Nat20CritHit

u/Nat20CritHit



r/Christianity•

Non-Christian here. I was having a discussion with a Christian and they started talking about testimony of/from God. I wanted to put a pause there because in order to even claim God gave testimony about anything we would first need to demonstrate a god exists in order to give testimony. They said we don't need to do that.

I understand it's often said that no one can really prove or disprove a god exists (using "prove" colloquially), but is it common practice to just skip that step and proceed with claims about what god said and that what is said is accurately portrayed and true? It seems to me that demonstrating the thing exists is an important first step.

546

r/SWORDS•

Anybody here have experience with Luna Tech products? I'm looking at picking up their Dave Young survival system but the reviews are minimal. Any feedback would be appreciated.

21

r/AITAH•

For context, my wife had her tubes removed a number of years ago so the chances of her getting pregnant are slim to none. We were talking today and the topic came up with being done with having kids but, even if she did somehow end up pregnant, it's a good thing that we lived in a state where abortion was still legal.

I agree that it's great that she still has the right to choose, and I understand that it's her choice to make, I just don't want to know about it. She was upset by this because it means that I wouldn't be there to support her emotionally or drive her to/from the clinic if needed. Am I the AH for wanting to remain ignorant of something that I ultimately don't have any right to

110

r/atheism•

I was having a discussion in another thread and it eventually progressed to the claim of God being perfectly just. I tried asking u/Elai_Blackfish if drowning newborns is just but they refused to provide a direct answer for some reason. They suggested I ask on r/philosophy but I wasn't sure if that would be an appropriate sub.

So, I came here to get the perspective of non-believers. Is drowning newborns a just act?

114

r/DebateAnAtheist•

Hopefully I got the right sub for this. There was a post made in another sub asking how to debate better defending their faith. One of the responses included "no amount of proof will ever convince an unbeliever." Would this be considered the logical fallacy poisoning the well?

As I understand it, poisoning the well is when adverse information about a target is preemptively presented to an audience with the intent of discrediting a party's position. I believe their comment falls under that category but the other person believes the claim is not fallacious. Thoughts?

37292


r/atheism•

I was scrolling through FB and one of my (VERY religious) friends' kids lost a tooth. As I was reading the comments between her and another person about the tooth fairy, she said "oh he 100% knows it’s not real he’s always known that. Same with santa and all the other holiday characters, but we agreed he can still participate in the tradition and fun without believing in it." The irony behind it was just too much.

An internal debate soon followed and I figured it best not to rock the boat but it's crazy to see this level of disconnect in an otherwise intelligent and respectable person. Anybody else get blasted by a moment of "wait, did you just...do you not see...?"

6019