What makes HorizonXI's launch so important and should I get involved?

Hopefully this type of post is okay. Mods can shut it down if need be, just point me in the right direction for this type of question (the FFXI sub doesn't allow private server discussion).

I'm newish to FFXI. I had played back in '04 and I liked it, but it was a bit too complicated for my 10 year old brain so I fell off quickly. So now I'm back to playing retail and enjoying it, but this launch of HorizonXI has been all I've been seeing everywhere FFXI-related lately; Reddit disccusions, Twitch, etc. Seeing how active it is on stream has me interested (retail feels like a ghost town in comparison).

But the question is why is it so big? What makes it different from all these other private servers that have released over the years? I have seen a lot of people saying things along the lines of "this is our last chance." Just from the amount of discussion around it, this server just seems extremely important within the FFXI community. Is that implying that private servers are dying? And why are these private servers more worth playing to you than retail?

Posted Dec 26, 2022, 12:33 PM UTC

1961
CatchThrownExceptionLSB Developer (zach2good)•

This sort of thread should be fine, as long as it sticks to the facts and doesn't stray into the (very passionate and intense) private server population attacking each other for whatever reasons.

To me as an outside observer, horizon have done so well because of their PR machine. They've hyped, they've advertised, they've streamed, they've made art, they've set out road maps, they've answered questions, they've collected a lot of technical and non-technical staff, they've got high profile streamers hyping them, etc. All before the actual launch.

The majority of p.server players are chasing a nostalgia hit from the 'good old days' of FFXI, which is what horizon have promised to deliver and more. Promising to take their version of the game in a direction that seems to resonate with these players. Their goal isn't vague or undefined, so when they present progress towards it it makes it seem possible that they might achieve it.

On a technical level, they've launched at a really good time in terms of how the base software they're using is going. It's faster, stabler, more correct and more extensible than any time in the past, and has allowed them to launch and run with 700 people per process (a collection of zones) and just over 4000 people peak total, with little or no qualms. Its to be expected that they have added a series of custom systems and modifications to the base software that bring in some more instability, but on the whole, seems like the biggest and best p.server launch ever.

FFXI official retail is alive and well, despite what the p.server player base is saying about it. SE totally flubbed the 20th anniversary and didn't really do much, but that isn't a signal the game is circling the drain. There is a healthy player population as long as you're on one of the top 3 biggest servers. Still getting content updates 20 years later. We even got a new zone in the last update (but it was a reskin of an existing zone).

As for other pservers, they're doing well, there's a bunch that regularly pull hundreds of players every day, all promising slightly different experiences. Eden, Wings, Catseye and others are still very popular and probably aren't going anywhere anytime soon. Collaboration between private server devs is at an all-time high, and animosity/competition is at an all-time low.

It's kind of expected that the 4000 player peaks horizon is pulling in will stablize to something lower once people re-discover that classic ffxi is a massive difficult ball-ache thay doesn't respect player's time. But for now, congrats to horizon!

21

I'd also add in the ease of access. Private servers have been notoriously hard to install. Horizon is plug and play, you download a launcher from the website and install. Make an account and character on the website. Boom done. This has really opened up private xi to non-tech savy people.

18
Rinuko•

To be fair, catseye has a similar setup. But it sure is user friendly this way without having to patch pol

3

Your comment here. Is why Nasomi and other servers that have their own installer are larger populations. All the technical aspects to installing, transferring files, etc that come with some of the harder to install private servers is why their numbers are low. People don’t know how or want it now. I was installing a pvt server and in the instructions said to the effects of “move it from this drive to this file ya dingus” I gave up at that point.

3
Jimmayus•

To follow up in a different way, Horizon is the first server to really benefit from a couple of massive advancements in our understanding of a lot of combat mechanics. Stuff like magic hit rate, how monsters use tp, how their tp moves work, how monsters of various types get their various damage, all of that has advanced dramatically since 2020.

Now Eden has all that same stuff too, but Horizon gets it from the beginning instead of a sort of in media res type situation.

7
ka1ri•

It's a snowball effect at this point. Now that people are hearing "oh man the game I loved when I was a teen has a thriving a bustling server I can play on?" They are hopping on. When they hop on they realize that the experience is incredible. The admins there have done a fantastic job from day 1 launch going smoothly to them constantly banging out these little daily problems without a ton of issue.

8

Personally I think it’s a nostalgic factor, I play on another pvt server with many custom aspects, the first one being exp is x4 of retail, meaning instead of 50-100exp in Ronfure I get 400-500 it’s a quality of life server I play on, I played retail for 7 years. With these Era close servers I just don’t have that time to play anymore, I already after a few months have like 8 lv75’s and am happy about it. I did make a Horizon account and can see the love/care put into it but just won’t have the time to play at the retail grind

7
Ghost_Turtle•

Which server has the x4?

1

ffera.com it’s, Eras site. x4 exp, custom warps and nm hunts, like I said, quality of life insurance.. your time is cared about

1

Era would be nice if it didn't have 20 people online, 10 of those being dual-box alts

1

Sure the pop is “lower” but I’m fine with dualbox and major QoL. Chasing that nostalgia is fine and all but I don’t have 7 years to play XI again

1
GMJankin•

The biggest thing is, you can feel the Horizon Team cares about this project, also the fact it’s Era+ so they have removed/updated/changed things for the better, let’s not forget about the job Changes, making some jobs more wanted and balancing some jobs that needed it.

6
IlikeVidyagame•

For one, it's free. Retail is not free and has a few practically mandatory additions to your monthly fee such as the mog wardrobe which really irks me. I liked retail well enough but the magic is just sort of gone. Horizon is just hitting the nostalgia for me, it's slow paced and simple. The world is extremely dangerous to explore no matter what level you are which I love. Horizon specifically though has a very active staff, they are dedicated to fixing bugs, they made some minor job changes just to shake up the meta which I think it's great. The game is 20+ years old, it's OK to move some stats and abilities around to make up for the mistakes of the original devs.

4
Billybobjoethorton•

It's too popular which makes it hard to play. Every zone is overcrowded and hard to level.

4
Sakurya1•

Im loving every second of horizonxi I've been playing but that is something I agree on. Everywhere I go, either someone is there exp/farming or there will be people invading my camp any moment. It's a bit frustrating but I'm dealing with it.

6
Billybobjoethorton•

Yeah. I remember leveling in the old days ronfaure, la taine, dunes, and basically every zone was dangerous. Now you have practically every mob claimed and it loses that sense of danger.

I wanted to experience the dunes- quifim- kazaam, etc leveling progression again and the dangers that came along with it but I doubt I'll be able to for quite awhile.

Ffxi wasn't really meant to be this overpopulated.

3
SolugadOP•

How populated was this game back in the day? I'm seeing 4000+ on this server being brought up. Retail was probably half of that back then, right?

0
Rinuko•

I remember 2-4000 back in the 360 days but maybe not as crowded as this

2
Billybobjoethorton•

If I remembered correctly I still saw 3 to 4k. It's been way too long. The Japanese had a year head start so the population was more spread out. They also are on a different time zone so when we sleep they play.

I think also private server players tend to be more hardcore maybe so they are going to grind a lot longer.

Someone told me that the population on horizon is much bigger than what is shown but can't confirm. Think they said they heard it in the discord.

0
Paloom•

You just need to explore.. I've taken war to 30 and drg to 30 and only ran into 1 or 2 issues when It came to leveling.

2
Billybobjoethorton•

Soloing or in party?

1
Paloom•

Partying. Dunes, bubu, high lands, la theine, qufim, meriphated mountains, carpenters landing, batallia, pashhow, rolanberry, sauromuge I've partied in all of these locations. But for some reason most only party in the dunes and qufim

2
Billybobjoethorton•

are new mobs added in the zones you mentioned?

Ppl just mainly going by memories of retail. It's already hard to setup parties and having to travel around to look for viable monster camps is very time consuming.

Someone said that the new mobs added have their ilvl shown? That would make it easier but a lot of searching around until someone makes a newer guide.

Some ppl want that retail experience rather than just gaining xp as well.

1
Billybobjoethorton•

The camp spots in retail are perfectly designed imo. Like Quifim you would ring around the lake and then night time run as fast as you can to defulkt tower.

Kazaam entrance pulling mandys but you have to avoid the wandering high lvl goblins.

There are always placements of high level mobs by xp mobs that give it more a sense of danger. Sometimes NMS are spawned there as well.

1

I feel the opposite. It's popular which makes it so easy to play. Doing a mission? Run to where the mission is and team up with a few other people doing the same thing. Aggro a mob by accident you can't kill? Odds are someone higher level is around to take care of it for you. Need a party but only have an hour to play? /sea inv region and throw together a party quickly.

1
Billybobjoethorton•

Sounds like ffxiv.

You can get all those things done without it being overcrowded.

0

Ha yeah kinda like FFXIV, but the good parts of it. You can't just sit in your house, wait for a queue to pop, and then do the thing without talking to or strategizing with anyone.

And sure you CAN get it done without a populated server, but I find it more fun to see tons of people wherever I go.

1
Billybobjoethorton•

I think it ruins what ffxi is about. It's always been about the journey rather than the destination. For example having all mobs claimed and and players saving you every time ruins the feel of the journey. Going through jugner forest, batallia downs to jueno was a dangerous trek to get your chocobo license.

Camps were well designed to where there was a sense of danger while leveling.

Basically you are losing all the feel of the journey in favor of getting shit done which to me is what is wrong with modern mmos these days. Players have fomo and it's basically doing easy content to get loot.

1
RagingtonSteel•

I just want to know how to launch the game via Windower

2
Absvir•

Isn’t there a thread on the horizon discord that explains this? Maybe my memory is wrong

2
RagingtonSteel•

I’ll take a look, thanks mate

1
Richard_TM•

I personally don't know why people feel the need to use Windower for it. I use Windower for retail, but this is clearly designed with Ashita in mind and the custom launcher uses it. It's so simple that it's just easiest to use the launcher they built.

1
SolugadOP•

Wait how do you make ashita work with it?

1
Richard_TM•

It's built into the launcher, so you don't have to DO anything.

1
SolugadOP•

That's amazing!!

1
RagingtonSteel•

Because on Eden I had everything meticulously configured. Hours and hours and hours of tweaking/configuring to get it exactly how I wanted. I initially used Ashita until a few addons I really liked broke and made the switch over. I would love to just port it over directly and get going rather than reconfiguring and retweaking. You might say I could just not do that, but, yeah…I put too much work in and I’m really particular

0
Richard_TM•

Ashita v3 or v4?

And can you even use all your addons/plugins that you have for Eden? I'm sure the allowed addons lists are different.

1
MackTen•

Use their batch file to tell your registry that your game install is in your horizon folder (and use the other included one to swap it back to Eden afterwards). Then, just create a new Ashita profile for Horizon's server and you can use your Eden setup and have everything be identical to Eden (plugin-wise, etc). You have to run the batch files as an administrator.

1
RagingtonSteel•

You sir, are a scholar and a gentleman. I had an inkling that it had something to do with the batch file but didn't have time yesterday to mess around with it. Much appreciated.

1
Stivo887•

Windower when setup doesn’t even need a launcher. I click one icon on my desktop and the game is loaded and I play. Really easy setup for it on the discord, I get literally everything ashita has plus more, like xiv bar and infobar . I definitely prefer Windower.

0
Richard_TM•

But you can't update the game from Windower. The Horizon Launcher is DEFINITELY a smoother experience than launching via Windower.

1
Stivo887•

Windower loads off the horizon install. You load the horizon launcher once, it updates, and your windower install is updated. I can load both anytime i want to. Horizon launcher takes 2 clicks, windower takes 1.

0
ConniesCurse•

hype can be a bit of a snowball effect once you hit a critical mass, and I think Horizon definitely has done that which is why it has such high player numbers, which in turn makes the server more appealing to even more people. I'm not a long time ffxi player, but looking at private servers with 200-400 concurrent players is a lot less appealing than one that's fresh, with many times the player count of most other servers.

Idk a ton about ffxi specifically but one thing I do know from my time with wow classic is that private server communities tend to love the fresh start experience, and people are more likely to want to start investing time in a server that is new, fresh, and very populated.

Private server technology is also something that usually has to develop overtime and it takes quite a while to approach real accuracy. The tech behind this certainly seems like the best iteration yet from this community, maybe it broke through some intangible threshold where more outsiders are willing to check it out now?

Also generally I think the newer retail design for balance and stuff is just not very popular. Leveling with trusts or whatever is lame af. FFxi should be a game that relishes in it's """dated""" design, and play to those strengths instead of going for a more casual market, at least that's my opinion. FFxiv beats ffxi retail for a casual experience 10 out of 10 times.

This is like the difference between OSRS and Runescape 3, Retail Wow and Classic Wow. Retail FFxi and 75 era ffxi. Some people say that it's nostalgia that drives the communities for these older versions of MMOs, while that might be partly true these communities have repeatedly shown that that's not all they have up their sleeves, and these games can give experiences you can't find very often in gaming anymore.

Horizon kinda feels like ffxi's Nostalrius moment tbh, albiet maybe on a bit of a smaller scale. Honestly I think square could pull some great numbers and cash from official classic servers like blizzard did.

2
faverodefavero•

What's Horizon's XP ratio compared to original? 3~4x? Thanks.

1
AldrichTharakon•

The xp rates are the exact 1.0 WoTG era rates which mainly effects singleplayer xp (almost double of what you get on Eden).

1
Bizarro_0•

It sure doesn’t feel the same for party exp…. Either that or mob is scaled different… a lot of people feels that it’s off though.

0
Bizarro_0•

Mob distribution is kind of dumb imo…. A ton of low level mobs right by the gate and nothing through the map…. I ran around the dunes as level 10 and saw maybe 4 goblins total

0
nickandwolf•

ERA+ and as close to 2006 retail as possible.

My friend and I wanted to get into FFXI back in June and tried Wings but then we heard about some drama and decided to wait and see. As time moved on and drama evolved, we set our sights on Horizon XI. To hit a sweet spot at a new launch and have all the things we were looking for is awesome. ERA+ really gets me hyped to see the new jobs and how they handle horizontal progression. While it took us like 3.5 hours to start grinding at launch, it has been smooth and I've been trying real hard to help the FFXI novices as well. So far the community isn't bad and is fairly respectful.

1

As weird as it sounds, I feel like it's youtuber videos. If anyone on youtube wants to make an FF11 essay, they have to mention private servers and eventually they mention "the new one". There was probably a big player boost when Cat's Eye was the new one or Eden was the new one. Personally I think retail movement speed is awful and can't believe other people put up with that. (I guess they just don't know any better or want the "original experience" including the bads that come with that)

1