Why were you banned or what was your deleted comment?

Pinned

I’m trying to come up with some evidence as to the fishy goings on in the sub Reddit squaredcircle so if one of your comments was censored please tell us what is was.

I was banned from squaredcircle for posting ‘sort by controversial’ in the aew ratings thread. No warning, nothing. They said this was trolling when it was a reminder to myself.

At the moment there is no way to complain about a mod who is abusing his power, and any attempt to plead your case is muted, so hopefully as this community grows (it’s still early days) we get get a bit more info into what is going on over there and hopefully have a place to hold those accountable.

Posted Dec 30, 2022, 2:54 PM UTC

51184
b1ggayb1tch•

On the Dynamite ratings I said “better than expected™️” and I was banned for “trolling.” It’s amazing to see how those mods get so pussy hurt over a harmless joke. I wonder if I would get a ban if I said this under the Raw or Smackdown ratings

34
NemoPointOP•

Thanks for commenting, hopefully the first of many, as sad as that sounds. Yeah it seems when it comes to the wwe threads anything goes but for some reason they feel the need to censor anything that might hurt a billionaires feelings, or that’s how it seems anyway. I agree with people being banned for vile, racist, sexist stuff or things like that but for so many to be banned for stating their opinion, I just don’t get it. It seems in the mind of the mods anything but praise is trolling, very strange.

14
Tokzillu•

I was banned for commenting on their mod team's abuse and misuse of power.

They told me I was "ban evading" and they couldn't do anything about it. Reddit itself confirmed I am not flagged for ban evading and I'm not banned from any other subreddits. They implied I was a child when I pointed this out.

I have previously been temporarily banned for the following, that I remember off the top of my head.

  1. Saying I didn't believe the story of CM Punk and Ace Steel going ballistic for no reason, while the Elite were completely innocent and did literally nothing but walk through a door. (I also received several Redditcares messages over this)

  2. Saying that the Elite booking themselves to win the trios belts back immediately was indicative of Tony Khan not having control over his locker room.

  3. Saying I got an abundance of Redditcares abuse for a comment I made. (the comment was similar to #1)

  4. Commenting on a thread about the Elite and the ratings, and pointing out the best of seven series is constantly the lowest point in the quarter hours. (I'm actually a big fan of both teams involved, and just pointing out that I enjoyed it thus far.)

There was more times I caught temp bans, basically starting from the whole CM Punk drama. Before that, I was a frequent top karma commenter month after month. I only ran into these issues when I did not stick to the mods preferred story. They also said numerous insulting things to others while having their mod flairs hidden, which I pointed out in the comment (not even on their subreddit) that got me my permanent ban.

I doubt much will come of any of this, but that's my story. As requested. Good luck, friend.

28
NemoPointOP•

Thank you so much for your comment Tokzillu, I also received a temp ban for commenting on the live thread when Colt Cabana had his match with Jericho. I said it wouldn’t amount to anything and basically pointed out all the things according the Cm Punk he had done, not even my points. Again it was seen as trolling his ‘fan base’ which is laughable. It seems the mildest of comments are deleted and people banned, if it comes down to the mod in question having a difference of opinion or enjoying a different style of wrestling then it’s truly sad.

It’s early days, working on a disclaimer. Just think there is power in numbers and having evidence of all the nonsense bans in one place might get somebody’s attention, because right now you’re muted and that’s it. And most of the time you see a comment about someone being banned you think ‘well that sucks’ but then move on.

Once again thank you for your detailed comment, and as far as I can see none of things deserve a ban

9
Tokzillu•

gif

5
KilledByDeath•

I said something to the effect of the mods will delete any post on the front page that’s slightly critical of AEW. I was permanently banned for that. Then they deleted the thread it was posted in.

18
NemoPointOP•

Hey thanks for your comment. Again another example of over reacting. In no way is that a comment deserving of a ban. If it wasn’t true you’d like they’d be comfortable in leaving it up, but it seems to be truer than ever.

3
scarlet_lovah•

I asked why I was suspended, I was pointed to a thread that didn't seem to have anything wrong, I asked if they could explain why the post was against the rules or point me to something in the rules of the group, I was told I was arguing against the suspension. I wrote that the suspension was fine, I wanted to know how it violated the rules so that I didn't repeat the problem, and was looking for an explanation.

The next reply was something like "you're clearly arguing against being suspended, I don't have time for this" and boom permanent ban!

15
drkqwsr•

should be called SCModJerk

10
NemoPointOP•

Is this what you posted? And they banned you? Or is this a recommendation for the name of this sub Reddit? haha

1
drkqwsr•

a sub name suggestion, im just an scjerk enjoyer

4
NemoPointOP•

Unfortunately any sense of humour is seen as trolling, and I don’t want to give them any ammo when it comes to uncovering what’s going on over there. It is kinda perfect though

6
touch_me69420•

I pointed out that aew have more talent than TV time

7
NemoPointOP•

Hey, thanks for the comment. Again this is just an ‘opinion’ which last I read was okay to do on Reddit and if you really want to get into the facts 150+ talents + 3 hours of weekly tv, it’s not rocket science, this isn’t a made up idea or a comment made just rile anybody up, another example of them over reacting and in no way, shape or form should be deleted or banned.

Hopefully with more comments in the near future the sheer amount of instances like this will be made public and something can be done about it. Most of us had posted on SC for years with no issue, and if it turns out (which is becoming more and more apparent) that a mod or mods are abusing their power and doing this because they disagree with someone’s opinion, again I didn’t see that in the sub rules. Thanks again

1
Fusionman29•

My official permaban was for calling out the complete and total power abuse in the removal of ZFF but I had clearly been shadowbanned for months, I will edit in a bit noting what I think started it. I have also consistently seen people come into comments or seen redditcares sent if you suggest that the squared circle discord ran by the same mods is clearly used as a tool to decide what comments to brigade

EDIT: my “temp” ban that led to the shadow-ban was for calling Dave a bootlicker for his bullshit reporting on womens wrestling IN ZFF and a few weeks before I angrily went to the mods asking how the Shotzi video was acceptable under site or forum rules and was ignored entirely

7
NemoPointOP•

Hey thanks for your comment. The Reddit cares thing is a serious abuse of the function and insulting to those who actually need it. The reason people don’t call out the mods more is exactly for this reason, it seems any mention of them maybe being more open with the posters is given a ban. Surely a SC that’s ran properly is best for everyone, if someone breaks a rule a PM reminding them to read the rules is surely better than just perma banning someone, it seems like there is no leeway and the power has gone to some of their heads, which has always been a problem but surely those higher up should start noticing a trend and act so one person doesn’t spoil the entire sub Reddit.

2
Great_Deer88•

Is there something that can be against the SC Mods?

5
NemoPointOP•

I don’t know if you missed a word and are asking is there something that can be against the SC mods?

But if you were, that’s going to be the point of this sub and the mission statement. Many of us have posted for years on SC without issue but recently the protection of anything anti aew, or even tame opinions or jokes are being subject to a ban and that’s not right. If something is going on with the mod team over there, if it’s one or two bad apples, the aim is to find out because while SC has its problems I think it’s brought on by sensitivity of some mods and them actually creating the problems and toxicity they claim to be trying to stop, and it’s still the most popular sub Reddit, to be banned for a sentence or even for no reason as someone else said isn’t right either.

It’s not a witch hunt, but hopefully with this being the first stage, evidence gathering, we can discover a pattern as to who and why this is happening and the reasons behind it and if Reddit agrees or disagrees with the direction or if they agree it’s not being run to the standards the most popular wrestling sub should be, because I will be taking this to the top, or as high as I can get it. If there is no wrong doing they have nothing to worry about and would welcome an investigation.

So if you were banned or a comment was deleted tell us your story. Or even if you weren’t join up and recommend us to others. The first period will be slow but a journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step and hopefully something can be done.

5
Great_Deer88•

Yes you’re correct I missed a word, sorry. I wanted to ask if there is something that can be DONE(missed this word, my bad) against the mods via appropriate actions.

No i haven’t been banned(yet) as I stopped commenting there after the CM Punk fiasco because that was the time period after which the mods have been super aggro

3
NemoPointOP•

No worries, I do that too sometimes, my brain moves faster than my fingers can type.

The punk situation seems to be the start of a lot of things over there, it’s seems to me the mod team are very pro elite, which is totally fine but shouldn’t be they should join the fight and try to create a narrative within SC. Banning or censoring people who have a difference of opinion on the entire situation. I don’t know if it’s loyalty to the brand or something else entirely that’s another of the aims. To try and find out why they’re allowed run the most popular wrestling sub Reddit this way, it’s not their sub, it’s the people’s sub, they’re mods and should only step in when someone has broken the rules. Stopping people posting racist or sexist things or bullying etc which is their job they chose to do. They can’t start thinking everything isn’t praise is bad faith arguing or trolling because that’s their interpretation. Reddit is so weird you can read the same comment in your head in a soft voice and the comment seem fine but then imagine it being shouted by an angry person and it can take on a whole other meaning, but these mods should be experienced enough to deal with that type of thing and not let their personal feelings get in the way of what they’re meant to be doing.

The evidence will speak for itself and a favourite quote of mine is ‘innocence has nothing to fear’ but there is already mounting evidence of a pro- aew bias and censorship of anything questioning the booking decisions, tame jokes, lame jokes, liking a different wrestler than them. The goal is to go above their heads and there be an investigation by a Reddit team and ideally the bad apples be removed from the mod team and all the unjust bans be reversed, it’s a big ask and it’ll take time but hopefully this is the start of that.

3
Great_Deer88•

Well you have summed it up quite nicely. Earlier things were-for a lack of a better word- subtle when we could see the pro AEW bias. More aew posts being pinned, WWE pinned posts that had 150+ comments being unpinned to pin some choco pro or whatever apartment wrestling( not hating on any form of wrestling) the mods are into that gets minimum engagement. Like there is no logical explanation to pin the type of post that gets the least amount of comments and engagement as it totally defeats the purpose of pinning posts on reddit.

But then came the CM Punk vs Elite “real shoot fight”(or whatever fancy lingo the mods there use) and then it became so crystal clear of what is going on there. Even sensible pro aew fans started pointing out how the mods are building a narrative there by removing, pinning or banning posts and users in order to paint whatever picture they wanted that would support their favourite company and wrestlers.

People in SC have been shitting on WWE and Vince since YEARS but no mod did anything about it. Hell, people have compared vince to actual criminals and wished he was dead while the mods didn’t do anything about it and acted to be innocent passersby.

In the latest AEW ratings post which was posted like a day ago, the mods didn’t reply to the most upvoted comments there politely asking the mods to explain what warrants a comment removal and what doesn’t but were replying to downvoted comments that were bootlicking them and parroting pro aew and pro mod stances. It’s just a messed up situation. Earlier the excuse that mods were coming up to run away from actively answering to people was-“we have a life too!” But now they have even stopped with that pathetic excuse because it’s clear they kinda don’t, considering the hours they spend in carefully crafting and handpicking posts and comments that they want to stay up at top and removing those that they don’t want to be seen by anyone.

For what it’s worth, one good thing out of this entire mess is that now even the Redditors there are waking up and asking questions. It’s only a matter of time when the facade comes off and the entire mod team has to either change or nuke the sub or something because more and more people are gonna question.

5
whiskerbiscuit2•

Banned for this comment saying WWE didn’t owe anyone a job for life

https://www.reddit.com/r/SquaredCircle/comments/ozuikr/tony_deppen_i_dont_comment_a_lot_about_wwe/h82ucyq/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3

Apparently I’d already been warned about “hate speech” when I got a 3 day ban for this comment comparing Nick Gage and Jackson Ryker

https://www.reddit.com/r/SquaredCircle/comments/oudbxo/zero_fucks_friday_0730/h734pnv/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3

I’ve made several appeals to get the ban lifted with no success. Also the “warnings” and bans all started around the same time I was posting more and more on SCJerk.

5
Blueandigo•

I got permanently banned and this was after not posting for almost 2 weeks. So I have no idea why I was banned.

4
NemoPointOP•

Hey thanks for leaving a comment. This seems to be a recurring thing I’ve heard from a few people. It seems to me, or it’s the only thing I can think of - that if you post in other places and they read your post history then you’ll be banned from SC, which literally makes no sense as it’s nothing to do with them. I think anyone who posts on SCJerk or a few others get flagged, and they just wait until they can come up with something to ban you.

Again banning people because they enjoy a difference style of wrestling is not part of the rules and the people doing it should be held accountable. Hopefully with more comments like this a thread will appear as to how, who and why this is happening and hopefully for it to stop. Thanks again.

4
Blueandigo•

No doubt. I'm convinced the mods there are teenagers.

3
kingajeezy•

I made a comment on the Vince wants to come back thread to the affect of “I love the entertainment he’s provided me, but he should probably stay away.” Someone said I love rapists and I simply responded that these are accusations “the he raped a former referee” for a long time, and I’d feel a lot differently if he were charged. I got banned for that comment, and no mod would actually answer me why. Downvote if you think it’s controversial, which I admit it is, but it’s certainly not banworthy

4
NemoPointOP•

The whole point of a sub Reddit is to discuss things surely. This topic is obviously going to be very sensitive for a lot of people, and rightly so but until it’s a record of fact like you said you and a lot of other people would change their opinions on it but once again another comment which is nowhere near being a ban. And once again the usual thread of trying to communicate with the mod in question and either being ignored or shown a rule which is down to interpretation, not what mood the mod is in that day. Thank you for your contribution, hopefully the more we get the more notice will be taken, as I’m working on avenues at the moment but still waiting for the community to grow. The more people they ban the more will come here to show something fishy is going on over there and it’s not being modded correctly.

Edit - also the fact someone replied to your comment and you were banned for replying is another common thing that seems to be happening over there

1
kingajeezy•

This wasn’t my first perma ban. I previously got banned in September 2021 for an unbelievably tame comment (it wasn’t “civil” and I was able to message a mod and have it reviewed, which resulted in my unban. Unfortunately, that mod would not respond to PM’s asking for clarification, because I clearly didn’t break an actual rule.

2
NemoPointOP•

That’s the thing, I understand that being a mod is a hard job, really time consuming and a lot of red tape etc but being able to appeal or the fact they mute people and there is no way to discuss it isn’t how you run a sub Reddit. Another common thread is them goading people in the mod chat and people getting angry, almost so they have justification for the original ban. Basically the message being put out is the mods word is law and you can’t even defend yourself if you think there has been a mistake.

A deleted comment I had from the nxt live thread was when they played a short video re-introducing Tyler Bate I think it was, I basically said something along the lines of - it’s good they did this to show new fans who is he and what he can do, and older fans a chance to remind themselves, take note Tony Khan! / it was because earlier that week there had been a debut in aew and hardly anybody knew the person or the history. The comment was deleted and I was told ‘stop this stupid console war’ the fact that they thought it was important to delete this comment and make sure TKs feelings weren’t hurt is bonkers. In the aew threads there is a lot of mentions of wwe, as it should be they are in a wrestling war at the moment. But the fact you can’t mention another company in a live thread again is them taking it too far.

At least there seems to be one mod there that took the appeal on board, I’m not sure if it’s one or two bad apples or if it’s a site wide type thing but hopefully we get to the bottom of it

2