ComprehensiveOwl9727

u/ComprehensiveOwl9727


r/expedition33•

This community posts dissertation length posts about who bears responsibility for the fate of the canvas, yet Esquie, the lovable clown, this sly creature of deception, is just as culpable for the tragic outcome of this story as Aline, Renoir, Verso, and Alicia.

He knows literally everything that has happened in the canvas. Monoco calls him the most powerful creature in the canvas. He knows Sciel’s story, knows the Dessendres, knows painted Verso, knows everything! Yet he shares exactly 0 of this vital knowledge with the team until it is far too late. Just a few tidbits during Act 1 would have been enough to get Lune on the right track! But this vile trickster holds his cards close to his

49472

r/expedition33•

I don’t want a 3rd ending.

I don’t want a sequel expanding the story of the writers v painters.

I don’t need DLC (except for maybe making the endless tower more endless).

I don’t want these things unless Sandfall had them planned from the beginning, or has an idea on how to expand the world that makes them as equally excited and passionate as the original idea.

Not every story needs a sequel, not every mystery needs an explanation. We fall in love with characters and worlds, so we want to cling to them, but if we don’t let them go we run the risk of seeing them warped and ruined with time and overexposure.

Sandfall can do what they want. It’s their canvas. But let’s learn from the

1.8K401

r/expedition33•

Full spoilers ahead obviously.

The game is always about the Dessendres.

Open to a friendly debate in the spirit of the Grandis. There have been many posts about the games narrative suddenly shifting to the Dessendre family in Act 3 and somehow shelving the characters of Lumiere. I want to lay out the argument for why this isn’t an accurate reading of the plot points that are shown in game.

For one, we are invited to look at alternate possibilities in this universe from the very beginning. Sophie most obviously invites us to consider the Paintress’ perspective and the possibility she is caught in a cycle, but even further, Lune acknowledges how little is known about the outcome of previ

42

r/expedition33•

Teenage Girl with dissociative identity disorder kills both her parents and enslaves her dead brother.

Man thinks he’s the main character, forgets to put on plot armor.

Overachieving perfectionist loner finally makes friends, immediately dies (twice).

Father with a foot fetish goes on an adventure with his son. There’s a lot of fighting. His son dies.

Grieving widow has a fling with smoldering hot man over twice her age. Comes to regret it.

Husband and wife have bitter, years long, argument over wife’s crafting hobby.

2012

r/expedition33•

Greetings all dads, future dads, and those who aspire to dad like humor. Let us show Renoir who the real papa is by overwhelming him with utterly terrible jokes until he can’t help but leave the canvas in horror. A few initial contributions:

Why did Verso send Esquie to timeout?

!Esquie was too winey!<

What did the Nevron say after Maelle beat it over the head with her baguette?

!that was a real pain!<

How does Verso flirt with the ladies?

!his smoulder!<

What else you got!?!?

84

r/expedition33•

I’ve been pondering a frequently asked question in many of the discussions about the endings and overall narrative. In essence the question is: “why do we get to know the people of Lumiere, and in particular the expedition so closely if the game just discards them in Act 3?”

Ive landed on, at least for me, a meta-narrative and symbolic reason for this. This isn’t to say that you have to like this decision by the developers, it’s simply my own reading of this particular aspect of the story. Take it for whatever it’s worth to you.

My reading is this: Lumiere and Gustave, Lune, and Sciel are characterized and then killed or sidelined in order to force the player to personally experience the

12

r/expedition33•

The longer I participate in this community the more it becomes clear that many of us are, through ignorance or malice, committing a grave atrocity. Too many of us stand idly by as a thriving civilization is erased from history.

I’m referring of course to the Grandis.

How many of you have only ever mentioned gestrals and Esquie (and maybe François) when discussing the inhabitants of the canvas? Where are the demands for a Grandis plushy? Or fan art of the Grandis Merchant? Where are the 3D printed Grandis figures? The Grandis poetry appreciation threads?

Sandfall itself is guilty of participating in this heinous gommage. Why isn’t there a Grandis traveling companion? There’s no “Dark Gra

52540

r/expedition33•

TW for discussion of suicide in the real world.

I want to focus on what I find to be a troubling aspect of some conversations around Verso's motivations as a mirror to our own understanding of suicide and how to help individuals in the real world who experience suicidal thoughts. This post is not about which ending I prefer or about whether or not the people of Lumiere are real or how happy/not happy Maelle's ending is or any of the other most common debates.

For background, I have worked with suicidal individuals as part of my career for over a decade, and now actively train others to have effective conversations about suicide. Unfortunately, I have found many reactions to Verso's plight

581262

r/expedition33•

An open question I’ve been considering. What understanding do the people (in canvas) of Lumiere have of broader history? Presumably the real Lumiere has an entire world history, close enough in parallel to our own to have the Eiffel Tower and different enough to have magic systems.

When Aline paints Lumiere did she implant this knowledge? What did she do with obvious contradictions between painted Lumiere and real Lumiere? Gestrals and Grandis don’t exist outside of the canvas and I assume the geography of the canvas is nothing like the real world.

Let’s say you’re a resident of Lumiere who is painted into existence by Aline as a 30 something year old prior to the fracture. What are your

35

r/expedition33•

One of these is not like the others…

Verso- I will elegantly strike with my weapon and give myself a second life

Sciel- I will rupture your soul with dark magic

Lune- I will tear the fabric of reality to rain down elemental fury

Maelle- I will entirely erase you from existence

Monoco: BONK

50

r/expedition33•

Stepping back from some of the more detailed debates about the ending, the lyrics of Une Vie À T’aimer are absolutely gut wrenching. I personally have never experienced the loss of a child, but I have at certain points in my life, talked extensively with people who have, and Aline’s lyrics in the song reflect this utter desperation and despair that I’m not sure there are full words to express.

Renoir’s also, the despair watching his wife and love (no where does the game imply that they don’t love each other) fade into oblivion over the grief that he himself also carries.

Aline: “Stop loving me!!!l

Renoir: “I will love you forever”

Aline: “I will paint forever!!!”

Renoir: “Stop Painti

10

r/expedition33•

Anyone else feel like you’re back in high school or college literature class with all these ending posts? I haven’t thought about terms like “death of the author” or the elements of high tragedy in a long time, but here I am asking chatGPT about the similarities and differences among Greek, Shakespearean and French tragedy and looking up plot details from plays I read once in high school and only have a small memory of. It’s been a long time since a story pulled me in like this, and I know that’s true for many of you.

02

r/expedition33•

Part of the joy of participating in art is being able to discuss with others, so I'm going to add my own small voice to the chorus of us who have thoughts about this incredible story. I finished Act III several days ago viewed both endings, and have been reflecting on the implications since then. These are my reflections. I come into these reflections with the assumption that the developers wrote everything in the story on purpose. They didn't forget what they were doing in the transition from Act II to Act III and the choices that are presented to the player (and those that are not) are integral to understanding the overall themes of the story that the developers are trying to tell.

The en

201


r/avowed•

I’m going to sprain my shoulder if I see one more bleste nimdut posting about how Marius is their least favorite companion. He’s easily the most in touch with reality of any of the companions. Kai is hung up on second chances (when he’s actually on his 9th or 10th chance), Giatta obsesses over living up to her tree parents, and Yatzli somehow can’t decide between 2 opportunities of a lifetime or riding off into retirement with her lover without asking an envoy she met a few days/weeks ago for advice.

Right…Meanwhile Marius is over here making sure everyone stays alive, handing out herbal remedies, making sure Kai’s bad habits don’t get everyone killed, and mostly advocating for common sens

14337