School children creating their own spells...
Why is no one talking about this more? Schoolboy Snape is out here inventing a half dozen spells by age sixteen. This appears nowhere in the Hogwarts curriculum, at any age. The Marauders are making magical implements (the map), which again is not in the course work.
Assuming these four are absolute legends of wizarding talent, why aren't people fawning over this ability? You think Snape would pass up the opportunity to show off to a bunch of first years with some "use X when preparing this potion ingredient, a spell of my own inventing, which is far superior to Y in every conceivable regard..." humblebrag? Obviously the marauders would've kept the map more of a secret, but if these kids are becoming animagi and creating magical devices, you know they had some other jams they shared with their mates, and that nonsense is getting passed on as legend in the house, Frat-boy style. Some fourth year has gotta be a "House historian" whose job is to keep records and notes of all the dope stuff his classmates have done in the official house records. "Yeah, Pat, class of '87 invented an enchantment to keep your drinks the perfect temperature. Alex, class of '62 invented a way to pass party invitations without getting caught. Sam, class of '14 invented a quick garment modification spell to change hemlines and color of clothes for the night. These are the holy trinity of party house spells all third years learn before we throw a rager in Hogsmede..."
Assuming those four aren't light-years more advanced than others kids their age, but rather just top of their class, why aren't we seeing kids developing their own charms and jinxes in the books? Sure, the twins are making candy, but they always had more of a "we chose to imbue this treat with that trick" vibe, rather than "I invented a new spell, and a confection to put it in" vibe, as nobody in charge at school seemed overly impressed by this accomplishment. And how isn't Hermione didn't figure out a "flashlight under the blanket" spell that would illuminate her books, but light wouldn't go past the edge of the blanket to wake up the other girls in the dorm, because that seems like exactly the sort of thing she'd do once she found out spells could be invented, rather than learned. There's no way she was satisfied with the availability of spells taught in books, she'd find them all lacking in one ability or another. If she can repair glasses before a single formal lesson, you know she's modifying spells by year one, and inventing new ones by year two.
Posted Dec 17, 2022, 8:32 AM UTC