r/rpg•
atomant88

Favourite Race Selection for a Fantasy RPG?

Favourite Race Selection for a Fantasy RPG?

View Poll

Posted Dec 25, 2022, 11:28 AM UTC

939
Diovidius•

I like variety in my settings. Sometimes kitchen sink, sometimes a very specific set of races, sometimes only humans.

25
The-Silver-Orange•

I voted for human only. Because that was the closest option. But I actually don’t mind including any other races as long as it is only a few in each campaign. I generally don’t like the kitchen sink aesthetic, where anything goes.

24
chugtheboommeister•

Yeah i enjoy mork borg for this reason. I do enjoy customization. But thats where subclasses and jobs and origins and build can replace species

2
KPater•

Humans with one or two "weird races". Or full kitchen-sink.

Not a big fan of "beast races". For some reason this often gets paired with a type of fantasy I'm not too keen on. Too typical, and often too romantic (in the literary sense).

10
AlHazard33•

In Fantasy settings, I prefer them to be mostly humans, maybe with some really strange alien like creatures (like the Ailan Siddhat in our Dungeon World who are rather monstrous looking and behaving), or shapeshifters and werecreatures. But that's basically it.

If there are other species, they tend to be alien and strange. And ususally not for the players.

9
mcvos•

I voted Tolkien, but honestly, it depends on the setting. It's important that they're rooted in the setting, and aren't just some stat bonuses with pointy ears. In some settings, a completely different set of races makes more sense.

Fifty Fathoms, for example, wouldn't work with elves, dwarfs and halflings.

9
TheRealUprightManGuild Master•

I bet someone said that about Cyberpunk, but we have Rifts and Shadowrun and those were both big sellers!

2
CheesyCramch•

Bruh, at the time of my vote, are there really only 11 people who like beastfolk? Are y'all afraid of being labeled a furry, or do you really not want to be a sharkman?

Edit: saw the 79 "any and all" votes. We're cool.

7
Shreesh_Fuup•

Why be a human when you can Grung it up with the bois

3
Testeria_n•

I really like Narnia books style beast folk. But they are also Greco-roman and kitchen sink in part...

2
MidnightCreative•

Any and all, but I'd have them predominantly in their separate regions/countries/biomes. Obviously some travel, but maybe a Minotaur is a rare sight in a human city for example.

6
anderoScientist by day, GM by night•

I prefer to do a custom build for each game world.

I don't want to repeat the same thing over and over. I like novelty.
I might have one Tolkien style world, then one world focused on humans and angel/devil people, then a world with rat-folk, then humans only.

I don't think I would go "kitchen sink" unless I was going full cosmopolitan because I wouldn't be able to explore the sub-cultures since there would be too many. I would find that to be too irrelevant.

6

Gimme the weirdoes. If I'm playing high fantasy I want to play with the whole "Monsters as People and People as Monsters" thing. Give me the shark men, the insect dudes, etcetera.

4

Pick 4ish and build a world around that.

I hate kitchen sink, makes everything feel the same

Though 100% the Greco-roman beastfolk are my favorites out of these groups.

4
robbz78•

Yes, I think the poll is missing an option for "the mix of races the setting needs".

1
OhlookitsMatty•

No love for undead or constructs?

3

I like a wide variety, so long as they’re thematic. And ideally have more to their culture than “Ancient Mongolia but centaurs”. I know some rehashing is bound to happen, hard to find something truly new, but it shouldn’t be a carbon copy or caricature.

3
YeetThePig•

I try to make a point of every species getting at least two major and distinctly different cultural groups established in their descriptions to avoid cringy “every X does Y!” tropes.

2

Ahh yes, monocultures! That’s not even what what I was talking about but I absolutely would have if it had passed into my mind.

Or where they take a race, find the one thing different from human baseline then make the entire culture about that. Everything and everyone in an entire race lives their entire lives centered on the fact that they can talk to trees(as an example) and completely ignore all non tree based agriculture or crafting.

1
DreamsHorizons•

I personally wish satyr/faun were used more in fantasy games. They have a cool astetic, but people fail to use them as any more then that. In my head they form tribes where satyr are trained to be warriors and fauns being more magically talented.

2
xdanxlei•

If I already know them, they're not fantasy enough for me.

2
Tarilis•

Anime catgirls.

2
CHIM_Jim•

I like Lieber-inspired settings, and as a result prefer humans only for players, though demihumans may show up in some form or another.

2
SundayRabbit•

I've never thought about using Elemental themed Races based on the different kinds of Fairy races

2
Shreesh_Fuup•

I like my fantasy to go all out on how alien the races are. Not really a fan of "human but tall and with long ears," or those horrendous diet furry catgirls you see in bad isekai, but I can respect going full in on the big spiky lizardmen and weird fish creatures and alien jungle constructs made of clay and photosynthesis.

I can also respect going for a more grounded, human-only route, but I cannot stand half-assing it with dwarves and elves and halfing and fucking gnomes. Gnomes suck ass and nobody I know ever even remembers they exist.

1
YeetThePig•

That’s just what the Gnomes want, man! That’s how they getcha! They comin’ out the damn walls, man!

1
BuckyWuu•

My only concerns are the fluff around them and what I can do with them that are fun from a playstyle perspective and engaging in a narrative perspective. For example, I've played a Rouge Kobold that got booted off of an airship in transit and swore revenge on the crew, a Human Cleric of Ng (that's legitimately the gods' name) and ran him has a grandiose theatre kid that ran around like a reskinned doctor doom, as well as a Strix Thaumaturge (not only was i playing Disneys' Gargoyles [but wityh angel wings and WoW ears], I was someone that chucked a stupidly long pistol at people before magicing it back into my hand AND got to kill people through a combination of slapstick and bad puns)

1
Ashamed_Movie_1285•

I like greek but only sometimes

1