Zenographer

u/Zenographer


r/Stoicism•

I've been reading Bertrand Russell's History of Western Philosophy, a great book. He says some interesting things about Stoicism, some of which I'll quote here. It seems far from how people think of Stoicism now, and makes me wonder if anyone now really counts as a Stoic in the original sense of the idea. I also wonder if close students of Stoicism think this account is fair.

The main doctrines to which the school remained constant throughout are concerned with cosmic determinism and human freedom. Zeno believed that there is no such thing as chance, and that the course of nature is rigidly determined by natural laws. Originally there was only fire; then the other elements--air, water, ear

912

r/Stoicism•

There have been a number of threads on this board lately about the so-called dichotomy of control. I write to seek some clarification and discussion.

Some take the position (as far as I can tell) that in the Stoic view, the only thing “up to us” is how we handle impressions and whether we think about things clearly. On this view, it’s a mistake to say that Stoicism tells us to distinguish carefully between the choices we make about what to do (which are up to us at least sometimes), and choices that others make and other things in the world that we don’t control at all. All this is (the criticism goes) a pop psychology distinction that is foreign to Stoicism.

I don’t really understand

618

You've reached the end of this feed.