Worth repairing 2020 15" or putting it toward new 16"?

Advice

My old x360's mobo fried. I could repair it for about $700 (parts & labor), or put the money toward a new entry-level 16.

I use it for light multimedia / creative work (not enough to be worth a dGPU > battery) and am mostly wondering if the new 16" is enough of a quality of life upgrade to be worth $400, or if I should just bank it and upgrade in a few years instead. Battery, webcam, color accuracy / screen brightness, USB charging, and keyboard/touchpad quality are all priorities.

I use tablet mode for digital sheet music.

FWIW the specs on my old one are: 4Ki7-1165G7 cpu, IPS screen, 1tb NVME SSD, 72.9 whr battery

Posted Dec 19, 2022, 11:46 AM UTC

24
doc_55lk•

With a repair that expensive, I'd honestly just put that money toward buying a new laptop.

1
NSMVidia•

I second that. Additionally, I highly recommend the HP carepack because my 2020 spectre recently failed spontaneously from the same issue and it was covered under warranty with no deductible and no hassle.

They sent me a refurbished unit that feels and functions like New.

1
Fishwithadeagle•

I'm curious how the motherboard fried and if it is really fried. What are your symptoms?

For the spectre 16, I'm much more preferential to the older gen compared to the new gen. It just seems like they took a lot of the luxury away with the new models

1
wiseman121•

I'd get a few other opinions from repair centres regarding your current laptop. Somewhere that does board level repair may be able to solve it for much less than $700.

However I would not spend $700 on a repair. My best recommendation here if you need a new laptop is to not focus solely on the spectre. It's a great laptop but gather hardware requirements and get a few models in mind. I generally recommend anything hp spectre/envy, surface, razer, dell XPS or Lenovo ThinkPad to any of my friends. Just go for whatever is the best deal for what you need.

1