on what happened beforehand, DM gets FREE REIGN. Lazy character creation means you take what you get. It sounds like an interesting story, OP.

1

Calling them lazy is just plain rude, this was discussed between them and it just seems like she wanted to try something cool. No need to put someone down like this.

3
PayDataPaladin•

That sounds like a cool NPC or a webcomic.

3
difficult-narwhal563DM•

uh..... I can't speak for the opinions of your players, but in my experience the whole "woman = object" is more about how others treat that character as a possession/something to be had. If your player work to flesh out the character and expand on them as a person rather than a temporary thing than it would be a good "rising from the ashes" like story that already exists. It definitely could be considered that you are towing the line, but as long as the work is put in to clarify that your player's character is their "own person" and not just a tool it should be fine (IN MY OPINION).

Of course, take this up with your player (if you can, amnesia-plots are difficult to do) and see what they think.

3
HeftyMongoose9•

It's not sexist. An object that's polymorphed into a person is still a person, and if she's being treated like a person then she's not being objectified. To objectify is to treat someone as a mere object, and not also as a person.

It sounds like a cool idea, but I definitely would check with the player about anything relating to their backstory. You'd be very much stepping on the player's toes if you make unilateral choices about their backstory. At the very least, I would ask them: "I've got a crazy idea for your back story. It's really wild, and you might not like it. Do you want to know, or do you want it to be a surprise?"

3
Guilty_Fee3161•

I sure hope you don't get dispelled...

3
1000thSonBard•

If your character were male, would it be sexist to men?

2
Its-From-Japan•

Unfortunately that's not how it works. Men have been the oppressors and users for so long that it's both an equal comparison. It would be like in the States if you revealed a human character of color was a slave the whole time, as opposed to a white human character being the slave. Two drastically differing experiences on either side. But i do think it's good that you're trying to look at this from a perspective of fairness and equality

-1†
1000thSonBard•

What you're describing isn't whether it's sexist or not, you're talking about whether it might be perceived as sexist. Those are two different things.

It isn't sexist, but some people would perceive it as sexist.

2
Its-From-Japan•

Truth is in perspective, isn't it? What you see is your truth. Now, that same concept/event may be seen by multiple perspectives and each one will have their truth to it. This situation isn't exactly objective. So there really can't be an undeniable truth. If it's sexist to an individual then it's sexist, but that doesn't mean everyone feels that way

-3
1000thSonBard•

Truth is in perspective, isn't it?

To an extent, on subjective matters. Not in the 'we're both right' angle you're going for

If it's sexist to an individual then it's sexist

Sexist things are sexist, got it.

2
Middle_Leg_2151•

false

2
Its-From-Japan•

False false

1
SkullRanger48•

I would talk to her about it first

2
VonWoosen•

You definitely need to let the player know you have ideas, please say ideas plural, about why the character has amnesia and need to know if the player trusts you enough to take liberties with it, or do they have ideas of their own? Essentially you're idea is taking someone who's soul was placed in a Dagger making it sentient, only to have the sentient item become alive. I think the concept is amazing and will be mentioning this to my DM as he LOVES sentient magic items. You'll need to flesh out the backstory you've already created, and could effectively combine something the player has in mind with yours. It is collaborative storytelling and if you create overlapping stories across multiple campaigns, this could be something that you return to, reference or allow to happen in your games.

2
Tormsskull•

You could go with this idea and let the PC slowly learn this fact after dropping a lot of hints. Once the big reveal happens, gauge the player's reaction or if needed, flat out ask them if they like it or not. If they like it, great, roll with it.

If they don't like it, turns out that NPC wanted the PC to BELIEVE this story, and reinforced it in many ways. But in truth, he was a terrible individual that kidnapped her early on and lied to her or tricked her into believing that she was actually a dagger, when instead the truth is (anything else you think the player will find more acceptable.)

2