Anarchy is just where good normal people control society, right?

Some people say anarchy is chaos, other people say anarchy is utopia. It is pretty confusing

If anarchy society is safe and happy and controlled by normal everyday people, then I might be one of you guys cuz I fucking hate the fact that rich assholes get to control peoples lives

Posted Dec 29, 2022, 2:29 AM UTC

3214
Isra443•

Yes, we are against those 'rich assholes' but no, anarchy is not about good normal people controlling society. Anarchism is against control and hierarchy, that recognition of oppressive power is one of the core reasons about why we are different to say, Marxists or Communists.

Of course we want an anarchist 'society' (I have mixed feelings on that word but I want to use it so I don't end up being confusing) to be safe and happy, but that wouldn't be possible under hierarchy.

The idea that anarchy is chaos is a linguistic shift progenated by opposition to anarchy. It is quite literally taking our position (against control and hierarchy) and equating it to chaos. It plays into the fundamental discourse that a non archic 'society' is a bad one.

I don't think Anarchists are utiopians by and large, but we do of course believe anarchy is better than our current system.

37
eresh22•

It plays into the fundamental discourse that a non archic 'society' is a bad one.

This is always the part of authoritarian society that gets to me. Somehow, there's only one person out of 8b who is capable of making good choices, and that just happens to be the person currently in authority. Seriously??? The absurdity of this cracks me up.

14
GoldPast4546•

but how would you expect anarchy to be introduced to a community and how would you stop the first individuals to assert themselves taking over as new government

5
wlangstroth•

The way it’s handled in places like Christiania.

And yes, I know it’s not anarchist enough for reddit, but at least they’re giving it a go.

3
GoldPast4546•

no they are absolutely not, they continue to abide by the laws of denmark except for petty bullshit and the rules that would make anarchy fall flat are still in place. If they go too far denmark can still stomp them out.

1
eresh22•

Anarchy is normal people living their normal lives in ways that make sense to them and that are consensual. It's also you not giving a shit what that looks like for other people, so long as they've agreed (and continue to agree) to it. It doesn't mean there aren't any cities. It means the people there have agreed to some basic rules on how things work there and act in good faith to follow those rules.

Being anarchist means opposing conditions that create hierarchy. That means things like making sure through mutual aid that everyone's basic needs are met to the best of that society's ability because hierarchy very easily emerges when people are struggling to survive. (This includes medical care, food, shelter, water, electricity, some form of relaxation, etc.) It means searching yourself for beliefs like "father knows best" and shaking them off like fleas. It means looking honestly at your life for where you've abdicated responsibility for your choices to someone else. It means recognizing which parts of your life you should have control over and limiting your attempts to control to those things. It means disrupting anyone who is trying to exert control over those parts of your life.

11
piatsathunderhorn•

anarchy is about dismantling and preventing hierarchy, I personally believe the best way to do this is to build a society free of capitalism, money and class that uses a system of direct democracy that way we have no representatives, everyone has equal stake in running society and in equality.

7
pdxanarchist•

Nah I think you’re misunderstanding. No one is in control.

5
[deleted]•

There are lots of ways to be an anarchist. Some people are libertarian individualist anarchists, where there are no rules, everyone does what they want and lets others do likewise. I'm not sure if any philosophers actually argue for this. I also don't think that there have ever been societies structured like this, though some individuals and very small groups do follow a philosophy approximating this. I believe this form of anarchism is inherently unstable. It could devolve into chaos, or some form of "might makes right" heirarchy, but human nature means it’s more likely to devolve into the second option.

There are lots of different forms of democratic and community focused anarchism. Here there are rules, but they are not imposed from above, but agreed on by various forms of participatory democracy and consensus building. This is what is meant by a "horizontal power structure". This prevents one persons freedom from impinging on anothers. Rules are socially enforced, not by police and coercion. Individuals may even be given some limited powers and responsibilities, but these can be taken away quickly and easily. The concept of "mutual aid" is paramount. If you really don’t like the rules of that group, you are free to leave and find another group. This is how lots tribal societies are run, as is Rojava.

There is another reason why chaos might be persued by anarchists, which is to overturn or destabilise the authoritarian system we live in. Direct action, crime and saturnalian parties/festivals are all "chaotic" in a sense. They can help us see beyond current power structures and experience life without them.

4
zhivago6•

Power corrupts, so if good normal people find themselves in control over others they will abuse that power. While not a widely held idea, I think it's biological, humans act like any other social mammal and maximize their resources and the resources of the "in-group" while exploiting members of the "out-group". If you encounter a police officer, his in-group are other law enforcement, and you are part of his out-group.

3
Paczilla2Anarcho-Punk•

No

2
marker8050•

I'll be honest, I'm not a complete anarchist but i will work together to end any fascism or oppression.

1
_eudaimonos_•

The way I understand it (which may not be very well) is that anarchy opposes unjust hierarchies. David Graeber talks about this and there are many videos of him on YouTube talking about this (as well as many other anarchists).

An example he gives of a just hierarchy is one that is inherently self-equalizing like that of a student and teacher. That hierarchy’s purpose is for the teacher to elevate the student - by it’s nature the power a teacher has over a student is just in that way?

1
[deleted]•

Yea, I think heirarchies based on expertise are unavoidable and probably desirable. Some people will know more than me about particular subjects, I shouldn't get all Dunning-Kruger on them and assume my ideas are equal. I should listen to them and learn from them.

However, anarchist educators do/should try to do things differently from your standard teacher. They should acknowledge and be honest about the limits of their knowledge, that knowledge and learning should not be imposed and people are free to not listen, that imparting knowledge does not necessitate controlling behaviour, that learning is a non-linear and explorative process and knowledge is not compartmentalised into distinct subjects.

1